ECW or TNA

[bmtangle]

Who cares I think their both great.

 

[gamehead]

It depends which ECW you're talking about. If it's WWECW then TNA by a longshot but if it's the old ECW than the winner is ECW but not by much

 

[daveamania]

It depends which ECW you're talking about. If it's WWECW then TNA by a longshot but if it's the old ECW than the winner is ECW but not by much

Agreed. TNA is a much better show. They bring guys from ROH in all the time plus they don't let the storyline take away from the rasslin'.

 

[grungy72]

Tna destroys wwecw in almost everyway i kinda wish ppl would start to realise and see that so we dont have to put up with what keeps getting thrown our way every fucking day lol

 

[Smokeydogg]

tna sucks i'd rather watch the new ecw

 

[ThE cErEbRaL aSsAsIn]

ecw tna has fat joe

 

[ecwrulz92]

i agree with the cereabrel assasin i like them both but i dont like samoa joe so i will go with ecw cuzz they got cm punk and test and they r two of my favorites

 

[.JoeY]

Since I have been watching ECW longer, I would choose ECW over TNA however, both are great companies, so it's hard to choose because each company has it's own, "hits & misses".

 

[ThE cErEbRaL aSsAsIn]

ecw hands down

 

[Hazard]

Exactly, depends on what you are talking about, Old ECW takes the cake easily, it wasn't just wrestling, like Paul E. said, it was a life style, counter culture, TNA gives great wrestling and all but it isn't bigger then what ECW was.
ECDub!

But the New ECW, TNA wins by a longshot.

 

[DXiRoNMaN]

TNA has the better wrestling, the writing is piss poor. it's also hard to watch because the commentary is so awful.

 

[carolinadude]

I'm guessing "ECW" means the original now-defunct company, since this new one is not ECW. ECW hands down.

 

[crazymike0907]

TNA is full of nothing but wrestlers that either arent good enough for WWE or weren't good enough to last in WWE. Half of their roster is ex-wwe guys. What's that tell ya? Plus all the majority of them do is piss & moan about how they were under-used in WWE (Christian, Rhyno, Dudleys). Go cry me a damn river guys jeeze! Sound like a bunch of little bitches.


not that the new ECW is much better, but I'm still going with that anyway. Hopefully, Heyman gets full control soon and really takes it to the extreme!!

 

[DxFreak]

I have gotta say TNA just because ECW is crap with the wayy heyman has been acting to the original ECW superstars

 

[Complex_Enigma]

Sure if this was a OLD ECW Vs TNA ECW wins hands down anyday of the week but this is the new ecw and TNA blows that shit outta the water in everyway possible, Commentators on Tna aint that bad, Better then a Tonned down Styles and especially Taz man that guy sold out Ecw almost as much as heyman did. And Rhino got fired for breaking a pot plant so he has every right to be bitter, Christian LEFT wwe, and became TNA Champion which he deserved in wwe

 

[newsboy_88]

well i'd have to say that it's sort of tied, but if i were to choose any right now... i'd have to say tna. tna has better wrestlers and they're more entertaining. though the way things are going in ecw, i'd have to say that soon mcmahon might just crack under the pressure and do the one thing that would save ecw, give heyman total creative control.

 

[bmtangle]

new ? who is the most underated and the most overrated in ECW and TNA?

 

[hahahaha]

Right now TNA...but let Paul Control more and push actual wrestling then WWECW may suceed.

But thats coming from a girl that like TNA over Smackdown and Raw

 

[Flippyskate21]

i say tna, i've been watching tna for awile now,and i think its improved since i first started watching, wwecw isn't as bad as people say, its improving just like tna is, so it is a close one

 

[iamwrestling]

TNA is full of nothing but wrestlers that either arent good enough for WWE or weren't good enough to last in WWE. Half of their roster is ex-wwe guys. What's that tell ya? Plus all the majority of them do is piss & moan about how they were under-used in WWE (Christian, Rhyno, Dudleys). Go cry me a damn river guys jeeze! Sound like a bunch of little bitches.


not that the new ECW is much better, but I'm still going with that anyway. Hopefully, Heyman gets full control soon and really takes it to the extreme!!

Man am I sick and tired of people who have never watched a TNA broadcast in their life saying stuff like that. Get this through your head man: CHRISTIAN TURNED DOWN WWE!!!!! Rhino was fired from WWE, yes, however WWE offered him a contract to join WWE brand part III (also known as WWECW) AND RHINO TURNED THEM DOWN!!!!! SAME THING WITH THE DUDLEYS!!!! They offered Jesse James and Billy Gunn contracts when they started DX again and THE OUTLAWS TURNED THEM DOWN!!!!! WWE has offered Sting contracts and he turned them down multiple times. WWE offered Nash a contract before and he turned it down. Now, as for TNAs roster being 50% WWE rejects, WRONG!

