He needs to be more ripped? Sounds to me like you're just
homo for Punk
Hahahahahahha, wow you're so unbelievably funny. I don't think I've ever heard somebody make such a witty joke about someone's sexuality.
Yeah, seriously. If you're still making jokes like that at your age (I assume you're older than 16), and getting as much enjoyment out of it as your emoticon suggests, then that just shows how much of an absolute fool you must be.
I'm gay myself and I've no problem with gay jokes that are funny and made with the right intention - and I don't think that childish little insult suffices either criteria. Grow up, you're only making yourself look like an intolerant ********. If you're gonna make a gay joke at least have the decency to make it funny. Then again, I'm probably expecting too much of someone of your intellectual capacity.
Away with the soapbox for now.
Wow, CMPunker. You seem to be greatly troubled by this non-issue.
Off the top of my head, by your logic, we shouldn't have believed that Jeff Hardy could defeat Youmanga (he did), we shouldn't have believed that Hardy could defeat Triple-H (he did - twice) - in fact ANYBODY of a similar stature to Punk shouldn't have been able to get over and become a believable star. Thankfully, history proves otherwise.
Jericho's physique is hardly much better than Punk's, 'nor was HBK's (especially in his last run). Was HBK a believable opponent to 'Taker? Yes. Was Jericho a believable opponent for Batista? Yes.
If you have trouble buying somebody as a contender against a big guy then that's fine. You're entitled to not buy into a concept with which you have an issue, I can't really lecture you on what you should or shouldn't believe.
What I CAN do is point out that if people who share your view are the minority, and I believe that's quite clearly the case, then it's not the issue you're making it out to be. If the majority buy Punk as a threat against these guys then that's what matters.
EDIT: And, by the by, in the realm of an actual fight, a big muscle head isn't always going to come out the victor against somebody of Punk's size. It's not about having tree trunk legs or 20 inch pythons, it's about knowing how to fight. I've seen people shorter than Punk kick the shit out of people much bigger. Being a muscle head slows you down.