How would you remedy the roster imbalance?

Bobby B

Time to play the game
Simple scenario:

On October 1st Smackdown will make its long awaited move to SyFy. Like when the show moved to MyNetwork TV a few years back, Smackdown will most likely recieve a talent shot in the arm from Raw to try and boost ratings and give the show a general all round lift.


As a general rule you can't have guys coming in without guys going out (unless there's a number shortage), so while I expect big names will come in from Raw, I expect a few names from Smackdown to make the switch across to the A show.

Let's make things a tad interesting

We could be here all day if I said give us a complete list of 20 talent moves you would make to try and create a perfectly balanced line-up. It would make for a pretty hectic thread, and besides which any moves that may happen would be done under the guise of a draft lottery, where only a handful of drafts are done (at the top level anyway).

So...

... how about 5 drafts total, both in and out, to make some attempt to rebalance Raw and Smackdown.

My Picks:

From Raw to Smackdown:

Randy Orton - There has to be a big name move doesn't there? It was Triple H last time, and for me it can be one of two people. Randy Orton or John Cena. Cena is still the number one draw, so for me he stays on the number one show. Orton is over as a face, but I don't feel his character has had chance to adapt to that role yet. A year or so on Smackdown will do him no harm what-so-ever.

The Miz - As much as I think Edge will most likely end up being the other big name, it's who I would move, not who I think will move. For me The Miz is a main eventer waiting to happen. But I really think he could get lost on Raw. At best come October he will be the number 4 guy on the show (behind Cena, Sheamus and a returning Triple H). He could survive, sure, but any man who you think could be money in the future needs time away from John Cena. There is a money feud between him and Randy Orton waiting to happen, and I could easily see a Smackdown build of this feud main eventing next years Wrestlemania.

Ted DiBiase - wow it's been a bad few months for him. Drowning on Raw while his ex tag-team partner Cody Rhodes grows on Smackdown and NXT. Needs to split with Maryse, and restart the car on Smackdown. His career has stalled in the last 4 months.

From Smackdown to Raw:

Kofi Kingston - Raw is hugely short on main event level faces. Assuming one of Orton and Cena moves, you end up with two main event faces on Raw (likely Cena and Hunter). Beyond that, it's a tussle between Evan Bourne and John Morrison for the third spot. I'm not saying either could never be World Champion, but they are a long way off right now. Kofi at the very least could hold the title, and he's a perfect fit in the upper-mid card on Raw.

The Big Show - He's just what Raw needs right now. A face on the cusp of the main event who is capable of dropping down a little. Christian would've fit here too.
 
I agree with you in that Smackdown does need some big talent to compete especially with the big move.....I would LOVE to see Randy Orton move to Smackdown....I feel as though he has become kind of stale as of late on RAW....dont bash because it is an opinion.....he will firmly stay the number two face as long as Cena is ever on RAW....he could become the top face on Smackdown because there really isnt any other face besides Undertaker who comes and goes every now and then...so Randy would be a perfect choice so he can adapt better as the top face.....Ted DiBiase needs to go, as long as they dont pair him up with Cody that will be fine....The Miz needs to stay on RAW because he has the contract so that basically excludes him from Smackdown for the foreseeable future....I would also love for Edge to return to Smackdown.....he could either feud with Randy for Mania or either Christian which will be great.....think of the feuds with these two....Randy vs Alberto....Randy vs McIntyre....Randy vs Punk.....Edge vs Christian.....Edge vs Kofi.....Edge vs Kaval to put him over......Randy and Swagger could reignite their feud.....or they could make Edge face again and pair him with Christian and win the tag titles, then split and feud at Mania resulting in a Christian heel turn....the possibilities are endless....also, Big Show should just stay on Smackdown, thats where he belongs.....just like Rey Mysterio belongs to Smackdown, and Cena belongs to RAW....Big Show also is NOT on the cusp of the main event....he is just a perennial contender because he is like a what 3 or 4 time world champion.....if he ever holds the title again it will be because of loyalty like Kane....RAW doesnt need stars at the moment....they have Nexus which is creating new stars.....Alex Riley is coming in.....before you know Triple H will be back hogging up the title scene....Ezekiel Jackson will be back and better than ever to dominate. and I truly believe he will be main eventing in some capacity by this time next year...The Miz is also another star....they have plenty to deal with
 
Guys I would send to SD

Edge - Is Edge tweener right now? Or is he still heel? Or did he turn face again? Does anyone fucking know? Edge just isn't doing much on Raw right now. Main event scene is way too crowded.

