This is from an outsider's perspective, but I think it is absurd to say that one person, even if it was Choxy, killed off the entire section. I browse the section from time to time, and to be quite honest it is boring. There are a few dedicated ones that will read each other's work fully, but who honestly has the additional time to read some of the work posted up here? Most of the stuff is too long and is just a rehash of something else. It doesn't help that some people start multiple projects and just leave them to go on to the next. Because of that, they leave behind a trail of failed threads on the first page of the section.
Don't get me wrong. If you want to write a piece of work that is long and relatively unappetizing to most, go ahead. However, do not be surprised when the section does not churn in much traffic from the outside.
I would love to tune into a consistent Book This! show that was unique and the matches were relatively short, but why would I want to read about someone like Ziggler having a match when I can just watch him having one on TV every now and then.
I do not know why people don't go the route that WZCW is doing. Have a group of people do a fiction WWE and another do TNA. From there you can pick up match writers and creative members for that certain brand. With that, the load of the show is shared and people can still be a part of something unique.