You want to talk about Orton, well get ready....
Otron is getting to the level of horrible. Does anyone realize how long it as been since he has had a decent program? The list time that he had a decent program was with The Undertaker in 2005. That is over fours years without a noteworthy program and we have this guy as the main heel on Raw? That's ridiculous.
I agreed with almost everything on your post, but this. Orton was looking scary good going into Mania. Do we not remember that? Everyone was huge on him after the rumble. He was being booked as scary heel that couldn't control what he was doing. He couldn't be stopped. He punted Vince, then destroyed Shane in a match. Then going on to rko Steph... Followed up handcuffing Trips to the ropes. While kissing his wife... He was one most unpredictable characters. He was a scary heel that each of us thought was amazing.
Since Mania however, he has been made to look as one of the weakest heels I've ever seen. It is pretty bad when you can take your most over heel in the company, and turn him into the weakest heels seen in the last ten years. The man couldn't even win the title by himself..... He had to win it on a 3 on 3 tag match. He lost the title only to win it a week later. Then he's had these series of clusterfuck matches with Cena, that have either been overbooked or underbooked. Or well we don't know how to keep this going so we're going to give him the title back. I don't know what to think about it.
Now Orton has never seem to me that he was one of the better men in the ring. He's boring and lazy in the ring. Does the least possible amount of work ring to get by. He has like 15 versions of a headlock. He hasn't been good in the ring for a couple years now. The last time that he had a worth while match that actually lived up to the hype was SummerSlam 07 the main event with Cena. You know the one where they were actually allowed to have a match? Yeah that one!
When you actually think about it, the only time that Orton has had good to great matches have been when he was in the ring with a solid in ring performer. Cena. Arguable the best performer that wwe has right now. Then before that he was in a triple threat with Angle. Which was an awesome match. Then before that he was carried to a great series of match by 'Taker. Before then it was with Foley, and Edge. He hasn't done that much on his own.
His gimmick is boring. He's not exciting he use to come out and threaten people and then follow through. Taking Cena's dad out. Taking the entire McMahon family out. He was scary as a character, because you didn't know what was coming. Now he's boring you can't go to that extreme, and then cut him back as much as they can and try to keep the same gimmick. Everything is slow with him. He comes out and sucks the life out of everything. I'm not sure who said this, but it's true. Cena will come out and get the crowd fired up. Everyone is ready for the match. Then Orton comes out, 3 minutes later we are bored to tears and ready to turn it off. The crowd is dead, and uninterested in the match. He's the only guy that does that.
Simply Orton needs help. He has to change somethings up. He needs to be able to either go sadistic heel like he was or go face. Then come back with a new heel gimmick. He has to work on what he thinks is a good match. Because whatever it is.... isn't working. People say that he's the best heel. That isn't true. That title still belongs to Punk. He's been fresh, and continues to be fresh were Orton doesn't change anything.