I still cannot believe Halo beat final Fantasy 7.
Halo has to be one of the most overrated games ever made. (let the red reputation commence from disgruntled Halo fans)
I think its popularity has been helped by the fact it was one of the first games available for the Xbox, much like Super Mario Bros. It also has become the "mascot" for the Xbox, which probably helps it enourmously. When people buy the xbox, they see Master Chief. Like mario or sonic
I have been gaming for years, and has console fps's go, it does not have a patch on things like Doom, Medal of Honour or Goldeneye.
Maybe I'm being old and grumpy(and a little biased), but I found ff7 to be one of the greatest rpgs ever made. It revolutionised the industry in the states. Never before had a console based rpg sold well outside Japan and here was a game that took the world by storm and created a legacy. I still play ff7 now and I still love every minute. I still feel shocked when Aeris dies. I still think Sephiroth is the meanest bad guy ever.
Anyway, back on topic.
I'm glad Goldeneye beat Halo. An oldschool fps that fully deserves to go the whole way in terms of how popular it had become, plus adding elements not seen in a normal console fps, like a zoomable sniper rifle.