Should Kurt Angle return to the WWE *title edited due to being misleading*

[steveom07]

The title of the thread may be slightly misleading. But what i wanted to ask was, would you be happy if Angle were to return to WWE and who would you like to see him fued with if he did return.

Angle is arguably the greatest wrestler in the world and his mic skills are also top class.

He's had some of the most entertaining fueds in WWE history and some of the greatest matches ever.

I would like him to return to WWE and fued with Shemaus or Orton.

I stopped watching wrestling between 2005-2008/9 and dont know if Orton and Angle ever fueded but would love to see it.

Also another HHH and Angle fued would be immense.

What are you're thoughts?

 

[It's Damn Real!]

Oh dude, come on with this thread title. Such a cheap ploy to get users to click on your poll. Mods can we get that changed?

As for the thread itself, no, I don't want to see him return to the WWE, because I think he's fantastic doing what he's doing with TNA. Why return to the WWE, so he can be inundated with "YOU SUCK!" chants the moment his music hits again? No thank you.

He's the face of TNA – sorry AJ – and has been since his debut. He's the one guy I'd hold onto like a death grip if I were running TNA, and seeing him come back to feud with guys like Orton or Sheamus would be be far too dull of an angle(s) to what he's been working with in TNA over the last four years.

He's spent the last four years reinventing himself to become the greatest wrestler in the world, and I honestly believe he's nothing short of it. Returning to the WWE would be a step backwards for him, IMO.

 

[Ferbian]

While I don't particularly care who he would return to feud with if he decided to return, I would definitely welcome him back at least.

I've always liked Kurt, he's been great in both TNA and WWE, while his character were more serious in TNA, which helped my liking of him because I got another look on him.

But I don't think that Kurt Angle will return to WWE, he's getting older, he's 41, and has been enjoying the past few years with a lighter schedule, something that he could most likely never get with WWE, unless he was truly regarded as one of the top guys, which I also doubt he will, WWE would put him in the main event, because of his past history with the main event, but not as champion anytime soon.

Kurt Angle will most likely stay with TNA, being one of the top dogs there, something he could very well be in WWE as well, but not in terms of TNA, he's TNA's Triple H in terms of "the man", instead of what will be WWE as just another main event player.

 

[klunderbunker]

If he goes to WWE, TNA is in real trouble. Angle is one of the few consistently awesome workers and characters in TNA. I think of him like the Radicalz in old school WCW. As long as they had them, there was a legitimacy to the company as they could point to those guys and say top that. TNA can point to Kurt Angle and say we have one of if not the best in the world and it's a great way to stop criticisms. Angle going back to the WWE would take that away, as he's the most legitimate guy TNA has and his debut was EPIC. It was one of the top moments in TNA history and to me was far better than Hogan's debut. It was a guy that was still at the top of his game jumping ship. If that goes the other way with him going back to WWE, it's like saying TNA isn't where the top guys want to be, but WWE is. As much as Angle has ranted against WWE, it would mean that the hell that Angle described it as is better than TNA. That's just bad.

 

[It's Damn Real!]

Like Ferbian noted, just to add to this – Angle has noted repeatedly that he has no desire to return to the WWE, and even went as far as to say so on PPV's and iMPACT! on more than one occasion.

He said he's still in good graces with Vince and that there's no bad blood there anymore, but that he also came to TNA to make them a contender and that he wasn't leaving until they were one, so to reitterate, the likelihood of him ever returning is very, very slim I'd imagine.

 

[Ferbian]

Like Ferbian noted, just to add to this – Angle has noted repeatedly that he has no desire to return to the WWE, and even went as far as to say so on PPV's and iMPACT! on more than one occasion.

Exactly my point, while on those occasions Kurt could have very well been scripted to say those things, I believe I've heard him in a shoot interview saying he had no interest in returning to WWE, while it's a shame cause Kurt was a great talent, a talent I would love to see in WWE again, I respect Kurt's choices to wanting a lighter schedule.

