klunderbunker
Welcome to My (And Not Sly's) House
It definitely would not have been the same that's for sure, it would have been a huge step back, but it could have still had the potential to exist in one form or another. My personal opinion on the denigration of the product aside, which was not a very high one when you consider the record number of title changes in 2000 alone and use of David Arquette turned me off to the product completely. However JCP/NWA/WCW had a rich history on the Turner Networks and that's the one thing the other NWA affiliates did not have that WCW would have been able to keep is the TV time slot had the original deal gone through. Again the product would have been much different and probably not as glitzy as it used to be, again all speculation.
Again, it would have been hard to think of a WCW without Turner's financial contributions, but they had existed for YEARS without his or AOL-Time Warner's financial contributions as an independent company with the TBS time slot. It very well could have been that way again. But don't get me wrong here, I respect your point and feel you have merit in your stance, it's just that this whole idea of what undid WCW is such a COMPLICATED matter. It's definitely not a cut and dry thing.
What I'm saying boils down to this: I've seen a lot of people here that seem to think that WCW died because one guy one day said "wrestling sucks and it's not airing here anymore." and that's it. That's what killed WCW. That theory obviously makes no sense so I was pointing out that the company was in peril already and needed some kind of saving. What Kellner did was say this company is beyond help and axed it from his network. No one else wanted it and the company went out of business. In short, it wasn't one thing that killed WCW on one day after a merger. This series of events had started years ago and was out of anyone's control when the plug was finally pulled.