I'm going to
bold one from each category as the one I thought most deserving. Not that it matters, but it's fun.
1. Best Match of the Year
-Smackdown Elimination Chamber Match
-Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan for the World Title @ Extreme Rules
-AJ Styles & Kurt Angle vs. Chris Daniels & Kazarian @ No Surrender
-Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Minoru Suzuki for the IWGP World Title @ Kings of Pro Wrestling on iPPV
-Big Show vs. Sheamus for the World Title @ Hell in a Cell
-James Storm vs. Bobby Roode @ Bound for Glory
2. Worst Match of the Year
-Psycho Sid vs. Heath Slater @ Raw ??
I don't know, I always hated this category. Probably some awful Divas match, or something that involved Hornswoggle. I spend my year trying to tune these matches out.
-TNA Sacrifice
-TNA Slammiversary
-WWE Extreme Rules
-TNA Bound for Glory
-TNA Turning Point
-WWE Night of Champions
-WWE Royal Rumble
-TNA Lockdown
5. Best Angle of the Year
-Aces & Eights (for about a month)
-Heath Slater Challenging Legends
-Kane & Daniel Bryan's "Anger Management" courses
-EY & ODB get married
-Joseph Park Looking for Abyss
-The re-debut of Brodus Clay as the Funkasaurus
6. Worst Angle of the Year
-Aces & Eights (everything after the first month)
-Claire Lynch
-Vickie Lynch
-"Embrace the Hate"
-CM Drunk
-People Power
I'm assuming by "rookie" we mean "new to their brand". Because most of the guys that get brought up to WWE haven't been "rookies" for a decade.
-Antonio Cesaro
-Damien Sandow
-The Ryback
-Seth Rollins
-Dean Ambrose
-Bully Ray @ No Surrender (the "Destined for Greatness" promo)
-Bully Ray @ Against All Odds (the "feeble woman" promo)
-Punk/Cena/Hart promo @ 9/10/12 Raw
-John Cena promo on the Rock @ 2/20/12 Raw
-Punk/Foley promo on HIAC @ 9/24/12 Raw
9. Biggest Surprise of the Year
-Brodus Clay Re-Debuts as the Funkasaurus
-The Rock Announces His WWE Championship Intentions
-18 seconds
-Brock Lesnar Returns
-D-Von revealed as Aces & Eights enforcer
-Santino almost wins World Title
10. Best Wrestler of the Year
-CM Punk
-Alberto del Rio
-Sheamus
-Daniel Bryan
-Dolph Ziggler
11. Worst Wrestler of the Year
-The Great Khali
12. Non-Wrestler of the Year
-Ricardo Rodriguez
-JBL
-Booker T
-CM Punk, WWE Champion
-Bobby Roode, TNA World Champion
-Sheamus, WWE World Champion
-Kevin Steen, ROH World Champion
-Team Hell No, WWE Tag Champions
14. Best Group (Includes Tag Teams)
-Chris Daniels & Kazarian
-CM Punk & Paul Heyman
-Sheamus vs. Alberto del Rio
-Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan
-The Rock vs. John Cena
-Bully Ray vs. Abyss/Joseph Park
-Sheamus wins the title in 18 seconds
-The Shield debuts and puts Ryback through a table
-Brock Lesnar Returns on Raw
-CM Punk Aligns w/ Paul Heyman
-CM Punk turns heel on Raw 1,000
-Hulk Hogan sex tape
-Impact Wrestling goes live
-Austin Aries vacates the X-Division title, wins World title.
-The Rock vs. John Cena - Once in a Lifetime
-Jerry Lawler suffers heart attack live on Raw; recovers in two months
-Punk 365
19. Most Improved Wrestler of the Year
-Sheamus
-Austin Aries
-Sin Cara