It's hard to argue against The Shield. I know that ROTY is usually about one person, but The Shield have been such a cohesive unit of guys who've all brought something different to the group. I dunno if one of them can really be singled out as being "better" than the others right now. Ambrose has been US champ for about 7 months and he's the best overall talker of the group, Rollins has the athleticism, pretty solid mic skills himself and Reigns as the look & the power. I know that WWE allegedly has plans to elevate Reigns next year, but that's next year. When it comes to the past 12 months, I think they're all on an even level.