John Cena, and by extension, Randy Orton are right. I love the nostalgia aspect of the Rock's return, don't get me wrong. But, he is a hypocrite, and got rightly called out on it. It isn't about being a slave, its about disappearing for 7 years, and then pandering to the crowd, telling them how he is back for good, how he never abandoned them, how he is proud of his time as a wrestler, when anyone with even half of a brain knows damn well he is full of shit. He left the world of wresting for what he thought would be greener pastures. He thought he was going to be be the next huge movie star. He thought he was too big for wrestling anymore. He thought he was going to be the next Stallone, the next Schwarzenegger. Instead, he ends up being a tooth fairy who drives whiny alien kids to a fucking mountain. He came back because his movies have steadily done worse at the box office. he isn't the huge movie star he thought he was going to be. He finally realized that he needs the wrestling fans to remain relevant.
This isn't about which wrestler you like better, its about which "wrestler" is actually telling the truth. For all of Cena's movies, he always came back. Movies were side projects, to be done in addition to his wrestling career. For the Rock, movies were the only project he wanted. For seven years. The Rock did abandon wrestling, he did tell everyone he was Dwayne Johnson, not the Rock. Every interview he gave, he always told the interviewer about how wrestling was his past, not his future. He only gives a damn about WWE fans insofar as they continue to buy movie tickets for his piece of shit movies. Yeah, Cena has made some groaners, but the Rock paved the way in that category, because his movies were all Oscar winners, weren't they?
I hate the fact that I have to side with John Cena. I love the Rock as a character. But, he did abandon the WWE. He shit on every WWE fan that ever bought a Rock T-shirt when he attempted to erase his wrestling past. If it wasn't Wrestlemania, and the huge payday that he is guaranteed to get, would he have "returned"? If this was October, and it was only building up to Bragging Rights, does he return? Hell no. After Wrestlemania, after Dwayne Johnson gets his paycheck, how much are we going to see him? Anyone want to place any bets on whether he sticks around for Extreme Rules or Over the Limit? Or is he going to disappear for another 7 years, all the while claiming that he is never leaving? My money is on the Rock disappearing again.
Both John Cena and the Rock are capable of talking a good talk. But, John Cena has been walking the walk for the past 9 years, while the Rock has been making movies. I would love to believe that the Rock meant every word he said in his return promo, but I can't. I can't believe a damn word he said in that promo. As good as it was, it was a fabrication. A lie. We all know he is going to leave again, sooner rather than later. While John Cena is proud to call himself a WWE Wrestler/Superstar, its only been for the last month and a half that Dwayne Johnson rediscovered his pride. He spent the better part of the last 7 years telling everyone he was a movie star, not a wrestler, how wrestling was the past, how he would never wrestle again, etc. Dwayne Johnson did everything he could to tell people he wasn't a wrestler anymore, but a movie star, while John Cena does everything he can to tell you he is a wrestler.
I am not a young newbie. I have been watching pro wrestling since the early 1980s. I watched the entire run of Hulkamania, saw Flair become the dirtiest player in the game, witnessed the rise and fall of WCCW, WCW and ECW (the real ECW, not WWECW). I was there before the Attitude era, during the Attitude era, and now, during the PG era. I LOVED the Rock, once upon a time. To this day, he gives a better promo than 99% of the business. I am not questioning his ability to provoke a crowd reaction, he has always been a master at that. I just don't like being lied to, and I feel that Dwayne Johnson is lying to everyone when he says he is back for good. If he is still involved in the WWE at Summerslam, if he is still there at Night of Champions, I will be glad to admit I was wrong about everything. I will gladly eat my words about the Rock's commitment to the WWE and pro wrestling in general. I want him to be telling the truth, I am just old enough to know that if it sounds like bullshit, smells like bullshit and looks like bullshit, it's probably bullshit.
When John Cena tells us how much he loves the WWE, he proves it every week by going out there and entertaining the fans. When Dwayne Johnson tells us how much he loves the WWE, I have to ask, if you love it so much, where have you been? Even Steve Austin makes a couple of appearances a year, every year since he retired. He left because he had to. Injuries forced him out. Rock, you left because you wanted to, and ignored the WWE for almost seven years. You want me back as a fan? Prove it by being here long after Wrestlemania and that fat paycheck is gone.