He said he's still in good graces with Vince and that there's no bad blood there anymore, but that he also came to TNA to make them a contender and that he wasn't leaving until they were one, so to reitterate, the likelihood of him ever returning is very, very slim I'd imagine.

While this won't be a bashing comment towards TNA, more than just by assumption and looks right now, the fact that Kurt said he'd make them a contender and not leave until, means he'll never leave, because while TNA could very well become a contender, the last couple of months shows nothing of it, and WWE's improved product is not helping the progress.

 

[airvar]

Kurt Fits into TNA.. Sure he would have some great feuds and put on classic matchs against some of the newer guys in WWE, but he honestly is a better fit in TNA right now, no reason to want to see him back.. All he would do in the WWE is clog up an already crowded Main Event/ Upper-Mid card scene and probably halt the push of some of these younger stars ( If Kurt Angle is there he has to have TV time meaning somebody Has to get less).

Kurt was great in the WWE, He is just as good in TNA, and he fits better there. Sure it would be nice to see him come back and feud with a few people, but the "new " feud opportunitys just aren't worth loosing him in TNA.

 

[It's Damn Real!]

Exactly my point, while on those occasions Kurt could have very well been scripted to say those things, I believe I've heard him in a shoot interview saying he had no interest in returning to WWE, while it's a shame cause Kurt was a great talent, a talent I would love to see in WWE again, I respect Kurt's choices to wanting a lighter schedule.

But scripted or not, it was his general sentiments from day one – albeit they were much more vehement at his debut.

While this won't be a bashing comment towards TNA, more than just by assumption and looks right now, the fact that Kurt said he'd make them a contender and not leave until, means he'll never leave, because while TNA could very well become a contender, the last couple of months shows nothing of it, and WWE's improved product is not helping the progress.

Which is just yet another reason why it's kind of absurd to be discussing the idea he'd ever do so in the first place.

I honestly think he's vested interest in TNA, and that can be found no more than in his recent decision to remove himself from the TNA Top-10 rankings system entirely – choosing instead to face each one of those contenders as a means to prove his worth for having seeded #2 to begin with. What better way to help TNA than to give a rub to the new blood in the system by helping to get any who aren't over over? That, also, is likely scripted, but I just get the general feel from Kurt that he's very happy doing what he's doing, and that he's in TNA for the long haul.

 

[Ferbian]

But scripted or not, it was his general sentiments from day one – albeit they were much more vehement at his debut.

Exactly, and as I mentioned, the fact that he has legitimately said he's not planning on returning doesn't help the arguments for Kurt returning to WWE.

Which is just yet another reason why it's kind of absurd to be discussing the idea he'd ever do so in the first place.

Sure it's absurd to look at now, but who knows, there is a chance that Kurt could very well decide to go other ways, there's always backstage politics to deal with, let's not forget that Jeff screwed Karen Angle, and is getting married with her right now, while Jeff and Kurt are on balanced grounds, everything can very well change in the matter of seconds, minutes, hours, days etc.

I honestly think he's vested interest in TNA, and that can be found no more than in his recent decision to remove himself from the TNA Top-10 rankings system entirely – choosing instead to face each one of those contenders as a means to prove his worth for having seeded #2 to begin with. What better way to help TNA than to give a rub to the new blood in the system by helping to get any who aren't over over? That, also, is likely scripted, but I just get the general feel from Kurt that he's very happy doing what he's doing, and that he's in TNA for the long haul.

Agreed, while again the scripted part of it can step into consideration because of Kurt Angle's standing in the business and the fact that he could give the rub to the guys, while I do believe that Kurt agreed to do this to help the business, just like Chris Jericho is doing in WWE, I do believe that Kurt didn't necessarily position himself away from the ranking system by default as much as to help a storyline.

 

[Bobby B]

I would like to see him back, but it won't happen.

