I'm going to vote for The Vicar Of Dibley here.
Personally, I love Drew Carey and Whose Line Is It Anyway is a fantastic show. If it were WLIIA that was facing The Vicar Of Dibley, I would have voted very differently. As it is though, I must vote for Vicar Of Dibley. Dawn French was incredible in this show and her performance as the Vicar was pretty good, if not well known. It really was a brilliant show by one of the best British female comediennes, if not thee best. It seemed so innocent and yet so complex in many ways and really does give you a few laughs out of nothing.
Vicar Of Dibley for me.