RP Feedback Thread | Page 11 | WrestleZone Forums

RP Feedback Thread

Ok heres my feedback im gonna be brutal so if anyone has a huge problem with it pm me or messanger me the link is on my profile:

Izzy: I like the way you continued the storyline between Manzo and Sincade from all or nothing, it showed focus, depth and gave us a brilliant look at Manzo's past, truely deserving and now i can see why they put you in the main event, Im Sorry i ever doubted you bra...

Mystique:Great Rp, Showed us alot about your character, you used real life events and references to create a story, on the negatvie side it was abit too long, it got boring at times and I had to really focus to continue reading it, if i can give you any advice it would be to make your rp's short and sweet for now, and i use the words for now due to the fact that you are still green, but i see progression and as david stated earlier you are on the fast track to main eventing just keep up the good work.

Ricky: I loved the Rp, felt it showed another side to your character but what i didnt like is the fact that you focused on legend to much, Maxx was being downplayed alot in that rp, i dont know if that was on purpose or just something that you forgot to include i dont know, but i will steal a comment from Will from the all or nothing feedback when he said dont over look your challengers coz Maxx could slowly creep up on you.

Again not being negative or bashing you just something that i saw and thaught i point out, but again i love the direction of your character and the way you are changing from a comedy act.

Kenny: No Offence bro but not the best Rp you have ever done, it touched on points but i just felt like you wanted to insult people, and if you want to get back in the Tag title picture your gonna need more, also i felt that the RP was more of a tweener one i didnt feel like i wanted to cheer for you, i felt that you where complaining which works on some levels but not in this situation.

Joe: Short but sweet, it dealt with the whole issue between the DS and WVC IMO it is the best RP that you have ever done, and talking about how those titles are still vacant due to the way DS won them was priceless, good job and im glad your improving i see a bright future if you keep writing like that.

Legend Part 1: Ok again another solid rp from you legend i really enjoyed it, you showed character deapth and like ricky proved that your more then just a one dimensional character you showed layers!


Legend Part 2: I didnt like this RP and ill tell you why, it felt like you where a victim of name callign and that you had to bash back, I did like the Maxx reference due to the fact that you used his RP as a way to strike back at David and it worked ten fold, but other then that it seemed like desperation and again its just my opinion if you feel that im wrong or wanna question me about it please write it here or pm me and ill responed.

Hasheem: Ive said all i needed to say about this RP, it was long but a good read Good Job and im glad that you followed my advice, well as little as i gave you lol

Milenko: Ok kid your new but there are a few things i felt that your rp lacked, firstly it was character I wanted to understand abit more about you then being a clown who likes to beat people up, and I think i saw a reference in regards to alcohol, why and what drove you to this?
The formatting was abit off but that cant be helped, it just takes time to get your character together, but other then that i see a good showing and if you want to pm me i can talk to you about developing your character abit more, maybe slowly building his story up with each Rp thats if you want my help that is coz the mods are here too and also COCO the crisp.

Maxx/David: Your developing as an rper,It was a good read and i felt the anger, just make sure you dont make a habit of doing the anger rp's all the time as will said it gets old really quickly dude.

Allied Powers/David: ROFL... I loved the mocking of the WZCW roster i dont know why anyone hasnt even referenced this at all or even commented on the characters, it was blinding, it showed something original it felt like i was watching trips and shawn do it i loved the midgets especially the Dynasty...WORD!, the end was abit of a struggle solid Rp all around but again you used the tortoured Maxx, I am interested in where this is going but try not to use that angry character too much because i saw alot of guys jump on you for it, and it made them look stronger IMO.

Will: Great RP, solid as always you showed why your one of the best heels in the fed and can really see you going for Rios, I want to see how this Gus will feud pans out because this seems like something thats like a volcano its gonna explode sooner rather then later.

