I sometimes wish that the Attitude Era had never happened, because fans will never move on and accept anything WWE does now. If they created the biggest star since Hulk Hogan, you people wouldn't accept it, because you will not accept anyone being as good as "Stone Cold" Steve Austin and the Rock.
If the Attitude Era had continued to this day, you would be sick of it now, admit it. Most storylines have to finish at some time, and if it continued even today, most of you would want something different, just for something fresh and new. "Stone Cold", if he wrestled today, would have become stale, doing the same matches and using the same catchphrases over and over.
Personally, I believe that the best era of WWE is one where the storylines are interesting, the in-ring stuff is first-class, and Raw-SD is must-see. I didn't think the actual wrestling was that great in 1998-99, with the exception of the top guys, and maybe D-Lo Brown. Sure, the build-up was good, but the pay-off on PPV didn't always deliver, except the main-events. Even Undertaker in 1999 had his worst year ring-wise, with his knees stuffed and barely able to move.
I actually think things looked up in late 1999, when SCSA was written off screen. It allowed others to be given the ball. In 2000, the Rock and Triple H were at their best, the Undertaker returned as a biker, and was better in the ring. Kurt Angle and the Radicalz invaded the scene, making for some compelling in-ring action, (like the initial Angle-Benoit series, or the Jericho-Benoit series of matches). The Hardys, E & C and Dudleyz were entertaining us with TLC.
Come 2001, and we had the best WM ever (WM X7), with the best WM main-event ever. SCSA had returned, and went heel, which freshened his character up big-time. Also, WWE bought WCW and the Invasion angle happened. Triple H got injured, and took time off, and the Rock was making movies, so the star power moved to others, and the Invasion took off. The Invasion gets a bad rap now, but I found it must-see TV. Paul Heyman was brilliant as a commentator, and then starred as a member of the Alliance. RVD was introduced to us. People like Test and Christian jumped sides, and those who say the Invasion sucked, let me present Summerslam 2001 and SS 2001, perhaps the best year where the big four all delivered more than any other year. Good times!
2002. I wasn't a massive fan of the brand extension, but did like the return of HBK. Also, this was the year where Bischoff and Stephanie battled as opposing GMs and stole each other's talent. This was also the year which gave us Brock Lesnar when he actually gave a damn about wrestling, and not playing football, UFC or just taking Vince's money. Also, Hulk Hogan returned, and gave us a "Wrestlemania moment" against the Rock at WMX8. Also, Triple H and Jericho gave us a thrilling HIAC match, and then Undertaker-Brock matched it later that year.
2003, saw some of the best in-ring action ever. The "Super-Six", as I called them (Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit, Edge, Rey Mysterio and Los Guerreros) gave us wrestling clinics weekly on "Smackdown". Each match better than the next, it was a wresting conniseur's dream. HBK continued to entertain, and tore the house down against Chris Jericho at WM. Brock Lesnar also continued to dominate and be the star he could have remained if he had stayed. With Austin and the Rock off the scene, others provided the highlights instead.
2000-2003 was probably my fave era. I don't know what to call it, but I still liked it then. The amount of good quality in-ring guys (Angle, Benoit, Guerrero, Rey, Edge, HBK, Jericho), the promos ( especially when Chris Jericho had the mike, and except when Triple H took the mike) and the building of future stars made this period as exciting as you people think the Attitude Era was.
Outside the Attitude Era, we had Angle, the Radicalz, Brock Lesnar as a monster, HBK v Jericho at WM 19 and their 2008 feud, RVD, Extreme Rules Matches, Divas people cared about (Trish and Lita at the top of their game, Mickie James, etc).Chris Jericho was great on the mike and in the ring. Tag-Teams still had a place, whether they were the Un-Americans or the comedy team of Booker T and Goldust (who were very funny, but made people care as well), Shane McMahon daredevil stunts. All this stuff had little to do with Austin, Rock, Attitude or even anything risque, raunchy or edgy. Yet it was highly entertaining.
My point is, you don't need SCSA or the Rock to have wrestling be good.