Overall Competitor of the Year
I'd go with Balor. I prefer Zayn over Balor, but Zayn was injured for over half the year and Balor was the top guy in the brand for a majority of the year. The guy is solid in the ring and had some good to great matches with Neville, Breeze, Owens, Crews, and Joe, plus the demon persona is pretty cool and different.
Male Competitor of the Year
Balor again and for the same reasons. Breeze is also a good option too as he always puts on solid matches, and he plays his character very well. His mannerisms in and out of the ring are really great and he's just a well rounded wrestler. Corbin is improving but isn't there yet, and Crews and Joe have done good things with their side feuds and title shots, but nothing big enough yet.
Female Competitor of the Year
I'm stuck between Bayley and Sasha. I love Bayley and the way she connects with the audience and she's just naturally likable. Her matches with Sasha in Brooklyn and at Respect were really good, with her win at Brooklyn being one the biggest moments of the year. Plus both she and Sasha were the first women to main-event a major WWE event with their Iron-Woman match at Respect. Sasha on the other hand improved a lot, and she also plays her role well, and a previous poster mentioned this so I won't repeat it. She's a great heel. I'm giving it to Bayley, but it's more personal preference.
Tag Team of the Year
Enzo and Cass. The guys always get a great reaction and they had a pretty good match with the Mechanics in London. They're probably the most popular team on the NXT Roster with Gable and Jordan in second. Even though they lost their match at London, they're still crowd favorites.
Match of the Year
This is also just personal preference, but I'm going with Zayn vs Owens at NXT Takeover: Rival. The build was awesome, with Owens attacking Sami the night of his debut being a surprise (considering he went from killing CJ Parker to #1 contender). The match ending by stoppage was a new finish as Owens looked like a monster while Sami never gave up, and overall it was a really entertaining match considering their past together.
TakeOver of the Year
I'm stuck between two.
NXT Takeover: Brooklyn was really good. You had Breeze opening the show with freaking Jushin Thunder Liger, Vaudevillains beating the Dubstep Cowboys, Crews debuting, Joe and Corbin beating the fuck out of each other, Bayley and Sasha in an amazing match, and a pretty brutal ladder match between Balor and Owens.
I loved Brooklyn, but I think I liked London more. Asuka vs Emma was a really good opener, with all the false finishers having me think Asuka was actually gong to lose. Same with the tag match between Enzo and Cass/The Mechanics, the end actually had me believing that Enzo and Cass would win until the awesome save by Dawson and the pretty cool super Shatter Machine. Corbin/Crews was a fine match with a nice finish and Corbin got a pretty important win. Bayley/Jax was really good and the guillotine was a fresh finish and the story was told well. And finally was Balor and Joe. The two beat the hell out of each other, and it was a really good match with a really good build.
For me, it's London. Brooklyn is no doubt the bigger show of the two, and I can definitely see why it can be considered the show of the year, but I just personally prefer London.