Firstly, Kurt left the WWE because the working schedule was taking its tole on his body. He wouldn't return unless the WWE game him a much lighter schedule on a par with what he's doing with TNA right now.

Secondly, he likes TNA. He believes he's on the crest of a wave that's only going to grow.

(Those are the two reasons that are backed up by reports). I also think he might simply like being somewhere else. He was with the WWE for a long time, and did a lot there, was invovled in some great matches.

Personally, would I like to see him back. 100%. A great wrestler, a fantastic draw, and he's on a par with Jericho that he's a credible World Champion yet at the same time seems to be very good at elevating younger stars.

Won't happen though.

 

[XgringolocoX]

No, I don't care to see a HHH or Shaemus fued with Kurt Angle. Sure, he'd be back on the biggest stage, but at what cost?
Reports, more likely rumors, were floating around the time Kurt jumped ship to TNA. Those were that a WWE star was a walking time bomb, the next Eddie Guerrero. Angle has even said that the grueling schedule was wearing him down, forcing him to eat pills like MnM's and lead a generally unhealthy lifestyle.
By his own words Angle is MUCH happier and healthier working for TNA. While I'm not a big fan of thier overall product, as a fan of Angle I can't wish him to be anywhere else.
One thing I never got was the attitude of some fans that no matter how it effects the performer (wrestler, musician, actor, etc..) they want thier entertainment at any cost to said performer. As a future endevoured wreslter once said....that's not cool.

 

[Post]

As for the thread itself, no, I don't want to see him return to the WWE, because I think he's fantastic doing what he's doing with TNA. Why return to the WWE, so he can be inundated with "YOU SUCK!" chants the moment his music hits again? No thank you.

Kurt is perfect right where he is in TNA, and it is honestly one of the main reasons I watch their show. Kurt is valued in TNA. They know that no one can really fill his shoes. So, he is rewarded w/ respect, good pay, a lighter work schedule, and a serious character.

One of the many problems in the WWE is that if you aren't Cena or Triple H, then you are expendable. Kurt does not need that headache or the "You Suck" chants (It's Damn Real nailed it!). I'm got into a fistfight @ Joe Louis Arena in 2004 (RAW) with a nutjob who didn't stop chanting "YOU SUCK" the entire show. I'm all up for freedom of speech, but not when it's in my ear for 3 hours.

Now for the question at hand. Do I want to see Kurt return to the WWE? My answer is YES. Return when he is done wrestling for TNA. Have Kurt return for one last match at Wrestlemania, the same weekend that he is being inducted into the WWE HOF. Put on a hell of a show, accept the honor...and then hang em' up.

 

[wrestlemaniac]

I wouldn't like it, I mean if her were to go back then he goes back to to being just a submissionist. That isn't a bad thing but in tna angle does moonsaults and flip dives and the very rarely seen angle 450 splash. He makes anyone he's in a match with look great. Now it's at the point where I can't really see TNA without him.

 

[Ferbian]

I wouldn't like it, I mean if her were to go back then he goes back to to being just a submissionist. That isn't a bad thing but in tna angle does moonsaults and flip dives and the very rarely seen angle 450 splash. He makes anyone he's in a match with look great. Now it's at the point where I can't really see TNA without him.

Problem with this is that Kurt Angle did exactly those things in WWE as well, each and every one of them.

I saw plenty of Moonsaults in WWE, I believe I've seen a 450 splash ( I could be wrong on this) and he does dives.

And to top it off, Kurt Angle makes people look great when wrestling no matter what promotion he's in, he made John Cena look great in his first match, he has made everybody look great, and did a lot to some of the matches where he wasn't necessarily a huge star yet as well, matches like the 2000 Wrestlemania Triple Threat match.

 

[wrestlemaniac]

Problem with this is that Kurt Angle did exactly those things in WWE as well, each and every one of them.

I saw plenty of Moonsaults in WWE, I believe I've seen a 450 splash ( I could be wrong on this) and he does dives.