Gus: Great use of storyline, again great development from you, I was worried about all or nothing with the stinkfest of an RP that you put out i found it unbelievable, i couldnt cheer for your character and just felt that it was more stupid then anything else. but with this one WOW bro you nailed it on the head and hit the various storyline points including Heidi, Will and the rematch clause brilliant kid and i hope its enough to get you back the gold!
 
Thanks to everyone who gave me feedback. I will take it all to heart and do my best to get better. I'm in the midst of a 2nd RP that I can already tell is going to be better than the first one.
Cory
 
Maxx I'm so hurt you left me out...YAY MINE MUST HAVE BEEN PERFECT!!!

*Runs and prints out the RP to put on his fridgerator.*
 
Mystique: Nice, short and had nice imagery. Brilliant to see it properly formatted and neat compared to your first one. Coming on leaps and bounds kid, keep it up.

Ricky: Brilliant as always, still one of the premier men of WZCW. You know I'm high on those background building roleplays as I did one myself, so full points from yourself.

Legend: Good work, I agree with MR. Scott that the second seems just a reply but the first was good and made alot of references. Good work as usual.

Hasheem: So, So very long. Brilliantly done, but long. My only issue is that you had "Dwayne" there at all. I mean, it's the freaking Rock right, and he turns up on WZCW for the first time in a one of cameo that in reality would cost the fed about say $1,000,000 and it's for ... A house show? Right, ok.

Milenko: Neaten the formatting and figure out what direction you want to be and you'll be fine. Not bad for your first RP, but not in a league of its own yet.

Maxx/David: LOVED it! Absolutely brilliant, both of them (Maxx & A.P). Thought it was really great how you got the anger showing and the comedy angle of Davinder and Rasheem across. Loved reading them both and keep up the frankly fantastic work guys.

Will: You know I love you man, delivered again and had a brilliant RP that showed what you was really all about. The card stuff? Priceless. Better than Dynasty? Of course, why wouldn't he be. Absolutely brilliant, best RP of the bunch so far.

Gus: Great work, much better than what we saw at All or Nothing, so relieved to see you back on track.

I'll review more later if I get the time, feedback on mine appriciated as always :D

Riot
 
Maxx/Iscy

Cheers again aguys...I know i screwed up with this RP. While i has (very)happy with the quality, it should have been separated.

I am working on something now to respond to what has been done so far. that will be short and sweet, just a response to being called out really.

I am trying to work on my length issues. I am trying to tell a story with this guy for the time being as I cannot inject any "real" language like cussing etc to it and am having to do something different to most of you in order to add some personality. I wil admit it is a struggle for me at the mo.

As a result i would like to direct everyone to the most recent stickied thread about RP practise and feedback. My submission is fairly long and incomplete but i would appreciate if some of you could head there at some point to give me some more advice.



Jesse.....

Loved your RP....made you look good, did a great job of teasing a heel turn by giving yourself a bit of attitude. And also made me look good which i definitely appreciate.
 
Izzy thanks for the comments but thats all david i dont rp no more and he is shinging brightly i cant believe hes taken maxx to this level and believe he has stepped up his game ten fold

Alex: All i have to say bro is keep building your character thats all you can do at the moment we all need to know who he is maybe talk to creative about a series of promos to help build mystique more, he is an enigma of sorts so having a promo touch on who he is may add more depth.

Jesse: I loved the rp, its showing frushtration of your character and playing off of the recent loss(es) the only thing i can say to you is this, your character is lacking alot, it isnt your fault but i think a heel turn would make jesse into something more, i dont know nothing about you, all i know is that your trained by sting and hogan thats all, I dont know who you are, why your here and what your doing it doesnt make sense there is a lack of purpose there, so think about what i said and again just give me a buzz if you want to talk about it im here to help

Reaper: Well dude all i can say is you got some terrific talent, but i liked your second rp better then your first, coz it showed direction, it showed that your not taking crap from no one, but your first was good but i didnt like it it didnt show me anything as stated by david you bring your a game when there is something on the line.