Christian (not a reject. WWE's a reject of Christian)
A1
Abyss
AJ Styles
Alex Shelley
Monty Brown
Andy Douglas
Austin Aries
Bobby Roode
Chase Stevens
Chris Harris
Chris Sabin
Eric Young
Christopher Daniels
Hernandez
Homicide
James Storm
Jay Lethal
Jeff Jarrett (also turned down WWE)
Johnny Devine
Petey Williams
Samoa Joe
Senshi
Sonjay Dutt
Sting

As for them not being big enough for WWE, then why did WWE make contract offers to Sting, Joe, Senshi, Hernandez, Monty Brown, Abyss, Christian, Rhino, Dudleys, Spike Dudley, Shane Douglas, etc and get turned down? If Joe's not big enough for WWE, then why did WWE create a lame attempt to clone him with Umaga? And, for the other guys there, I can't tell you about how good you are since you're too ignorant to even give TNA a chance and watch even one pay-per-view. But here, this is a great example of why TNA is so great.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5W2RGkuf4QI&mode=related&search=

If you want to prove that you're not ignorant, then watch it. And if you're man enough to admit that you were wrong, tell me your opinion of it afterwards.

 

[gamehead]

Man am I sick and tired of people who have never watched a TNA broadcast in their life saying stuff like that. Get this through your head man: CHRISTIAN TURNED DOWN WWE!!!!! Rhino was fired from WWE, yes, however WWE offered him a contract to join WWE brand part III (also known as WWECW) AND RHINO TURNED THEM DOWN!!!!! SAME THING WITH THE DUDLEYS!!!! They offered Jesse James and Billy Gunn contracts when they started DX again and THE OUTLAWS TURNED THEM DOWN!!!!! WWE has offered Sting contracts and he turned them down multiple times. WWE offered Nash a contract before and he turned it down. Now, as for TNAs roster being 50% WWE rejects, WRONG!

Christian (not a reject. WWE's a reject of Christian)
A1
Abyss
AJ Styles
Alex Shelley
Monty Brown
Andy Douglas
Austin Aries
Bobby Roode
Chase Stevens
Chris Harris
Chris Sabin
Eric Young
Christopher Daniels
Hernandez
Homicide
James Storm
Jay Lethal
Jeff Jarrett (also turned down WWE)
Johnny Devine
Petey Williams
Samoa Joe
Senshi
Sonjay Dutt
Sting

As for them not being big enough for WWE, then why did WWE make contract offers to Sting, Joe, Senshi, Hernandez, Monty Brown, Abyss, Christian, Rhino, Dudleys, Spike Dudley, Shane Douglas, etc and get turned down? If Joe's not big enough for WWE, then why did WWE create a lame attempt to clone him with Umaga? And, for the other guys there, I can't tell you about how good you are since you're too ignorant to even give TNA a chance and watch even one pay-per-view. But here, this is a great example of why TNA is so great.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5W2RGkuf4QI&mode=related&search=

If you want to prove that you're not ignorant, then watch it. And if you're man enough to admit that you were wrong, tell me your opinion of it afterwards.

Exactly! This is TNA wrestling. The WWE will never put on a great match like that. This match even got a five-star rating by Dave Meltzer. The WWE never had a 5-star rated match by him! But the WWF did and the last time they did that was in 1997! Nearly 10 years ago! With TNA great matches watch them become the greatest promotion in the world

 

[xdeadman17x]

for those of ya'll that say tna well FUCK U... the new ECW may not be the old ECW but it sure as hell better than tna i mean tna has wwe reject that can't carry good matches and that's y they got fired and if u dun't believe me look @ the ratings ECW >>>> tna bitches!

 

[ShaneRamlall]

Exactly! This is TNA wrestling. The WWE will never put on a great match like that. This match even got a five-star rating by Dave Meltzer. The WWE never had a 5-star rated match by him! But the WWF did and the last time they did that was in 1997! Nearly 10 years ago! With TNA great matches watch them become the greatest promotion in the world

Agreed...ECW well the new one anyways isnt doing better than it was before...Heyman might have little power but still cant put on better matchedslike TNA does...They have the best wrestling...From the X division and heavyweight division....Almost all their wrestlers can wrestle..Also all there chmpionship divisions are hot right now...Like the tag team isnt fucked up like WWE and the X divsion is way better than cruiserweight...The heavyweights are having great feuds...such as the joe/monty/rhino and CC/Sting as of last nights pay per view..Where else can you find action like thsi..No where else...TNA baby...

 

[lapel8533]

The dumb tna fans cheered when spike dudley jumped on top of abyss from the top balcuny. He weighs like a buck 50, jumping on abyss is like landing on a trampoling. They should of cheered abyss for taking that. Its not easy having even 150 pounds droped on you like that even if you are 350 and then having to catch it and make sure they land on top of you safely and make sure that "they" don't get hurt. TnA hands down

 

[iamwrestling]

The dumb tna fans cheered when spike dudley jumped on top of abyss from the top balcuny. He weighs like a buck 50, jumping on abyss is like landing on a trampoling. They should of cheered abyss for taking that. Its not easy having even 150 pounds droped on you like that even if you are 350 and then having to catch it and make sure they land on top of you safely and make sure that "they" don't get hurt. TnA hands down

The dumb TNA fans also cheered when spike's head was driven into tons of thumbtacks. They also cheered when he was thrown body first on the tacks. They also cheered when he was slammed back first on the tacks then pressed down even harder. Although, that was definitely not as good as hardcore stuff that happens on ECW on a weekly basis. Oh wait... ECW doesn't have no rules any more. If anyone is dumb it's anyone who watches ECW. Sure it's the same wrestlers and same names, but Big Show is the champion, The Dudleys (aka, the best tag team ever in ECW), Rhino (the last ever TV and World champion) both aren't there, the No Rules aren't there anymore.