klunderbunker
Welcome to My (And Not Sly's) House
Best PPV Of The Year
Best PPV Of The Year
- Thread starter klunderbunker
- Start date
FlexAmerican Dynamite
WZCW WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPION
Mania or Slammiversary, most likely Mania though.
Mighty NorCal
SHALL WE BEGIN?
How the FUCK is extreme rules not taking this???? THREE moty canidates!!
Steamboat Ricky
WZCW's Living Legend
Wrestlemania only takes it based on its name. If that card was Over the Limit...nothing doing.
Vote Extreme Rules. Cena/Lesnar >>>>>> Cena/Rock
Vote Extreme Rules. Cena/Lesnar >>>>>> Cena/Rock
This. Also, you had far less filler, better matches, better crowd.
Extreme Rules all damn day
True.
Extreme Rule's three matches were better than Mania's. With far less filler to water the show down
SpoodBeest
City Dweller, Successful Fella
Most somehow see the match quality as better all around for Extreme Rules, I didn't both undercards were average and three major MOTY candidates made up for the rest of both shows. Which in my opinion the epicness and larger than life atmosphere of WrestleMania 28 puts it above Extreme Rules in my opinion. Also I am of a very magniscopic minority who preferred Mania's Punk/Jericho bout rather than the Extreme Rules street fight. Rock/Cena was also a great way to cap off the show, if Lesnar won it might have been a contest. My vote goes to Mania 28
Bernkastel
Reaper of Miracles
I'm going with Wrestlemania based on personal preference even though Extreme Rules was a damn close #2.
This Is My Name Thank You
Is a horrible poster.
Was a fan of Slammiversary, and am wondering why Bound For Glory wasn't on the poll. I have yet to watch Extreme Rules. I am going to download it tonight and watch it. Then I will see if it is either Slammiversary or this Extrem Rules PPV.
Hardymania
Man of the Year Candidate
Extreme Rules was my favorite out of all of them. Punk vs Jericho and Daniel Bryan vs Sheamus, two championship matches, were very very good. Cena vs Brock was great even though I didn't enjoy the ending. Plus, "Adrenaline" was an awesome theme song. Shinedown Rules!!
The 1-2-3 Killam
Mid-Card Championship Winner
I do not agree with WrestleMania winning this poll. I guess it makes sense; Mania was a solid show with a "once in a lifetime" main event. But it did not have three Match of the Year candidates.
Sheamus/Bryan? Better at Extreme Rules.
Punk/Jericho? Better at Extreme Rules.
Rock/Cena? I'll say it...not as good as Brock/Cena.
So you could totally vote for WrestleMania if you want. You'd be wrong, but that's not my problem.
Sheamus/Bryan? Better at Extreme Rules.
Punk/Jericho? Better at Extreme Rules.
Rock/Cena? I'll say it...not as good as Brock/Cena.
So you could totally vote for WrestleMania if you want. You'd be wrong, but that's not my problem.
Bernkastel
Reaper of Miracles
The 1-2-3 Killam
Mid-Card Championship Winner
That's nice. Transformers 2 and Twilight brought in a shit load of money. They still suck. Your next argument?
Steamboat Ricky
WZCW's Living Legend
It's stupid how much Mania is beating Extreme Rules. Stupid.
Bernkastel
Reaper of Miracles
FlexAmerican Dynamite
WZCW WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPION
This is the same argument that can be used as to why Cena main events PPV's this summer while Punk didn't. Everybody who was on the Mania card drew more.
The 1-2-3 Killam
Mid-Card Championship Winner
Quantity of viewers has never, and will never equal the same thing as quality of product. WrestleMania is a huge, worldwide spectacle covered by mainstream media and promoted 24/7 for about three months of WWE programming. It has its own WWE-sponsored website. It is a household name. Of course WrestleMania is going to draw more than Extreme Rules.
But that argument is ridiculous. If I used that sort of logic, I wouldn't even watch the pay-per-view. I would just look up the buyrate and write my review based on that. Oh, it got 1,000,000 buys? GREAT! GIVE IT A PERFECT SCORE! Are you honestly telling me that because something drew more of an interest BEFORE IT HAPPENED, it's ultimate a better event?
Extreme RUles was a better show. It had better matches, and was altogether more entertaining. And you're telling me that because it didn't get as many PPV buys as WrestleMania, we should just write it off. What your doing is taking the whole job of the critical media, and making it absolutely useless. Why review anything? Let's just say whatever draws more interest from popular culture is clearly the pinnacle of quality. Justin Bieber is obviously a better artist than Eric Clapton. Twilight is obviously a better movie than Tree of Life. Or Back to the FUture, for the ridiculous people that threw the movie tournament.
Steamboat Ricky
WZCW's Living Legend
Because you aren't a legal citizen? You didn't register?
The first hour of Wrestlemania was horrendous. I mean, just God awful. Sure, the main three matches delivered, but the rest of the card was simply shit. And while I prefer Punk and Jericho's match at 'Mania over their match at Extreme Rules, the pacing and match placement of Extreme Rules made it a more enjoyable show overall. Not to mention the fact that Cena vs. Lesnar blew both Rock/Cena and HHH/Undertaker out of the water and that Bryan vs. Sheamus was incredible and to date Sheamus' best match ever. Moreover, the crowd for Extreme Rules was white hot all throughout. Can't say the same for Wrestlemania.
My vote goes to Extreme Rules.
My vote goes to Extreme Rules.
Well of course it's going to; Wrestlemania was going to get more buys off of the Wrestlemania name. By this logic, I logic I admittedly agree with to some extent, we might as well close this poll every year, and just award Wrestlemania the prize every year.
It was a glorious night in every way imaginable.
Seriously, THREE moty candidates in one night... how often does that happen? WWE just brought their A-game to that PPV, and it's likely one of the best shows I've ever seen.
Bernkastel
Reaper of Miracles
That's what we say about Hogan in the WZ tourney ever year. I guess Wrestlemania can't climb a ladder.