EOY Awards
- Thread starter D-Man
- Start date
For god's sake, I never said I didn't think he was a good poster! I just haven't seen anything that would put him in the same league as someone like Razor!
SavageTaker
Everybody Has A Price!
Are you talking about me?
SavageTaker
Everybody Has A Price!
Razor > ST = Dave > Lariat
The reason Razor > ST, is because ST became a great poster after improving, while Razor was a great poster all along.
The reason Razor > ST, is because ST became a great poster after improving, while Razor was a great poster all along.
Shitty logic.
If ST were to become objectively better, who cares how good he started out?
How long until natural selection takes it's course with you and saves the board drivel like this?
SavageTaker
Everybody Has A Price!
So Razor is a better poster because he started out great? I don't think that it should matter how posters started out. What should matter is what they have done that makes them deserve the ROTY award.
New deal, if a rookie wins the DL, they get my pick. So out of you, Phoenix, The DMan, and... Well, maybe that is it for the rookies left.
And Razor has been consistently great from the beginning, and continues to be great to this day.
He has therefore done more than you.
He has therefore done more than you.
SavageTaker
Everybody Has A Price!
So...let's say that right now and until the end of the year people think I'm better than Razor (I'm not saying I am but I'm also not saying I am not) that would mean, according to your logic, that he deserves the ROTY award because he was great when he started?
Cena's Little Helper
Mid-Card Championship Winner
Why does anyone here really give a shit what Doc says? If this were about video games or sigs, then maybe I could see your reactions being justified. But, time and again, he's proven how ignorant he is about posters, since, after judging them, he admits that he's never even read their relevant posts.
He just admitted that he didn't like TM, but that he has never made an effort to interact with him. Seriously, caring about what this kid says is tantamount to holding a blind person's opinion on film in high regard.
He just admitted that he didn't like TM, but that he has never made an effort to interact with him. Seriously, caring about what this kid says is tantamount to holding a blind person's opinion on film in high regard.
One thing I love his how he thinks people who are considered "funny" (I don't think I'm funny, but some people do. Whatever.) don't deserve much credit for it. Effective humor definately adds something to a thread. It's why one of Jake's spam posts can trump FalKon and JKO's million.
It's because he wishes that he could be funny, but he isn't. Humor definetly is important if used correctly. Sam 4 adminz.
The Dewbliners
WZ's Whedonite. Now 20% Cooler
Thusly, I rarely try being funny. I always fail. For evidence of this, see the Veterans Day thread.
You were funny in there. Then you took TM seriously.
Fair enough. You think that all-around is important, I think that consistency in a concentrated area is important. We all have different standards of judging.
Yes. It's Rookie of the YEAR, not Rookie of the Month.
τδιγλε;1502828 said:
And I have said that if someone can direct me to their relevant posts I will read them and reevaluate my goddamn opinion! I am not calling Coco a bad poster by any means. I think he's quite good, just not AS GOOD as others, judging by what I've seen. Also, get the FUCK over this grudge of me you seem to have. I try to be the nicest person on here, and I make one single comment and you jump down my throat. I could care LESS if you think he's funny. Funny does not mean he's Rookie of the Year quality.
tdigle in Greek said:
I have had previous interactions with him and have observed his behaviors on the boards. I dislike his attitude towards negative comments he has had in the past, and that has turned me off of him. I have seen his responses to other posters, and I didn't like them. I'm sure eventually my opinion of him will turn around, as it does with a lot of people, but right now, I do not particularly like him.
Tdigle said:
That's low, seriously. Bind people can enjoy films, too, you know.
