Bit in a mixed mind, partly because of having not played Super Mario World. But simply put, Black was a brilliant game for breakthrough graphics, literally was the Burnout of FPS. It's great playing, but the main set back is that the only thing you can do after finishing the story is playing again but on a harder level. There were some elements I liked, partly the fact that all the terrorists would run and dive shouting "GRENADA!" when a grenade is throw, just a minor lil joy factor I love.
On the flipside, I don't hear many people going on about Super Mario World compared to Mario Bros 1 & 3 in games they loved from the old days, I would admit the appeal is great with Yoshi in hand, but are we getting the same treatment in Mario Galaxy 2 that's coming along? I think I'm leaving out voting because I'm not fully sure on Black and I have no backing to vote SMW due to not playing it,