TNA dont need to win over anyone who comes on here and discuss TNA because we are all obviously watching it if we have an opinion on it.
How could they win over someone who doesnt watch it? Im not sure there is anything they can do to be honest. TNA seems to have this stigma attached to it and Im not sure they can do much to shift that. They could have a 15 year old no one has heard of as World Champion and people would still complain (I know I would). They could replace all their big stars (RVD, Angle, Hogan, Sting etc) with guys no one knows or cares about, who can perform a corkscrew moonsault, but I still dont think that would achieve much.
The best thing TNA could do is keep going in exactly the same direction they are going. A few people have mentioned TNA should be more like it was in 2005. I dont have any facts but Im pretty certain TNA is a lot more well known and popular now than it was in 2005. So going back in time and to a product that was less popular than it is now would be a huge mistake. They should continue to push Mr Anderson, Rob Van Dam, Matt Morgan and Fortune as their main stars and forgot about trying to push who the fans want to see. Because every fan wants to see someone else pushed. So thats never going to work.
Just stick to what you are doing (TNA) and continue pleasing the fans you already have. Because if you havent already won over the fans from WWE (they won me over from WWE a couple of years ago), I dont think there is anything they could do, short of calling themselves WWE: iMPACT! Wrestling.
GrandSword - I like you're idea of pushing one of the Guns but Alex Shelley would need one hell of a push before he could step in the ring with Rob Van Dam. If he got in the ring with RVD next week, I would expect Van Dam to win in under 5 minutes. Alex Shelley is nowhere near Van Dams level and he would need a lot of time invested in him to get him to that level and that time could be spent on Mr Anderson, Matt Morgan, AJ Styles, Pope etc and that's the problem TNA have. Not enough TV time.