I'm not going to pretend to be an expert and say who has the best "workrate", or who has the best in-ring psychology. But I will tell you who does the most beautiful looking moves, whose selling I believe the most, and who puts on the most entertaining matches. CM Punk, Daniel Bryan and Alberto Del Rio were up there on that list so it's sad to lose all of them. But here would be my current list:
(An honorable mention goes to Adrian Neville, Sami Zayn and Tyson Kidd, who are all sitting down at NXT putting on some spectacular matches but have yet to come to the main roster.)
The Top 5
My current top 5 would be (1) Dolph Ziggler, (2) Seth Rollins, (3) Cesaro, (4) Dean Ambrose & (5) Stardust. Dolph is just phenomenal in the ring, and I never feel like he has disappointed me. Dean and Cesaro have been stepping it up and I can't wait until they have a time to shine and maybe crack the top spot on this list. They still haven't had that instant classic yet though, but their weekly performances have yet to disappoint. Cody has always been a personal favorite, and I'm really digging his performance as Stardust. I just wish he got to face some newer opponents every week.
Rounding out the Top 10
The rest of the top 10 would be (6) Luke Harper, (7) Goldust, (8) Chris Jericho, (9) Sheamus and (10) Randy Orton. Luke is someone that has been impressing me every week, but he has yet to have a proper long singles match to take him to that next level. His tag team performances have been great though. Goldust and Jericho are both past their prime, but they are still killing it at great levels. They can still carry green guys to great matches and that's all you can ask from them. Sheamus and Randy are 2 of the best main eventers WWE has, but it also feels like their best work is behind them. Still, their weekly matches are still above and beyond the rest of the roster.
Places 11-15
Beyond those, I would put (11) Jey Uso, (12) Jimmy Uso, (13) John Cena, (14) Kofi Kingston, and (15) Diego. John continues to compete at a high level and put on good matches with the top 10 ring generals, but he still isn't really able to get a great match out of the people at the bottom of this list. The Usos however have gotten some great matches out of guys like Ryback and Erick Rowan, so they are obviously doing some great work. Kofi and Diego are also 2 guys who compete at a high level, but WWE just doesn't do much with them, which is a bummer.
Places 16-20
(16) Sin Cara, (17) Bray Wyatt, (18) Jack Swagger, (19) Damien Sandow & (20) Heath Slater. I'm probably Hunico's only fan left, but I'm a big fan of his work and get upset every time he's called out to do the job. I'm hoping he can get pushed in a tag team with Kalisto, because he's being severely underused. Bray is amazing at incorporating his character to his matches, but he's still got miles to go to compete with the best of the best. Jack, Damien and Heath are all guys who have it in them to be top workers, but they need lengthier matches and more exposure in big match situations. Jack is getting his due though, let's hope he doesn't drop the ball.
Beyond the top 20
After them, you have (21) The Miz, (22) Erick Rowan, (23) Rusev, (24) Big E & (25) Kane who are all capable of putting on good matches, but only when sitting across someone who knows what they're doing. The above guys have been able to carry these guys to some good matches recently, so they deserve some high placement.
(26) Fandango, (27) Rob Van Dam, (28) Curtis Axel (29) Xavier Woods & (30) R-Truth have left a lot to be desired recently. They should all be much higher on the list if I gave more weight to their much older material, but they have really been boring me on a consistent basis in 2014. But they have enough great matches under their belt for me to keep them in the top 30.
(31) Roman Reigns, (32) Mark Henry, (33) Ryback, (34) Zack Ryder & (35) Titus O'Neil all need some work in the ring. Henry has never really done well in a face role and at his age, he's not going to get any better. He should turn heel where he feels more comfortable in the ring. Titus and Ryback both need some grooming and to find their swagger, but I think they are both better suited on the face side of things. Ryder is just criminally underused not letting him improve at all, and on the opposite end, Roman Reigns is being overexposed on TV giving him more opportunities to blunder. He hasn't really put on anything memorable between the bells.
(36) El Torito, (37) The Big Show, (38) Adam Rose, (39) Hornswoggle, & (40) The Great Khali. Honestly, I see no future in any of them. Big Show keeps putting on the same match over and over again and I'm frankly dreading his return. Hornswoggle and El Torito might be amazing technicians, but WWE would never show that. Khali and Adam are both comedy guys and bring nothing to the table other than a few laughs at how pathetic their characters are. They're the bottom of WWE's talent pole.
I'm not counting the NXT guys (including Justin Gabriel & Tyson Kidd) because they aren't working the main roster and it's unfair to bundle them together. Brock Lesnar isn't working either. He'll be back for one match and then leave. And if I only count his last match, he's probably at the bottom. Hopefully he's back in form for SummerSlam.
Bad News Barrett, Christian, Daniel Bryan, Darren Young, Fernando & Rey Mysterio are all supposedly injured, so they couldn't make the list. When they all return, I bet they will all easily make the top 30, as long as they still got it.