I saw Chuck Taylor vs. Joey Ryan, it was probably the best non WWE match I've seen in person. I saw Samoa Joe vs. Reigns at Raw once, that was a very good match, especially since Joe won with the Clutch.
I saw Rikishi in a tag match with three local guys and he was so overweight and old he couldn't take any bump other than a low blow to break up a stink face. I love when local guys beat the bigger name guys though, its always a good pop. Like this one time, Buff Bagwell was wrestling a local guy, and like yeah Buff was never the biggest deal, but he lost to the local guy after a swinging neckbreaker. I was so not expecting that move to get the win that I sent a text during the pin and actually missed it. The guy ran into the crowd and acted like he just upset Cena for a world title, it was beautiful.