TNA is putting out a product that is basically a sensible version of that - wrestling aimed at adults.
I agree that TNA is more mature and adult than the WWE however, it has tons of flaws that need correcting, they need younger talent, they just let a bunch of young and rather good talent go.. Hogan needs to go, it's essentially WCW 2.0.. It doesn't have the "edgy" feel that I think people want out of a product.. ECW was edgy and had the very good matches that revolved around good storylines, they were all about putting on a good show.. WCW went the whole "anarchy" it was very much about good guys vs bad guys, superheroes against supervillains.. WWF kinda took both of what WCW and ECW were offering and combined it together..
Let me put it this way... JERRY SPRINGER is more edgy than TNA is, adults 18-30 generally watch it, it's great young-adult entertainment with ridiculous storylines.. Yes, it is scripted just like the WWE is, same goes with Sitcom like Family Guy/American Dad and so forth.. the WWE attitude era was comparable to products such as this and that's why it exploded as big as it did.. I am not saying there should be a ton of "hardcore" matches, but great gimmicks, great acting and entertainment with great storylines will go a long way and a little bit of a "hardcore" feel surrounding it will contribute to that.. They key thing though is entertainment, having an edgy product will make it more entertaining, that's why action blockbusters movies that rake in millions are usually PG-13 or Rated R..
Now, I am not saying that TNA or WWE should become CZW or something, CZW is over the top violence (edgy) yes, but really provides no entertainment.. CZW is essentially doing everything that ECW did and taking it in all the wrong directions.
TNA doesn't use this slogan, I think they should.. And I think they should go back to a red ring and red ropes, same with WWE Raw, "red" just has more of that "edgy" feel to it, it resembles blood and it is the first color that the human eye sees, in a way, it can help get people and the wrestlers more pumped..
Also, I really dislike the current WWE championship, it looks horrendous and has been ever since they introduced the spinner belt, the new one granted is better than the spinner belt, but I am just not sold on it..