Saying Joe Dumars is a bad GM is like saying Michael Jordan is a horrible basketball player. Joe Dumars is one of, if not the best GM in the NBA and if you ask anybody who knows anything about the NBA who the best Gms in the NBA are, Joe D will be near the top of everyones list. The reason he drafted Darko over Melo was because we already had Tayshaun at small forward and we didnt draft D Wade because we had Chauncey and Rip. And when Joe D traded Darko to Orlando he got their 2007 first round pick and that pick turned out to be Rodney Stuckey, so if he didnt draft Darko he wouldnt have gotten Stuckey. That means Stuckey is the guy you need to start critiquing, and so far he has been pretty damn good. Not everyone is perfect and if he could Joe D would take back the picks of Mateen Cleaves and Rodney White, but he more then made up for those picks by drafting the likes of Tayshaun Prince, Jason Maxiell, Stuckey, and Mehmet Okur. As well as the trades he made to get Rip, Sheed, and Ben Wallace, and the signings of Chauncey and Antonio McDyess
The Pistons dont need to rebuild, but saying that Joe D is only good at tinkering and not at rebuilding is completely wrong. He is great at both. Although the Pistons did make the playoffs the year before he took over, that was in the shortened 41 game season and during the offseason after that year the Pistons best player, Grant Hill, left Detroit. By the way Hill was going to sign as a free agent in Orlando, but Dumars being the great GM that he is was able to pull off a sign and trade to get Ben Wallace and Chucky Atkins which was an amazing trade. So the team that Dumars inherited was far from a playoff caliber team. And that is why they went 32 and 50 his first year as GM. Then in only his second year as GM they went 50 and 32, and in just his 4th year as GM the Pistons won the NBA title. Not only that, but there was not one player on that Championship team that was on the Pistons roster when Dumars took over. In just 4 years he got 13 new players and they were Champions. If thats not rebuilding I dont know what is. Before you look up the Pistons roster from when Dumars took over to try and prove me wrong, Lindsey Hunter was on the Pistons the season before Dumars took over, but he was a free agent that offseason and Joe D did not resign him. I guess if you want to still count Lindsey to try and find a hole in my argument then go right ahead, it does not change the fact that Joe Dumars is an amazing GM and he completely rebuilt a bad team and turned them into Champions.