I take a bit of offense to this, as the "dial tone personalities" thing is my creation, and I never once trashed this I just posed the question, is all. I certainly never said it was incapable of being a gimmick that might actually draw (heat or fans).
I do think you fail to understand that there's more to wrestling than either having no personality or having a gimmick, though. There are plenty of guys who have a personality but have no gimmick take Christian Cage, for example. Same goes for Edge, Kevin Nash, Kurt Angle, etc.
What in the world are you talking about?
Christian is Captain Charisma, that's his GIMMICK. Edge is the Rated R Superstar, one of the most gimmicky wrestlers of this modern era! Kurt Angle is the Olympic Hero, that's his GIMMICK. To say none of those guys have a gimmick is outrageous. It makes me wonder if you even know what a gimmick actually is.
As for this thread, I think it may have been better to have held off on the thread until she debuted on Impact, seeing as some people are complaining about how people are reacting to this signing negatively. Most people, like me, likely haven't even heard or seen of this new Knockout before so their own opinion can be based solely on the gimmick she's going to have. Telling people to wait to judge until they actually see her is kind of contradicting the thread asking for opinions on the signing.
As for my opinion, I really haven't a clue what to think. I can't even imagine how this is going to play out so I'm definitely curious. I'm not sure TNA really needs more Knockouts that are, in a sense, more like the Beautiful People, though. That's basically all the Knockouts Division has right now, besides a very select few.