I will leave more comments with more rps, I love this fed and will keep on helping if i can lol
 
Iscariot...the reason I had Dwayne instead of "The Rock" was because it said in the rules that I wasn't allowed to use any real superstar that WWE or any wrestling Corp. owns. So I had to edit it, with permission (Thank you, Will) and changed it to Dwayne. Was annoying, but I had to.

I also will be reading each person's RP and will be leaving feedback tonight. Thanks for being patient and thank you all for commmentating on my RP :D
 
Melon, you're an idiot :)

I KNOW who it is and why it was Dwayne, seriously I worry bout your IQ sometimes. What I meant (and said..) is why would Dwayne turn up at a house show AT ALL, regardless of his name.

*Adds his name to the "ban coco" list* :p
 
Melon, you're an idiot :)

I KNOW who it is and why it was Dwayne, seriously I worry bout your IQ sometimes. What I meant (and said..) is why would Dwayne turn up at a house show AT ALL, regardless of his name.

*Adds his name to the "ban coco" list* :p

Lol...your message was very confusing!!! Does it matter why he would show up at a house show, lol. I know you wouldn't want me to be banned.
 
This is the problem dude, house show attendance is usually piss poor so the rock takes round about 10 million a movieand it would take a hell of alot of money to get him at any show let alone a house show, if anyone wanted the rock they would at least save him for a tv appearence

Izzy: Melon just wanted to add some flair and Drama to his RP and Dwayne at thsi point is the same as ricky is with Will smith the ultimate baby face, so ultimatly it makes his rp stronger
 
This is the problem dude, house show attendance is usually piss poor so the rock takes round about 10 million a movieand it would take a hell of alot of money to get him at any show let alone a house show, if anyone wanted the rock they would at least save him for a tv appearence

Izzy: Melon just wanted to add some flair and Drama to his RP and Dwayne at thsi point is the same as ricky is with Will smith the ultimate baby face, so ultimatly it makes his rp stronger

Um. I would say that Will Smith and The Rock are pretty incomparable. Will Smith wasn't the focus of the RP. The term "Legend" was. Not putting any opinion out there about Leore's RP, I'm just saying that comparing the two based on the use of celebrities is a far stretch.

I'll add more to my RP as I can...my internet has been jacked up all day and some responsibilities here at school just got increased. But, once this is all adjusted, things should be A OK.
 
Um. I would say that Will Smith and The Rock are pretty incomparable. Will Smith wasn't the focus of the RP. The term "Legend" was. Not putting any opinion out there about Leore's RP, I'm just saying that comparing the two based on the use of celebrities is a far stretch.

I'll add more to my RP as I can...my internet has been jacked up all day and some responsibilities here at school just got increased. But, once this is all adjusted, things should be A OK.

Right reviews again

Ricky: The second and third RP where alot more better then the first, it showed more depth, worked more on the previous and current storylines, It enabled us to see more character depth and played on both Legend and Maxx this time around so it looks more authentic in storyline terms rather then promote a legend vs ricky feud. brilliant and i cant wait to see what you got next instore bra...

Kenny: Ok dude far better,you made sure that you played off of joes rp, it made you guys look stronger as far as contention is concerned for the tag titles, I love it and hope you keep up this level of work.
 
Glad you like it. I tried to expalin why I did what I did in the first one so that one wouldn't be as bad as it is.
 
Have posted another RP, another quite long one but i have involved Leon and Chuck in this to try and add a bit more story and personality but also to give GM someone to bounce off of. I think it works despite the length, though i have added a warning at the start about it.

Hope you like it guys.
 
DP,

If an RP really impresses me, then I often start it something like:

"WOW, just WOW."

But in your case, wow just doesnt cover it.

That was brilliant.
 
So Guys, the RP threads are closed but the show is not up. Since this thred died a death since the roulette show i figured we could resurrect it again.

Really enjoyed all the RP's. i could not pick a winner from the 6 man as i thought they were all very solid. I like how they all seemed to play off each other.

