I would agree with Edge if we were talking about an absence of a year or two. But, given the length of time that has passed, I have to ask, where do you draw the line? How long does a wrestler who made his bones have to be gone before he no longer can expect to automatically go straight to the top? If John Cena decided to take a 10 year break, and come back to wrestling at age 44, should he automatically get the top spot, even though an entire generation of wrestlers has come and gone? Cena earned his spot too...Or better yet...Jerry the King Lawler decides to have one last run. Lawler earned his spot 20 years before the Rock did, but he earned it. Guy was one of the greatest world champions of all time, should he automatically get the top spot, because of what he meant for the business previously? If a star NFL player retired for 7 years and wanted to return, should they automatically get their starting position back over whoever the current guy is? What's the time limit? Where do you draw the line?
I would say NO, just like I currently say that Edge is wrong. The WWE roster now looks nothing like it did when he left. The Rock isn't returning, he is on a nostalgia tour. The Rock WAS a great wrestler. But that 7+ year gap means you can't assume that the Rock IS a great wrestler still. He looks like he is still in great shape, but how the hell do we know if he can still put on a great match like he used to? If his match against Cena is lights out, and he can keep up with the best the WWE has to offer and look like he never lost a beat, sure, you let him resume his role at the top. But until you know that, you can't take the chance. 7 years is an awfully long time.
Yeah dude but The Rock is FAR better than anyone else in the roster right now, and they're basically trying to make money and hold the company. And what else do they have to main event a Wrestlemania? I've gone gone from wrestling basically since Shawn retired, and Ive come back because of The Rock vs Cena and see what hapers with the Streak, After this and Taker is gone, Im done too! Cheers.