TNA has not given a single clue as to who they might be but everyone is tossing names out their as to who it might be.
TNA has not given a single clue? They've been giving us clues all year! That's why people are theorizing on it - there's been so many clues and it's been written so well that "they" could be any number of people: TNA Veterans, Hogan & Bischoff, Main Event Mafia, Jarret & Foley, Heyman, etc.
Look at the clues they have given us.
1. First of all, Abyss has been at the centre of it all so whoever they are, there is some connection to him. At the same time, the only other people who have referenced "they" and seem to know who they are, are Sting and Samoa Joe. What are the connections between those three? All are TNA veterans and all are former TNA champions so could "they" be a group of TNA veterans? Or is it a reforming of the Main Event Mafia (Sting & Joe were in it and Abyss qualifies as he's a former champion).
2. Everyone Abyss has attacked all made their names in another company. In fact, and correct me if Im wrong on this, Im pretty sure everyone he has attacked was bought in to TNA after Hogan and Bischoff came in, or least post-2009 era, so could "they" be TNA veterans led by Jarret and/or Sting trying to claim TNA back from Hogan & Bischoff. Or again, Main Event Mafia trying to reclaim their spots from the new guys?
3. Abyss gone back to being an uncontrolable monster - is this a clue that it's James Mitchell? He used to "control" him before. However, could it be Sting controlling him? The last fued Abyss was in when Mitchell was controlling him was with Sting back in 2006/2007. Sting eventually "freed him" from Mitchell but not before taking control of Abyss himself. Could Sting be the one behind Abyss? But who is he controlling him for? TNA vets? MEM? Jarret and Foley? NWO Wolfpac? Also, there was a kidnapping in that fued too - a reference to Samoa Joe's kidnapping? Talking of which....
4. Samoa Joes kidnap. Its worth remembering that Joe said that they said this time it will be different this implies whoever they are, have been in TNA before. Mitchell and the new church? Except this time with Daniels and maybe Raven? Could it be Jarret and Foley? After all both were treated badly by Bischoff & Hogan but all of a sudden made a quick u-turn and everything was fine - did they hatch a plan so it would be different next time? And again, could it be the Main Event Mafia? These are all people who have tried to control TNA before and ultimately failed. So all you people who have been saying "it better be someone outside of TNA or it's gonna suck" I think are going to be let down.
5. Sting referencing "smoke & mirrors" and "deception". It's pretty safe to say this means the people you think are the good guys are the bad guys, and vice verse. So if Hogan and Bischoff are the bad guys then it means whoever has been against them Abyss, Sting and Nash are the good guys. You perhaps could put Jarret and Foley in with the good guys too. Them sucking up to H&B could be part of Stings smoke & mirrors.
6. Now this clue may not mean anything as TNA do have a habit of not following through on things but remember when people were getting laid out backstage and a playing card was put on them? As far as I remember, this was never solved. Why was a playing card put them? Is that a clue? Well, I know this may be stretching it a bit but
..you know when you type something into google and before you hit enter it comes up with suggestions? Do that with James Mitchell. The first suggestion you get is James Mitchell poker. Apparantly, theres a famous poker player called James Mitchell. When Russo was thinking this out, did he simply just type james mitchell into google to see what clues he could drop in?! Or was this just an angle that simply didnt play out?
I personally dont have a clue who it could be I used to think it was hogan & bischoff, then I thought it was james mitchell, now Im veering towards TNA veterans led by Jarret & Foley but I could also see it being MEM. I dont see it being an outside group, its someone with TNA connections. So, in my opinion this rules out the following:
Ex-wwe guys: Haas, Benjamin and Carlito are all working on contracts elsewhere so it would a stable of Mike Knox, Paul Burchill and Gregory Helms? I dont think so. And theres no way they could afford Batista.
ROH: no way would Cornette work with tna and no way would they work with him.
UFC: why would ufc get involved with tna? In their eyes, pro-wrestling is beneath them plus they are ultra-successful, they dont need tna. Also, UFC has become popular because its real. They wouldnt jeopardise that success by alligning themselves with a fake sport as it would blur the lines between real and fake and theyre selling point is their shit is real.
Wilpon: Yes, its spelt wilpon, not wilson or wilbon! It wont be them anyway, to small time and theyve even had to delay their promotion until january. Theres more chance of it being the Insane Clown Possee!
Shane MacMahon: No way. 2 reasons. First, if he wanted to be invloved in wrestling he could easily have a lot control in wwe. Secondly, even though he doesnt work at wwe Vince is still his dad. Is he going to risk his relationship (and all that monaaay!) to help the competitor? At least when Vince put his dad out of business he did it by buying him out, not his competitors.
Finally, Id just like to say that the OP about RVD isnt that ridiculous, hes just coming at from the wrong angle. In real life, we all know RVD was taken out for contractual reasons so this was added to the plan at the last minute and was, I assume, never part of the storyline they started months ago. However, in storyline, look how RVD has been booked. Hes been the Cena of TNA. He won the title really quickly after coming in. Not only that but he won it not only after having 2 matches on Impact but also 2 matches on the ppv just days before making him super-human like Cena. He then proceeds for the next few months to not only cut shitty face promos but to win, and get the pin, in practically every match he is. When was the last time you saw RVD pinned? Not only that, but when was the last time you saw him in a tag match and he didnt get the pin? All of these things winning all the time and shitty face promos win the kids crowd over but pisses off the true wrestling fan, just like Cena. Also, you have the whole TNA roster saying what a great guy he is, Hogan bigging him up as the face of the company (smoke and mirrors again face = heel) and when someone is being pushed that hard as a face then only one thing can happen next heel turn. I wouldnt be at all surprised if RVD is in on it not as part of they but in with a heel hogan and bischoff.
Sorry for the long post Ive been thinking about this for a while and kudos to TNA for that. We all like to bash tna for things not making sense but I think with this storyline, so far, its been better that way and maybe us wrestling fans should learn to be more patient. Of course, with Russo being a massive fan of Lost we could all be wrong and Rick Flair did actually die in that plane crash in the 70s and everything weve seen is him trying to meet up with the important people in his life (they) so he can move on to the next one!