Ben seemed to bring his up another level, the 2 RPs from the NoI worked very well together. Ricky proved again he is excellent at the serious RP but the comedic factor was alive and well. And Everest showed again how good he is at highlighting the history of his work and the ability of the people he fights with and against.

Am i right in sayin the DJ is now responsible for the RP of Maxx and the Allied Powers? I think he posted both this time and they were very good. I loved the AP one, expecially the news segment.

Disappointed that LaPalme and Colon no-showed. Maybe it was to be expected. I dont know what creative have got planned for me and Jesse. If the fued continues then maybe it is best that we both win. I liked mine anyway even though it wasnt my best.

Jesse, your RP was a bit too short but made your point loud and clear. I liked it nonetheless.

The tag match RP were simply brilliant. So i am glad i do not have to choose a winner in this case.

That was my thoughts. What do you lot think?
 
Ok first of all thanks Alex for that indepth analysis, im glad you liked all the rps and i do agree with you in regards to alot of wrestllers who arent doing anything at this point its a shame that these characters have a lot of talent but dont do anything interesting

COLON and Lapalme its a shame that you guys cant get off your behinds and do anything with yourselves you could of been stars in WZCW but meh

DC and HASHEEM, I was disappointed that both men had difficulty rping, im wondering whats gonna happen with this feud.

Ok now to the people who did rp:

Alex solid as always, a good rp you are progressing nicely and i see a definate future in regards to that win streak as for Lapalme we should of just let Melinko take his place

Ricky, great comedy i loved that fact that everyone was highly competitive for the six man it worked well and shows how hungry all are to win this, i love it but wont comment on my own stuff in this match

Ben: WOW. JUST WOW, that was an amazing rp, you really took it up another level you are quickly becoming a hardcore athlete and showing why you belong in this devision.

Everest: damn thats why your in the main event you played well off of my rp and took me down a couple of pegs.

Jesse: Quick and too the point, i would like to see you in the nation of islam, i really think you would shine in that group maybe would help you elevate your character to the elite x title

thats all keep em coming guys
 
Thanks for the great feedback, guys. It's stuff like this that makes me want to take the time to write great RPs. I'm just really busy right now, with school almost over and high school right around the corner, and I could take another leave of absence. But the support here makes me want to keep at it, so thank you.

EVEREST-Great RP, and like I said in mine, you're one of those guys in which many will be compared. Definately look forward to RPing with/against you in the future.

DJ-Very solid, enjoyable RPs. I loved you're second, I think you just added a lot of energy to it, and I hope you can put that same energy into Maxx in the future.

RICKY-As always, a very enjoyable RP. I laughed at your confusing, comedic logic, and it was a great representation of the smart humor you have. You continue to show why you're a champion.

If I get a chance, I'll try to read everyone else's.
 
a0161613: I really like the whole set up, with the computer and everything, it really kept me reading. And I just dug it the whole way through. But then you kinda dropped the ball a bit by giving like a minute long promo. Such an awesome set up. The promo wasn't bad by any means, but, it was over before it started. I don't know if you had some trouble coming up with some lines or not, cause I have done that myself. Where like, one paragraph takes forever to write that you just don't know if you can write anymore, so ya end up with a kinda short promo. If thats the case I feel your pain. But, awesome set up, could have milked that a bit more.

ozzman14: The talking is pretty good, the promo skills are there. But the actions. Too choppy and too point blank. Add some depth to your actions. You can turn a simple move of the hand into an insult by itself. The scenery was a little too bland too. Like I just pictured Kenny sitting in a closet with a light above him. The world is your playground in RPs. Use it to your advantage. Don't sit in a closet man, your also walking Kenny right into a gay joke... :blink:

Reaper: I can't really say anything bad about your RP, loved the flow. And the kinda monster vibe it has shines some. And I love actually in one point when you talked about the laws you guys have, how you only had one law... like instead of just mentioning the rest, you openly admit that there aren't any other laws, lol. I thought that was awesome simply for the fact that although your character does have this "aura" around him, he is still human, and it takes him down a notch, but on the human level. The personality and intimidation aspect is still there. But a genuine show of humanity stuck out in my eyes. Great job man.

