Does this mean you plan to vote out Lou Thesz in the coming rounds? Hell, some of his bookers, from what I read, seemed to think Theszie was lacking in the charisma department
For the record, this isn't trolling; I'm legitimately curious
Thousands of people don't come to see you for decades if you're lacking in charisma. Thesz wasn't the Rock, but he didn't need to be, because the things he did in the ring were the stories he needed to tell to get people interested. It's about knowing what your audience wants and who you're playing to.
I don't mean charisma solely in the sense we'd use it today, but I mean it in the sense that people are invested in your persona rather than thinking you put on good matches. People wanted to see Thesz, and wanted to see him win. The majority of people who like Benoit were only interested in his matches - a significant amount of people would say his greatest match was the one he lost to Kurt Angle at the Royal Rumble.
With the possible exception of his win at WrestleMania, I don't think Benoit ever made the crowd feel anything except "that was a good match". Thesz would make them feel the emotion during the match, and was quite innovative in things like pacing etc. which are important these days.
Finally, these are two wrestlers who basically achieved identical things. Simmons, for me, is more interesting, partly because he was the first black man to win the world title, but more importantly because he played a number of different characters over the years from his early days, through the Nation, APA and finally being the damn guy, and all of them were over. Benoit's character has always just been "technical wrestler".