My first thread I posted on this site was about a Four Horsewomen faction in the Nexus mould featuring Charlotte, Becky Lynch, Sacha Banks, and Bayley. Many are suggesting that the four of them be brought up together to save an ailing division. I'm starting to become less sure that that's the way.
Sure, throw the four (arguably) most over and ready divas from NXT to run roughshod over the Divas division. It would be kind of like throwing gasoline on an unlit fire, or debuting the nWo against the Mean Street Posse.
The Diva's division is a wretched mess that only needs some simple clean fixes. The heels and faces need to be finalized. Booking Paige with heel like promos and booking Naomi as a face is confusing. Why hasn't Emma turned heel on Raw? What the hell do the Bella Twins stand for? Why is Natalya a valet? Why isn't Eva Marie a heel valet? The list of problems goes on and fricken on.
Sending in the NXT girls isn't the answer. It's going to be freaking sweet, but they need to enter into a balanced division in order to not risk becoming a part of the problem. The last thing we need is Charlotte and Bayley on Total Divas. Until WWE consciously reinvigorates their women's division, a debut by any NXT gal can wait.
It used to be that the Total divas had their own matches and then there was the divas title angles. Now, the divas title is Total Divas. Total is what it is, if it's making WWE money then good. They need to go back to having the Total Divas in a separate angle from the title divas.
It's not that we want the NXT girls in WWE, we want WWE to have a proper women's division, and we perceive debuting these ladies as bringing NXT match quality booking with them. Sadly, that may not be the case.
Fix the divas division now, then add new talent to the mix. Paige and Natalya should be the top faces and not on TD. Top heels should be Naomi and the Twins. Everyone needs an alignment and they need to be consistent.
Next; book a feud outside of the title. Titles need number one contenders. There are enough main roster divas and five hours of major network TV (Main Event and Superstars notwithstanding) to support minimum two divas angles.
NXT has three different feuds involving women with one hour of programming per week. Charlotte/Bayley/Emma/Dana, the women's title, and Carmella/Bliss. Granted we don't see all three but these are active feuds. Bliss screwing Enzo and Cass out of the tag titles was brilliant. Put the ladies with the dudes.
Three main roster wrestlers have female parings? Tyson and Natalya, Rose and Rosa and, I guess Ziggler and Lana. Alicia Fox and Layla are barely on TV. Did they forget Summer Rae turned heel and joined Miz?
It's all pretty simple stuff that doesn't require reinventing the wheel. Clear characters, long term planning, more that one feud, have some overlap with the lads. Putting three or four new characters into a muddle mixture isn't going to save the broth.
If they did go for an NXT divas invasion, they have to be careful. Oversaturation is an issue. I believe there are enough talented divas in NXT to keep the division going. Carmella, Bliss, Dana Brooke, Emma, and others could keep it going. They could bring Blue Pants in more regularly. Eva Marie is pending to debut there (she needs to turn heel more than John Cena).
NXT would recover losing its four best, but the main roster isn't ready to receive them. Keep things simple and realign the division to wrestling basics. And make that damn title gold. I don't care if they have to fight over wrestling superstar Barbie's title. They could at least fight over a butterfly that looks like a prize.