I am struggling to decide where Benoit would be in the WWE if he was still with us, really struggling.
Now Benoit was not a young man when he died, he was in his 40s so was coming towards the end of his career. WWE obviously had no long term plans for him so had sent him to the ECW brand, which was never a good thing! He was continuing to put on good matches, as usual, but WWE was looking at the future, and it was becoming clear that Benoit was not going to be around much longer.
I do not think Benoit would have retired around the time of his death, he loved the business and would have tried to have kept going as long as he could. But here is where I am having the difficulty. Benoit had stated in the months leading up to his death that he would always be a WWE guy, but with his mounting injuries, advanced age, and fading career opportunities, would he have been willing to put up with the endless travelling that being on a WWE roster requires?
If he had decided to remain in the WWE, I could see him having had a smaller role, maybe more of a mentor to a new technical wrestler, with Benoit acting as the manager of and occasional tag team partner to the young up-and-coming star (perhaps this is what Daniel Bryan would be doing now if Benoit was alive????).
I think that eventually Benoit would have become a trainer in one of the developmental territories, like Finlay, or a road agent. This is if he had wanted to stay with the WWE.
If he had left, maybe he would have appeared in TNA, as they would definately been interested, but I just cant imagine The Wolverine on Impact. However, with the money they would have thrown at him it would be quite likely I guess. Angle V Benoit again would be great to see.
However, at this point in time, several years after his murder/suicide and several years older, I would imagine Chris Benoit would be on the verge of retirement, after years of gruelling matches, concussions and several severe injuries.
He would certainly be worthy of a spot in the WWE Hall Of Fame had he not commited his terrible actions, and it is sad that a man who gave so much to the business and would have been remembered as a great can now forever be remembered as a murderer, and has almost been written out of wrestling history.