This case is a lot like Cinnamon Girl to me...While the original is clearly better musically, the 2nd caters to my personal tastes a bit more, and isn't half bad itself. If pressured, I'd definitely take Peter Gabriel's version over the remake, but I'd like to think it'd never come to that point. (Go ahead and rip me apart, X)...
The Original:
The Cover:
Like I said, Gabriel's is better musically, but the vocals are great on the cover, and the music caters to my tastes. I can't pick a clear winner, but I'd lean towards voting Gabriel...
The Original:
The Cover:
Like I said, Gabriel's is better musically, but the vocals are great on the cover, and the music caters to my tastes. I can't pick a clear winner, but I'd lean towards voting Gabriel...