Jericho - If he stays, put him on Smackdown. They need more guys in the main event picture.

John Morrison - He just gets overshadowed on Raw. He isn't going to come out and cut an amazing promo. Just put him on SD so he can put on some good wrestling matches and he's over as hell with the fans.

R-Truth - Another midcarder who is getting overshadowed on Raw. He can wrestle, and the crowd fucking loves him. Back to SD is the place for him.

I know all these guys were on SD last year, but they shouldn't have been drafted to Raw in the first place. I say that makes the rosters pretty close, with Raw having Sheamus/Cena/Orton/Miz and SD with Taker/Punk/Edge/Jericho as their top guys.
 
I would move Kofi, Morrison, Bourne and Danielson over to Smackdown and Mcintyre, Show, and Rhodes over to raw.

Reason for this is that Smackdown should be the "wrestling" show, so why not stack it with the best wrestlers? And move the "entertainers" over to raw. I mean, I'd tune in to Smackdown for a Danielson/Punk main event. Come to think of it, I'd pay to see them go all out ROH style on PPV.

Also Vince should get his chequebook out and try to sign Davey Richards and get him to debut on smackdown.
 
If I were to choose I would have to go with:

To SMACKDOWN!

Randy Orton: Somewhat the same reason stated in the OP. I believe Smackdown can gain much more from Randy moving there, than Randy loosing by moving to Smackdown! Now that Randy is a "tweener", it makes it kind of crowded (and I use this term lightly) to have the two top stars in the company at RAW. Not to mention all the other top stars the show already has. Randy moving to Smackdown will be a great benefit for Smackdown as it could give it a tremendous boost in star power, which quite frankly, SD! really lacks at the momment.. To the same time, it doesn't hurt Raw too much considering the fact that John Cena will still be there.

Edge: I feel he is the second best person to get transferred. It seems to be the right thing to do. Edge has really gotten stale as of late. Not even his somewhat involvement in NEXUS is helping him out. With his move to SD!, it not only gives another mega boost in star power, it gives another "oppurtunity" for a good number of feuds. It would even give a possible chance for a re-union of Edge and Christian. Or in the very least, it could give a feud between Edge and Christian. Which I'm sure, most will agree that that would be something to look forward to.

Evan Bourne: I believe this guy can benefit more from SD!, than he can from RAW. Raw has always been more of a "promo" show. While SD! on the other hand has always been more of a "wrestling" show. Given the fact that Bourne rarely talks (cuts a promo), SD! could be a good way for him to show off his talents without having to say much. Also, he wouldn't get lost in the shuffle with all the top-stars currently in RAW like he has in the past.

To RAW:

Alberto Del Rio: It's been said that this guy is the "next big thing". So what not better way than to have him on the A-show. Alberto Del-Rio gets a good amount of heat as it is. With his move to RAW, he can start feuding with top stars. Thus, in turn, he can capitalize off the heat that the fans will give him as he feuds with the "best". Alberto Del-Rio is a great wrestler, it is only fitting that he is in the A-show, where he can get more exposure and truly become [one of] "the next big thing(s)"...

Lay-Cool: Having Lay-Cool on Raw could do wonders for the Diva's division. For one, Raw is the A-show (I think I've pointed this out too much), the place that Lay-Cool can get more exposure. Second, it could be a good way for Melina and Lay-Cool to continue their fued after NoC for the "Women's title Unification match". It goes without saying, the Diva's division is crap. But with Lay-Cool on Raw, it could, in the very least, give the RAW side of the Diva's division a good boost. However, to the same time, I am aware that the SD! locker room will be left with very little in the Divas division...go figure..
 
Here are my picks:

To Smackdown:

Randy Orton - of course it has to be Orton going to SD! He is way over right now, and will only be sharing the light with Cena on raw. There is right now no reason for two uber faces to be on one show. With Taker questionable, Orton would fit in nicely as the top face on SD!

Edge - You had put Miz, but I see the Miz being built like Edge, where he has smaller feuds, then cashes in MITB and becomes world champion, and once he holds the title for a bit, then moves to SD! (maybe by the next draft in may/june). So with that being said, Edge needs to go back to SD! He is a natural fit there, and will not be lost in the shuffle as much as he is on raw.

To Raw:

CM Punk - With the eventual demise of the SES (possibly as soon as next week) CM Punk will need a different direction to take. On SD!, he has faced most of the top guys over the past year and a half, and I don't think there is much more for him. It would be nice to see a Punk/Kingston feud and a Punk/Orton feud, but that would be it. Going over to raw, Punk can then feud with HHH, Cena, Morrison, and I think that would be good for him.