joe81014: Almost the same thing as Ozzman there. The actions. Too choppy and too point blank. The talking was good, it flowed, but those actions didn't leave much to the reader. The scenery was kinda cool, but, where was the podium? Inside? Outside? Paint the picture, then destroy it. Cause your burning the floor apparently... but... what kinda floor is it? Would the fire reflect off of it? Make the logo shine a bit? See what I mean, you have done something cool, like have the camera right up on your face, and then it like, zooms out and rises up above you and its looking down on you. As you light the logo on an abandoned factory floor. And some stray paper bags pass in front of you as the flames gather to form the W. Then you look up at the camera as it forms the V, etc. etc. etc. like, you could have milked that. Actions man, actions and details are your friend. But I do love that last line, lol. That could be taken two different ways, but I like the nod to comparison. Shows your character knew what he was doing. And knew that that "someone" could get upset.

Jesse: I actually read this RP, and then went back to reference some of your older RPs. I only saw other RP from you so far. In the first RP, you had a lot of good talking, and then hardly any action. In this latest RP, you have a little talking, and a little action. You kinda used the word ass too much, and then threw in a gay joke at the end there. It seemed a bit rushed, and almost like you were forcing yourself to cut a promo. Don't ever let that be the case. In your last RP you has such an ego, and such cocky attitude, and now your like, an MMA fighter. I don't wanna pick on you or anything so don't take this as hateful feedback, but if your character thinks he is the best damn thing ever, then thats what he should talk about. You kinda just addressed the match, but you didn't really reference why your gonna win. Training is a gimme thing, everyone trains, you really don't need to mention it. Its still good though, but, something simple along the lines of, "I'm gonna win, cause... lets face it... LOOK AT ME!" Thats just cocky all over it, and then you can throw in some actions of different flexes, and maybe even throw a random chick in there and pick her up, lol. World is you playground man, I said that to Ozz too. But don't quit, you'll get the hang of it.

DJ: I just want to say I am not a fan of the video cut RPs. But yours, was by far one of the best ones I have ever read. I loved the pacing, and I loved how you didn't rely on actual "video footage" of a match. It was all you, in different scenerios. Screaming, calm, angry, its a beautiful RP, PPV worthy. Great job man.

Michigan: :worship: but the actions were a bit choppy. But for an interview, there really isn't much you can do, so it was understandable. So, for others, Everest was stationary and confined to a set area. Everyone else that isn't confined and is free to do whatever they want, you should use some more action. Since Everest is basically sitting there talking... he can get away with not doing much.

Big Ben: Again, actions are a bit choppy, but the talking was on par with Everest. Try not to rely too much on video footage though. If anything, I'd talk about it in character. Like after the first couple video footages, its almost like your character has a collection of all the things he's ever done, in his backpack... like he carries it around to show people whenever he can. Also no scenery really left some confusion to how he showed video footage.

DJ's 2nd RP: Where the last one left off... you kinda stumbled a bit into the second one. It was still good though, and still entertaining. So I can't say much bad about it. I really like the transitions from you to something back to you something else. That stuff is pretty cool. But don't over do it.

Steamboat Ricky: For all the more your RP was, it was still entertaining. Wish it could have gone on a bit longer, but other then that, the Jelly fish thing was classic, lol.
 
Cheers DC, i did wonder if someone would pick up on the amount of talk i put in. With regards to that i felt in a bit of a hole creatively as i was expecting to go up against Jesse again.

And then i get put against someone who i had a horrible feeling all along that he would not RP. So that was difficult to fight as i knew it may not take much to win the match.

I enjoyed writing it though but the lack of real speech stopped it from being a classic in my eyes. My lethal lottery one could be brilliant, it is ready to go depending on what happens at Meltdown.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,837
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top