Wow...some of these top 5 lists have been pretty bad...Hogan and Cena should never be mentioned in Top "Wrestling" Matches. They aren't good wrestlers. They are strong, fan favorites (or tweeners in Cena's case) who are simply on the show for face value and box office draw.
Now, to my Top 5: (before anyone posts a reply, keep in mind this is a personal Top 5...I started watching wrestling around Wrestlemania 10, stopped around 2003, and picked back up right before the 2008 Royal Rumble)
5) Shawn Micahels vs. Ric Flair (Career Threatening Match, Wrestlemania 24)
I had my doubts about this match when it was made, mainly because I didn't see hwo they could build any heat between two men who truly respect one another....afterall, Flair requested the match. But when the "Old Yeller" promo happened on Raw, and then HBK was silently removed as the person who was inducting Flair into the HOF, I knew this was going to be an emotional classic. When HBK missed the moonsault on the announce table, my party and I hit rewind 4 seperate times to verify that HBK had broken his ribs, cause there was no way he hadn't. HBK's final farewell to Flair before hitting the Sweet Chin Music was timeless. Also, did anyone see it coming that Flair would finally hit the cross-body block from the top rope after missing it in every match for years? I didn't, and I was pleased to see it.
4) Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon (Steel Cage Match, St. Valentine's Day Massacre 1999
I can't believe I haven't seen this match anywhere else. This is such a classic. This was the absolute peak of the Austin-McMahon rivalry. Vinnie had just "won" the Royal Rumble & his 'Mania title shot was on the line. This was a super bloody, excellent cage match. It legitimately went back and forth, and Vince probably "wrestled" his best match against Stone Cold. The fact that the newly signed Paul Wight (formerly The Giant, now the ever-wasted Big Show) busted through the ring and threw Austin THROUGH THE CAGE in aiding his victory was a classic, never before seen finish.
3) Bret "Hitman" Hart vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin (Submission Match, Wrestlemania 13)
People don't always go for the submission match, as it lacks the high flying, super strength, and showy power move aspect of professional wrestling, but this match was so important towards he WWF eventually winning the Monday Night Wars. Bret Hart took the role as face walking in, and left as the heel. Stone Cold Steve Austin became a legitimate Main Event Level talent and the face of a new generation of wrestling. I was at Wrestlemania 13, and as a 15 year old kid, I didn't understand at the time the impact that this match had. Austin passing out from blood loss and never tapping showed everyone what we eventually found out: Austin was as tough an SOB as anyone to ever step between the ropes. Bret Hart was the best technical wrestler of his time (maybe ever...sorry Benoit/Angle lovers) and for Austin to hold his own with an absolute submission machine like Hart and leave the ring with the crowd newly alligned with him was a classic WWF moment.
2) 1995 Royal Rumble Match
Shawn Michaels and the British Bulldog opened at 1 & 2, respectively, and finished as the last men standing. This is by far the best Rumble ever...I know 1992 was for the title itself, but we had never seen this kind of longevity, stamina, and will to win in a Rumble like this. HBK having 1 foot touch the floor is an announcement I will never forget. Bulldog was absolutely awesome in this match. He elminated 4 guys and spent over 38 minutes in the match. But HBK stole the show (as he typically does), eliminating 8 guys, going over 38 minutes, and using pure athleticism to stay alive and win the match from behind (very condusive to the whole Heartbreak Kid personna of the mid-90's)...if only his Wrestlemania 11 match against Diesel wasn't on the worst WM card of all-time.
1) Bret "Hitman" Hart vs. Shawn Michaels (WWF Title Ironman Match, Wrestlemania 12)
Not only the best Wrestlemania match of all-time, but probably the best match of all-time. Shawn Michael's rise to the WWF Title, culminating in this sudden-death overtime win against the man who would end up being remembered as his non-kayfabe greatest rival of all-time, is the greatest story the WWF has ever, and will ever tell. Everyone has seen the match, so I don't need to remind anyone of the details, but if Sudden Death OT had been part of the explained rules in the first place, would Hart have ever let HBK out of the Sharpshooter?