You know who I would give a title shot? Benjamin...why? I am sick of hearing about 'how great he is' he does ONE good match a year, his only decent mic run was when he had his momma with him, yeah he may be athletic, big deal...it means nothing, he doesn't entertain me save for the MiTB matches, stale and boring the other 364 days of the year. Give him a title shot, have him lose and let us never speak of him again.
Thank God someone stated it.
Now for my choice, I would pick Umaga. Albeit he'd have to be built up as the unstoppable monster heel he was once and him being the unstoppable ruthless monster he is strapping a belt on him would make him look like a legit champion. The only reason stopping Umaga from being a championship contender is he needs a mouthpiece. Estrada is gone so he would need another manager.