I had it at Four and a half.
It told a great story, but they really tried too hard to force it to feel "epic" without just letting it happen. Shawn also at times seemed way to intent on making himself the focus, and he bordered on "overdoing it".
My only other big complaint was the use, or lack there of, of the cell. It seemed the structure was entirely unneccesary and underutilized. It was really only there to make the match feel bigger, it would have been the same match without the cage included.
These are just nitpicks though that keep the match from being considered five stars, it was still a great match, and by far the best from Mania this year.
