Here's my MTFO moments...
1. Jeff Hardy wins the championship at Extreme Rules 2008/9? only to lose it like 2 minutes later when CM Punks cashes in MITB. I was at a bar watching it with a bunch of people. I was so excited that Jeff beat Edge after a great ladder match. Then after he collapses in the corner, you hear CM Punk's music, and everyone in the bar just freaks out and screams in disgust!! Out comes punk with his briefcase, and its all over...we were all horrified and still in shock.
2.Survivor Series 2007- Undertaker v Batista Hell In a Cell
This was for the World Heavyweight championship. The two men had been going back and forth for QUITE some time, and these guys were battered and bloody, and then, as Undertaker was about to tombstone Batista, the cameraman interferes and hits him with the camera. Its revealed to be Edge. I was screaming in my house, the neighbor came over...lol. I was so MTFO.
3. Summerslame 2008- Edge v Undertaker, Hell in a Cell.
This was where Taker chokeslammed Edge from the top of the ladder to 'hell' thru the ring.

I remember our friends at my place were all screaming like schoolkids like that was the only thing we watched that night.
4. The re-debut of Y2J. Back in Nov. 2007. Granted, it was the worst kept secret with all those crytpic codes, but the way he interrupted Orton's passing of the torch, with all those jokes, was so needed. I so missed him, and was glad to see him back.
5. The return of Christian to WWE in 2009. Oh man...I've been a Christian Mark for SOOOO long. I was hoping to see him at the Royal Rumble that year. But the 'net probably kinda killed the swirl on that. But it was even better to have him return on tv. I was so glad Captain Charisma came back.
6. Armageddon 2008. Jeff Hardy wins his first WWE Championship in a 3 way vs Edge and HHH. Oh man...I was so excited. I think I was just as excited as the fans in the arena. Even watching it on the best of Smackdown DVD, I still get goosebumps, and watching the best of Jeff's dvd, you just can feel the emotion that was building to that moment for him.