UNDERRATED
Trent Barreta- I have said it before, and I will say it again; this kid should be a big deal some day. In the ring, he has speed, technical skills, and sells his ass off. He has a decent look, but could probably add 20 lbs. However, I have a strong feeling he may never get the opportunity to show what he can actually do.
Skip Sheffield- Yes, he was part of the biggest stable WWE has seen since Evolution. However, he wasn't really featured. He's agile, and he looks like a freakin' monster. He's like Batista, but more athletic and much younger at this point in his career. This is another guy who probably didn't get the change he deserved.
Alex Riley- This guy is the total package. His mic-skills are golden, and he has shown the ability to deliver charismatic promo's and such. He has good matches each time he's in the ring, no matter who he's jobbing to. I understand being the WWE Champion's sidekick isn't a bad gig, but what is Riley doing? I hope he gets involved in his own feud sooner as opposed to later. I think this guy has more potential than the Miz ever did.
OVERRATED
The Miz- I think every single thing about this guy is overrated. His mic skills, his character, his in-ring ability. Everything. I am still in shock about this guy being WWE champion. I think he's decent, meaning about average. I just do not see the appeal.
Sheamus- I must admit, I used to hate Sheamus. I used to think he was absolute garbage. But, he's grown on me a bit. Does that mean I don't think he's overrated? No. I haven't seen a wrestling performance from this guy to justify his place in the company. He has no character. He has an accent, and I'm sorry to say, that doesn't equal a character. I think this is the most boring main-eventer WWE has right now.
R-Truth- I am 99% sure he's injured right now, but he was on his way to a John Morrison-type push, IMO. And I cannot figure out why. I guess he must sell lots of t-shirts. When he speaks, I can understand about 1/4 of what he is saying. His mic skills are Matt Hardy-bad. Hell, he's worse than Matt Hardy. His rap songs annoy me, as does every other thing he does. He has no flow to his matches (a lot like Kofi). He's either being beaten down, or going 150 m.p.h. I just don't get what the WWE sees in this guy, I really don't.