TheTruNoLimit said:
In fairness to mention of Kane not being agile enough to hold the title... I believe there's somebody such as THE BIG SHOW holding the ECW title, right? And he did hold Heavyweight WWE Gold just a couple years ago... now explain how Big Show is capable of holding a title, yet Kane isn't. Big Show's move-set consists of a head butt, a chop, a leg drop, and a choke-slam. This is not too mention that he's about the slowest thing to ever step foot in the ring (besides a Great Khali or an injured Kevin Nash whose bad knee made it impossible for him to get around in the ring). Even Hulk Hogan can move better than Big Show.
Big Show doesn't need to be wearing a belt, either. He can't wrestle his way out of a wet grocery bag. He slows down any match he's involved in to a snail's pace. Kane and Big Show are nothing more than circus attractions when it comes to wrestling. One is big, bald, and has cool pyro. The other is big, slow, and useless.
TheTruNoLimit said:
Besides that, Kane's move-set and style actually works well if he's a heel. I'd agree and say that Kane really isn't fit to be a face because faces have to have a certain ability, as you called it, explosiveness. Kane plays the dominant heel very, very well.
Kane doesn't have nearly enough depth to make it as a credible title holder. He is a lot like Batista when it comes to the types of matches he can wrestle. All high impact with no serious cohesiveness or well-set pace to the match. It's usually just a series of strung together moves that culminates in a gimmie finisher.
TheTruNoLimit said:
And, aside from this, WWE gave Kane heat back-stage at a house show because Kane executed a standing drop kick. WWE does not want Kane to perform agile moves. They told him he may only perform power moves. This is an issue as well, especially since I've seen Kane do a leap-frog and a drop kick, even spring boarding from the ropes inside to the floor outside with a body splash... Kane is capable of more in the ring, but WWE doesn't want him to be more in the ring, whether it's to protect the big guys from injury, or to set the big guys aside from the more athletic guys so when they get in the ring their styles have great contrast, I don't know.
This is another example of piss-poor management on the part of the front office with regards to the use of talent. I personally would be much more afraid of an agile, nimble, big man, than one who is perpetually grounded in their offense. For an example of an ideal big man, look at Mike Awesome circa 1999 in ECW. He was a 280 pounder that could fly like a cruiserweight and outpower nearly anyone in the business.
TheTruNoLimit said:
Besides, I remember Kane facing Edge in the finals of the Gold Rush tournament... entertaining. Kane faced Edge at Vengeance, and it was entertaining. Steel Cage Match and a Stretcher match against Edge on Raw, entertaining! Kane had plenty of entertaining matches with Edge last year. Kane also had two good matches against Benoit in '04 at Bad Blood and on Raw with the title on the line. He had a good match against HBK as well at Unforgiven a couple years back in '04.
I've never liked Kane's offense because he's always been too slow. Not methodical, so don't get me wrong. Just slow. Taste is subjective as to whether or not any of his encounters are entertaining, but I don't like watching a wrestler so slow that he can get passed by an old lady on her walker. I couldn't stand his wrestling since his days as the Fake Diesel and as Isaac Yankem.
TheTruNoLimit said:
Bottom lining it, Kane is still a more capable big man, he just needs to work with the right opponent. Aside from that, Kane's matches against Umaga were half-way decent for big man matches.
Umaga is a tub of guts, but that son of a bitch can move with a purpose. His gimmick is recycled tripe, but it doesn't matter because he moves with speed, power, and agility. Kane needs to be reconfigured physically because what he's done so far hasn't helped to establish him in the upper pantheon of WWE alumni. He has a gimmick that's been over since 1997. Now if only the in-ring action could match that in quality.