I think there are a number of wrestlers that can be considered "underrated". I think for one, give Shawn Hernandez (supermex) a shot. Get him away from LAX, and get him in a decent angle ---yes, he can't really cut a promo, but hey...look at Joe. He didn't for awhile either. He came, he saw, he kicked ass, he left. Nonetheless, who says that every wrestler HAS to cut a promo when they come onscreen? Yes, I know...it would make them boring to a degree, but if they package Hernandez just right (yes I know...that's pretty evasive), I think he could really be a force. He has strength, he has mobility, he (to me), is a decent worker. I think the switch that Rob Terry made from a nobody to a (at least) semi-somebody proves that he (hernandez) could be elevated to the next tier. Get OUT of the angle with Morgan (Nothing against Morgan, because I mark out for him too), but move up moreso --- against Sting, or against Abyss. It can be done. Heck, put a belt on him to give him credibility. If Joe could win the X division, who's to say Shawn couldn't??
Once he wins that, put him in an angle that X division is the first in line to receive a title shot, and take RVD (or whomever) to the limit.....not no 10 minute draw.....but go 30 minutes or so. Don't make his matches squashes,--and have them go at least 10-15 every week.
I think the other underrated would be of course, Pope
. However, I think he's just about "there", so I don't know if he would be --or still be considered underrated. I'm SO glad that he's not Elijah Burke, and the night he made his return and had tears in his eyes, completely sold me (from a promo standpoint).