And to top it off, Kurt Angle makes people look great when wrestling no matter what promotion he's in, he made John Cena look great in his first match, he has made everybody look great, and did a lot to some of the matches where he wasn't necessarily a huge star yet as well, matches like the 2000 Wrestlemania Triple Threat match.

i think i would have remembered, i know he did very few moonsaults, no 450, 1 or 2 shooting star presses but i dont remember him flip diving like he did on aj styles, maybe dive but not flip dive. He did however make cena look decent in the ring i'll give you that and his match vs orton at ons 06 was great

 

[mr_dna]

Kurt needs to go back to WWE because unless WWE End up buying TNA he will not be a HOF and his legacy will never be as big as it could have. I can see him going back to WWE as unlike Foley or Hogan he has had no last Wrestlemania Moment and not had his HOF induction . Angle wants to be in the HOF and im sure he wants perform in front of 72,219 (wrestlemania 26 attendance ) again hell i know for a fact hogan would if vine called him up and said wrestlemania 27 big pay check will u be there he would dump tna and go. I think Angle will be back in WWE even if its just for a year to finish his career . I can see angle back flair back Anderson back and pope and i reckon booker to finish his career

 

[Ferbian]

i think i would have remembered, i know he did very few moonsaults, no 450, 1 or 2 shooting star presses but i dont remember him flip diving like he did on aj styles, maybe dive but not flip dive. He did however make cena look decent in the ring i'll give you that and his match vs orton at ons 06 was great

True, as I said I wasn't certain about the 450 splash, and yes his matches with Styles are definitely on another level, but even considering that Kurt Angle had, and could continue to have great matches in WWE, on the levels of what he's doing in TNA.

And it's because Kurt is a very versatile wrestler, while he probably wouldn't be one to go down to the mid-card like Chris Jericho, he's still versatile in ways that he could very easily feud with the mid-card guys, like he is currently in TNA, feuding with the top 10 ranked wrestlers, which is a list of people who aren't all at main event level.

 

[gd]

I hope not, for TNA's sake. Angle is clearly the best thing TNA has going for itself right now and it's not even close. Over the past year, Angle has made Matt Morgan, Wolfe, Anderson, and countless all look extremely good while continuing to be a badass himself. His feuds are the only ones that seem to garner interest and make sense all of the time.

As a fan of TNA and a pro wrestling fan, no way I want to see Kurt jump ship yet again. There's still a lot he can do in TNA (RVD, Hardy, etc.) This is someone TNA can't and hopefully won't lose anytime in the near future.

 

[MWats]

Kurt Angle is the man in TNA right now, if I were in his shoes, I would see no need to return to WWE where it is overcrowded with talent so I can be in a hot feud for a month and then get stuck in some shitty Intercontinental Title feud. If Angle leaves, that would be the first step in TNA's downfall. Angle is the most legitimate guy TNA has. Hardy is a drug addict, Sting's on his last legs, RVD is big in TNA because they don't have alot of big people, but not a star like Angle was, and Styles isn't known by the general wrestling audience. The only feuds in WWE that would be interesting for Angle are Orton, Cena, Jericho, and Undertaker, all which have been done before. Edge isn't that interesting, and everyone else's feud could easily be replaced. CM Punk could possibly be the only new interesting feud. Angle needs to stay in TNA, as he is much more important to their history than he was to WWE's. If they ever make it big, he can say he was a big part of that.

 

[akash]

no way in this world kurt will return to wwe and i also prefer him more in tna.he has really been consistent and a main eventer in tna.we can clearly look at his fueds,for the first month he was engaged in BFG match of sting than a fued with joe.next the hunt for WHC.then MEM for a year then two historic matches with desmond wolfe and awesome fueds with AJ and anderson.they were fresh and fueds and really helped to make him compareable to all times great.thus a big no.

