What about Mark Henry? hes been given a Monster push in the last few months. Hes someone who has payed his dues and has an initimidating look and presence. He took out Kane and the Big Show and has a lot of momentum going right now. I could see him challenging Orton once he regains the title.
I just wanted to congratulate this guy, who posted this the last time this thread was done (I believe in July?). That thread was blatantly obvious, with ADR and DBD both holding Money in the Bank briefcases - both of them became the next first-time World Champions... This time things are a bit more interesting, with no un-cashed Money in the Bank cases floating around and with both World title pictures at WrestleMania filled with World Champions and former World Champions.
Wade Barrett is the most obvious choice, but everyone was calling for it last year as well. Hell, everyone was calling it the year before when he was hot off leading the Nexus and dominating the WWE landscape for months at a time. None of that ever came to fruition, and with his most recent injury setting him back several months I'm not so sure he's as "safe" a pick as everyone usually thinks he is.
Cody Rhodes isn't a smart pick at all, in my opinion. He's a fantastic mid-card champion and one that has been growing on me a little bit every single week since winning the belt. In fact, I actually hope he DOESN'T win the World title for a very long time. WWE could benefit from the slow and steady approach, instead of shotgunning all of their good talent into a premature title run.
R-Truth and Dolph Ziggler seem like sound choices right now. We're not going to have a first-time World champ for at least a few months, in my observations. Sheamus likely wins the title at WrestleMania, but either way that's a feud that probably will carry on for awhile. Any logical choice to face either of them (since Barrett is injured) has already held the title in the past. Punk and Jericho will likely feud for awhile as well, and I don't see the WWE Championship being dropped off either of them too soon. This will likely be a period of 3-6 months of building up the mid-card and getting them ready to step up. Ziggler has been ready, but as you can obvious see is in a downward period. Post-Mania he'll spring back and be given more of an opportunity, I would bet money on that. R-Truth is just one more high profile feud away from being "there", and as we saw last year they tend to give out shots to guys like him during the Capitol Punishment, Over the Limit filler months.
I wouldn't be surprised by either of them winning, nor Barrett coming back from injury later this year and doing the same.