To me, this is a no contest,
It's really not.
However, you're picking the wrong person.
First of all, he is a better wrestler overall than AJ Styles
In what fucking way? HHH's promos are shit, he can't draw worth a damn, and the only time he has good matches is when a gimmick is involved, or he's being carried. Seriously, that's the truth. AJ Styles, on the other hand, is a pretty damn good promo cutter who's getting better each day at it, carried TNA to its Spike TV deal, and has participated in a LOT of this decade's greatest matches.
and has accomplished much more in his career.
Just because he politicked his way to all his championship reigns doesn't mean shit to me.
The fact is... TNA wouldn't be around if there was no AJ Styles, whereas I strongly believe that WWE would be doing BETTER business if HHH never existed. That accomplishment alone makes AJ more accomplished than HHH, if you ask me.
While HHH has been dominant in the WWE and beaten virtually every big name in the company, what has AJ Styles done except for hang around the upper mid card of TNA.
Like I said, he carried that company on his shoulders to make it to where it's at today.
As for the dog collar, that only helps HHH even more.
False.
He is much stronger than Styles and would use that to his advantage.
AJ's a pretty muscular guy, so I doubt HHH would be able to handle him so easily. Besides, AJ has been in a ring PLENTY of times with stronger wrestlers than him, so I'm sure he would know how to handle Trips' strength anyway.
AJ wouldn't be able to use his high flying moves and would be pretty much lost.
Have you ever seen a Dog Collar match? There are plenty of high spots.
I see this ending with a pedigree about 10 minutes in.
Wow... could you be any more wrong?
Just because it's in a TNA ring his other accomplishments don't mean anything?
First of all, HHH accomplishments are bullshit, so no... they don't mean anything, in any ring, but ESPECIALLY in a TNA ring. That six sided ring and the TNA fans really work against HHH. And that's a fact.
Last time I checked, it's still a wrestling ring and it's still pro wrestling
A very different wrestling ring than what HHH is use to, and in a very different atmosphere HHH is use to as well.
Those are all well and good, but are nothing compared to Triple H's acheivments. He is 13 time World champion, 5 time Intercontinental Champion, 2 time European Champion, former King of the Ring winner, the 2nd ever Grand Slam Champion in the WWE, plus he won a "Best Hair" Slammy Award in 1997.
None of those mean anything in this match; they really don't.
Now you may say that these don't matter in a TNA ring,
They really don't.
but I still say both the WWE and TNA are professional wrestling.
Both are still very different companies, though. Coke and Dr. Pepper might both be Soda, but they taste very different from one another.
Kurt Angle moved from WWE to TNA and that worked out just fine for him.
HHH isn't in Kurt Angle's league in ANYTHING pertaining to this business.
Mick Foley has been in the company for hardly half a year and is already World Champion.
Has he had a match against AJ Styles?
Adapting to the six sided ring won't be an issue for Triple H.
Yes it would, especially when there's a stipulation like this involved.
I would say his closeline would be a power move
So you don't think AJ Styles would be able to handle a closeline from HHH?
and the pedigree certainly takes some power.
AJ wouldn't let himself get caught with the pedigree.
I would also argue that his power actually makes all of his "non power" moves even stronger.
Ummm... what?
Being a brawler is an advantage in this match.
And AJ is definitely a brawler himself. Watch his matches against Abyss to see that.
Triple H will keep AJ close and use his more powerful strikes to wear him down.
AJ would counter everything Trips would throw at him. AJ has seen it all before, against much superior wrestlers than HHH.
AJ, on the other hand, isn't known at all for being a striker and will be out of his comfort zone.
AJ isn't known for being a striker? His kicks are the best in the business, especially his drop kick.
As for being to hit the Pele out of nowhere, maybe. But it will be a lot harder with Triple H beating down on him with fist while he is tied to him.
Ridiculous...
It's a much bigger company than TNA, there are just as many wrestlers on Smackdown or Raw as there are in TNA.
So, what does that have to do with anything? The fact is, Abyss and Samoa Joe and Kurt Angle are just as tough as ANYONE WWE has to offer, and AJ has multiple victories over all of them.
In theory, the number of people they have to go against doesn't really matter. It's about the quality of competition.
And AJ has just as much competition in TNA as HHH has in WWE. It doesn't matter who has the bigger roster.
AJ Styles defeated Raven and Jeff Jarrett to win his titles.
Triple H has defeated men such as The Rock, Mankind, Chris Jericho, Randy Orton, Edge, Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, and Goldberg to win his titles
Again... it doesn't matter. AJ could easily defeat those names in TNA. Maybe not in WWE, but definitely in TNA.
Okay... I'm done with picking apart the post.
The simple fact is this... the match is in TNA, and AJ Styles has been the face of the company since it was created basically. He would never, in a million fucking years, let someone from WWE, especially a guy who is as hated as HHH is by both the TNA roster and TNA fans, come into TNA and defeat him. He just would never let it happen. AJ Styles is already the superior wrestler, but I guarantee you were this match to ever take place, in TNA, we would see a more determined, brutal, sadistic AJ Styles then we've ever seen before. He would not lose this match. I would put my life on it.