Personally I would have gone with the Monster Mash on Halloween with Kane, Khali, Big Daddy V, and Henry.
It's gotta be the Lockdown matchup with the blindfold. It was so damn bad. The Blindfolds wouldn't even stay on, and nothing could get done. I try to give it a pass due to the storyline of Harris losing an eye for a while, and that this match would make sense, but it was so damn awful.
This is why you don't have multiple gimmicks in one match.