I agree with this, but then you have to ask why to run a 'reveal' style storyline in the first place. A huge part of the interest for people has been in the reveal for who these masked guys are; unless they're Mexican, that's always been a huge interest for people. So if you know all of your surprise reveals are going to suck, why run with the angle in the first place?However, taking into account of what the OP said, which makes perfectly sense, I want you to reconsider some things. First of all, except Eric Bischoff and Jeff Jarrett and maybe Bully Ray, who else do you expect to see as a member? I mean, who's available at the market store at this moment who can be a big enough reveal for you? Snitsky? Ezekiel Jackson? Maybe Hulk Hogan's son, Nick? Or do you want to see Kevin Nash? -again- This isn't 1996. All the big names are with the WWE and will continue to be for a long time. Only John Morrison is available, but as the OP stated, I can't buy the "Shaman of Sexy" as a beer drinking, ass kicking s.o.b..
From the WWE, I'd expect this. Their booking is an absolute mess these days. TNA, however, has tried to pride itself on intricate, detailed storylines. Why set yourself up to disappoint people?