Kofi Kingston - With Orton gone from raw, and HHH's return questionable, there is a hole for a second top face. Queue in Kofi, who would nicely fit into this role. When Kofi's feud with Ziggler ends next week, and he persumably has no IC title, it will be time for Kofi to enter the main event. If he becomes the second top face on Raw, then this is a good possibility. On SD!, Kofi is still behind Taker, Orton, Mysterio, and Big Show. On Raw he would be behind Cena and HHH when he returns.

Drew McIntyre - This only makes sense because SD! is full of mid-card heels right now, and McIntyre will only get lost in the shuffle. He has been off track and hopefully a move to raw will set it straight.
 
Edge, Gabriel, Miz to Smackdown!


Big Show, Kaval to RAW

Simple, easy, efficient.

Edge is the main-eventer SD! needs. He was going great before his change to RAW after losing to Jericho at Mania. He's already done it all so why would he care if he was put on the B show? Gabriel could be the replacement-face for the IC Division when Kofi moves to the main event. A move to SD! and a face-transition for Miz might actually be what (in my mind) he needs. Both shows need main event ready faces, not just RAW. SD! has Rey, Big Show and Taker. One hardly appears and the other is well out of the main event picture. Swagger, Kane, Punk, McIntyre, Rhodes, Dolph, and Rio are all (besides Kane) young, future/current heel main eventers. Need some young faces other than Kofi. I think Miz fits the bill here.

Big Show could be the face RAW needs as previously stated just for a temporary fix until Creative can get some other young guy face and main event ready (Morrison?). Kaval I'd like on RAW because he too is a face that can bring some life to the mid-card. The US Title could have some rides between Bryan, Kaval, Bourne, etc. It'd be interesting.
 
To SD!
Edge-To me when I thought of SD! the last few yrs I thought Edge to me SD! is Edge and Edge should be On SD! so We can finally see a E&C reunion or Fued either will work.

HHH-This is the one I would Like to see but probally want. I loved HHH on SD! but if this one does happen I dont see happening tillthe Draft.

John Morrision-Bottom line he Should of NEVER moved John is a Wrestling Guy and SD! is the Wrestling Show.

TO RAW
Drew McIntyre-As Much as I despize this guy he needs to move to RAW He just dont fit on SD! to me I dont know just cant explain it.

Rey Mysterio-Hes been on SD! so long expect for that like yr. on Raw So its time for a change
 
To Smackdown:
Edge: Like everyone had said, Edge should of never went back to RAW, on SD he'd be the main event guy, tweener and won't have to share the light with stupid John Cena. SD is his show. He's really boring right now on RAW.
Evan Bourne: High flyer, being buried on raw. Mid carder. He should team with Kaval and have the tag team division reborn. These two would make tag matches exciting again if teamed together.
The Usos: No air time on RAW for them for the past weeks. On SD they could fued with Kaval and Bourne.
 
I don't think anyone on Smackdown should go to Raw. Raw's already stacked. They're also trying to push 5 or 6 guys at the same time in Nexus.

Edge- To me, along with Undertaker and Rey Mysterio, Edge is Smackdown. He's made that show worth watching, and he's been better on there than on Raw.

John Morrison - IMO, if they took him off of Raw out of the shadow of the Miz (A can't believe I just said that) so he can have more airtime. With the Nexus storyline, a lot of guys have been put on the back-burner, and Morrison is one of them.

The Hart Dynasty- As the WWE Tag-Team Champions, they can jump to any show they want. The problem is, since they won the titles, they haven't. So, I'd make them a regular part of Friday Night's. Where they can defend the belts and get airtime on a regular basis. Again, the Nexus storyline has put a lot of guys on the back-burner. The Hart Dynasty and the WWE Tag Team Titles are examples. We're just a week away from a PPV where every title is supposed to be on the line, and there's no match for the Tag Titles.
 
To Smackdown:

Edge: He belongs on SD he's like Mysterio, Taker and Batista (when he was in the company). He's alot better when he's on SD and he would be a great for the ratings.

Jericho: He is a top star and he would probably be used as a main eventer on SD like he should be.

JoMo: He should never of been moved to Raw, he is getting lost in the shuffle on Raw and I believe he could finally reach ME level on SD but he won't if he stays on Raw.

To Raw:

MVP: So he can reform the tag team with Mark Henry because he isn't going to get anywhere on his own.

I can't think of anymore so I'm only having 4 picks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,851
Messages
3,300,884
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top