 

[Judah's Lion]

tough call. i really enjoyed Angle's run with the WWE and am currently enjoying his run in TNA. he's been very arguably the best acquisition in the history of the company and he really is the face of TNA. i remember reading an article years ago that stated Angle could be for TNA what Hogan was for WCW. that seemed very fitting to me and very realistic. in the same article, the title was "6 sides but only 1 Angle" and was a reference to the then six-sided ring. it was pretty accurate though because we all know that there is only one Angle.

his feuds in WWE with Austin, Triple H, Rock, Brock, Benoit, Eddie, JBL, HBK, Big Show, and countless others were all pretty great.

but i am seriously loving his new angle (no pun intended) with working his way up the poll ladder. his matches will all be pretty awesome and always set the bar high. he has the ability to win a match without making the opponent looking bad and the ability to lose a match without looking bad himself. he is on a very small list of people that can do that well and effectively.

his matches with Samoa Joe (the headbutt heard 'round the world was epic!), Sting, Christian, AJ Styles and Mr. Anderson have all been great. and again, his new angle is pretty awesome and i'm super looking forward to seeing him at the #1 spot. great stuff!

but to answer this question, i really could go 50/50 on it. whether or not i think Angle ever would or will go back to WWE (i doubt it, unless it's a Mania send-off for his Hall of Fame deal) is not really relevent. there are a lot of things i want in wrestling that may or may not ever happen. and this could be one of them.

however, i will say this. if Angle ever did return to the WWE and in the very soon future specifically, the feuds i would be most looking forward to would not be with Orton, Sheamus or Triple H. maybe another Cena feud would be okay, but even that is not what i'd most like. i'd be thinking like another extended feud with Edge, Christian, Jericho, CM Punk and Mysterio. with Edge and Christian, he already has some history (especially with Christian in TNA), he's had some good encounters with Jericho and easily could put on some great matches, CM Punk could be pretty awesome and then do some stuff with Mysterio. i think all of those would be worth watching.

on that note, why not give him a match against Taker at Mania? he'd be a very credible threat to the streak and would possibly be the show stealer of the year. just some thoughts. i voted "yes" just because i'd like to see one last run, but i doubt it'll happen, especially in the near future. the guy is the top draw in TNA and it's easy to see why.

 

[Mr-excitement]

Like Ferbian noted, just to add to this – Angle has noted repeatedly that he has no desire to return to the WWE, and even went as far as to say so on PPV's and iMPACT! on more than one occasion.

He said he's still in good graces with Vince and that there's no bad blood there anymore, but that he also came to TNA to make them a contender and that he wasn't leaving until they were one, so to reitterate, the likelihood of him ever returning is very, very slim I'd imagine.

You can't trust what any wrestler says, just like Flair and Dusty and a host of then-NWA stars criticized the WWF and later jumped.

Not to mention, all the WCW wrestlers who went on and on about how great it was and then complained about how once it folded.

As far as do I want to see him back, he's past his prime.

 

[Goliath Uterus]

Well yes and no, I'd love to see Angle come back to the WWE but I also enjoy what he brings to TNA, if he was to return, I have no doubt that he would a main event player on arrival, I really liked the idea above me pitting the Undertaker vs Angle at Mania, that would be a perfect feud right there. But I do love what TNA is doing with him as a serious face that is gonna beat the whole top ten- its great stuff. At this point in time i wouldnt want him to go to WWE just because i wouldnt want TNA to suffer the consequences of him leaving. But i did vote yes because I would LOVE to see Angle in a WWE ring again, its a tough call.

 

[richunclescrooge]

just a matter of time, he'll be back in WWE

When he's ready to retire he'll go back, have his last hurrah and go into the hall of fame

 

[Jeff]

Kurt is 41. I don't ever see him returning to WWE full time. I think he enjoys TNA's light schedule. When/If TNA ever does decide to take there show on the road I think that will be the end of Kurt with TNA. I do think when Kurt IS Done with TNA and he does choose to retire he may return to WWE in Guest Host roles, maybe a WrestleMania match, etc. But the days of seeing Kurt on the road I think are done.