With Cryme Tyme, Shad was your stereotypical black guy, complete with rapper gimmick.
He was also, you know,
over.
He was like a bigger and less successful R-Truth.
Fundamentally different gimmicks. Shad wasn't a rapper, he was a street thug. There's a difference. And I think Cryme Tyme should have been given runs with the tag belts, considering how over they were.
When he was in Cryme Tyme, I hated him. He sucked ass and played second fiddle to JTG all the time.
K. Personal feelings aside, they were very popular.
They were frequently annoying and the Dirt Sheet was probably one of the worst things I have ever seen.
I believe you mean "Word Up", because The Dirt Sheet was Miz and Morrison's show, and it was damn entertaining at times.
However, when the split happened, he had so much promise.
Here's the thing. He had
promise, but until he broadens his skill sets, he's not going to be able to live up to his promise. he definitely has potential. He just needed to go back to FCW to work on his ring, mic, and crowd-connecting skills.
He could have easily gotten over a dominating heel but the WWE gave up him.
I agree that WWE should have given him more of a chance, but I don't think he could have been as good a dominating heel as you think, not without some more training.
After the strap match, it seemed as though the WWE had chosen who was going to be the Jannety of the tag team and unfortunately, the picked wrong.
TOTALLY disagree. JTG has more charisma and is more over. He also actually has a distinct gimmick that no one else in the WWE has, and he plays it to perfection. Shad just doesn't seem believable in his new role...yet.
Yes, he wasn’t too good on the mic but he was good in the ring and has the physique to carry off being an imposing character in the WWE.
If I may quote you for a second:
"He's big, so is Kane. He's strong, so is Mark Henry".
What makes Shad different from all the other monsters they have?
However, the WWE gave up on that and sent him back to FCW.
I don't think they gave up on him by sending him to FCW. I think they sent him there so he can
improve and come back better than ever. If they "Gave up" on him he'd be future endeavor'd by now.
JTG has been mediocre since that feud and I thought it had a lot of fuel left in the tank.
Hard to do anything when you rarely get TV time. And yeah I think that feud should have gone on longer. Oh well.
I can almost guarantee that Shad will come back to the WWE with the Cryme Tyme gimmick in tow.
Possibly. They should never have split them up in the first place, in my opinion.
They have no faith in him getting over without being a rapper and that is where they were wrong.
Again, Cryme Tyme is NOT a "rapper" gimmick.
Of the two men, I always preferred Shad. JTG was just another small and athletic heel
Face for the past few years.
whilst Shad had more promise, I thought.
Size-wise, yes. Talent-wise...well, maybe. Time will tell.
I saw him live in April, he got right up in my face and I knew that he could pull off being a good heel.
Good, sure. But good
enough to stand out? I'm not so sure.