Now that 2011's officially behind us, I thought this might be fun. 2011 was certainly a good year for gaming, so what game do you guys vote for?
My two top choices are between Skyrim & Deus Ex with my winner probably being Deus ex. Skyrim was a great spend of money it was 120 hours of immersion and I got a lot of fun out of it but deus ex had a bigger impact, was more compelling and as far as a work of art goes it was far deeper.
Skyrim will get all the GOTY awards this year, however (I loved it don't get me wrong) however the story telling and characters were nowhere near as cool. It did have a great quest where I got to experience what being indoctrinated into terrorism felt like but like everything else it didn't feel like the consequences and weaving with the story were strong enough. I became a terrorist and then... nothing. The stories didn't weave enough and they didn't link with the world, aside from one or two main quest requirements and the guards.
Now Deus Ex was pretty linear but it worked. It addressed post humanism but also the growing gap between the haves and have nots and it gave all the sides a good shout. The ending machine at the end was terriible, the boss fights could have meant so much more and been so much better but the overall experience was compelling and fun. Like skyrim there were multiple ways to solve most of the game, but while skyrim did each approach well and have us a big open world, deus ex did each approach very well and gave us compelling world.
Of course I'm a believer in games are art. That doesn't mean a game without a deeper meaning or clever exploration of some issue isn't worthwhile, I fucking love serious sam and the like. But that the pinnacle of gaming like any other media is both exciting and compelling but also makes us think about something, and properly. The ability to experience it is more powerful than any other media. (there's also good dumb fun, stuff with a good point that's dull and just outright shit just like any other media form).
Now what's your personal choice?
My two top choices are between Skyrim & Deus Ex with my winner probably being Deus ex. Skyrim was a great spend of money it was 120 hours of immersion and I got a lot of fun out of it but deus ex had a bigger impact, was more compelling and as far as a work of art goes it was far deeper.
Skyrim will get all the GOTY awards this year, however (I loved it don't get me wrong) however the story telling and characters were nowhere near as cool. It did have a great quest where I got to experience what being indoctrinated into terrorism felt like but like everything else it didn't feel like the consequences and weaving with the story were strong enough. I became a terrorist and then... nothing. The stories didn't weave enough and they didn't link with the world, aside from one or two main quest requirements and the guards.
Now Deus Ex was pretty linear but it worked. It addressed post humanism but also the growing gap between the haves and have nots and it gave all the sides a good shout. The ending machine at the end was terriible, the boss fights could have meant so much more and been so much better but the overall experience was compelling and fun. Like skyrim there were multiple ways to solve most of the game, but while skyrim did each approach well and have us a big open world, deus ex did each approach very well and gave us compelling world.
Of course I'm a believer in games are art. That doesn't mean a game without a deeper meaning or clever exploration of some issue isn't worthwhile, I fucking love serious sam and the like. But that the pinnacle of gaming like any other media is both exciting and compelling but also makes us think about something, and properly. The ability to experience it is more powerful than any other media. (there's also good dumb fun, stuff with a good point that's dull and just outright shit just like any other media form).
Now what's your personal choice?