CaptainZaltan
Getting Noticed By Management
Yeah, some people on this site are needlessly obnoxious. The thing is, I don't think anyone has ever convinced anyone of anything in the history of the world by being a prick. Anyone with half a brain (or more) in their head would realize this. It just pisses people off, makes them get defensive, and makes them take an even stronger stance against the position of the person insulting them.
Case in point. I don't think you'd be taking THIS hard of a stance against Cena's mic abilities if you were thinking about this rationally. I'll give you Paul Heyman, and I think anyone would be hard pressed to find a better promo guy in the history of the business than him. Some of the others you mentioned (Angle, Truth, Ziggler) can definitely talk, but are they better than Cena? Can they engage the audience as well as Cena? I personally don't think so. The only other person you mentioned that I'd put in Cena's league is Bully Ray, and maybe Road Dogg.
As for the more glaringly wrong names on your list....Del Rio couldn't hold a crowds attention if he was on fire. Stephanie Mcmahon is so horrible that I've been actively using "graduate from the Stephanie Mcmahon school of acting" as the highest insult I can think of for an actress since the Attitude era. HHH can't put anyone over but himself. Titus and Barrett aren't anywhere near Cena's level. The Miz is well spoken, but people don't care what he has to say. Cena is better than all those guys, and to be clear, I hate most of Cena's promos. I think his comedy act is horrible, I despise his "listen to the crowds energy!" scthick whenever he's getting booed, and I think if he was as good on the mic as he's cracked up to be, he would be able to talk his way out of being booed by half the audience. But that's not really about Cena's speaking ability, rather it's about what he's saying and who he's trying to entertain. His lines are likely written for him by someone else, and he has to stay within the boundaries of the character he's portraying. A good actor can deliver shitty lines with passion and ability. A great public speaker can be saddled giving a presentation on something inherently boring. And a good talker like Cena can be stuck playing a character that grates on the nerves of the adult audience. And yeah, he's good. You can tell that he's good because whether the crowd is booing him or cheering him, they are LISTENING to him. And responding. They are engaged. The guy can talk, he's just not bothering to say anything I want to hear. Because I'm not the audience he's trying to appeal to.
Case in point. I don't think you'd be taking THIS hard of a stance against Cena's mic abilities if you were thinking about this rationally. I'll give you Paul Heyman, and I think anyone would be hard pressed to find a better promo guy in the history of the business than him. Some of the others you mentioned (Angle, Truth, Ziggler) can definitely talk, but are they better than Cena? Can they engage the audience as well as Cena? I personally don't think so. The only other person you mentioned that I'd put in Cena's league is Bully Ray, and maybe Road Dogg.
As for the more glaringly wrong names on your list....Del Rio couldn't hold a crowds attention if he was on fire. Stephanie Mcmahon is so horrible that I've been actively using "graduate from the Stephanie Mcmahon school of acting" as the highest insult I can think of for an actress since the Attitude era. HHH can't put anyone over but himself. Titus and Barrett aren't anywhere near Cena's level. The Miz is well spoken, but people don't care what he has to say. Cena is better than all those guys, and to be clear, I hate most of Cena's promos. I think his comedy act is horrible, I despise his "listen to the crowds energy!" scthick whenever he's getting booed, and I think if he was as good on the mic as he's cracked up to be, he would be able to talk his way out of being booed by half the audience. But that's not really about Cena's speaking ability, rather it's about what he's saying and who he's trying to entertain. His lines are likely written for him by someone else, and he has to stay within the boundaries of the character he's portraying. A good actor can deliver shitty lines with passion and ability. A great public speaker can be saddled giving a presentation on something inherently boring. And a good talker like Cena can be stuck playing a character that grates on the nerves of the adult audience. And yeah, he's good. You can tell that he's good because whether the crowd is booing him or cheering him, they are LISTENING to him. And responding. They are engaged. The guy can talk, he's just not bothering to say anything I want to hear. Because I'm not the audience he's trying to appeal to.