Quite frankly, if there's a preaching of everyone being equal, and then going on to say one particular denomination of color is more prone to be (insert term with negative connotation) than the rest of the population WITHOUT any proof I think there could be found trouble with those statements.
Slash-LN noted that his school was that way, due to overwhelming majority being white. Again,
personal experience is proof to a person's belief. Further, he went on to say:
Slash-LN: I think these people making the statements are complete idiots. I don't see what her race should have to do with anything She was born in America. She's an American. That's all there really is to it.
What, Macios, pray tell, is hypocritical about that? He's saying that people judging her on the basis of her skin are "complete idiots." And he's right. This isn't to crown "Miss Blond Haired, Blue Eyed America", it's to crown
Miss America. Period.
It just seems you're back to being contrary just to be contrary, even if none of the facts back up your argument.
I have friends who are of mixed colors and heritage and believe me I know African American's who are racist towards whites and oriental, white friends who are racist about everyone, and Latino friends who are racist to everyone. My point is everyone can be racist and it's not one particular race being the most prejudiced.
That's your
personal experience. No one is discounting it. They're simply sharing their own
personal experiences. Honestly, you're the one being hypocritical by essentially saying,
"This is my experience, so yours must be wrong."
The ONLY justifiable claim to your statement is the fact that you could mention how the majority of the United States is indeed white, and going on the theory that everyone is inherently racist, you could make the comment that because it's a majority of the population the white people in America are the most racist simply because there's indeed more of us.
That would be the logic Slash-LN used, would it not be? 99% of his school was white, and they were racist towards the black students.
I'm not sure where Alex's opinion comes from, to be honest, as he lives in England. Unless he's visited here multiple times, I don't see how he can say we're the most racist country in the world. Still, that doesn't make him a hypocrite. A hypocrite is someone who
says they believe one thing, but their
actions show they believe something contrary to what they say. Where do you get the hypocrite stuff from?
This quotation whilst based on a factual moment is in no way an entire support for Aelx's argument.
But this wasn't Alex who said it, it was Slash-LN. And again, he was stating personal experience. He went to a school that was 99% white. Fact. White kids at his school ran a black girl off. Fact.
One case of racism does not classify an entire denomination of people to be racist.
He didn't say that it did. He said it was prevalent
in his town. Instead of being hell-bent on calling someone a hypocrite because they shared from personal experience, actually read their
entire post. Because he then went on to say:
.
I think these people making the statements are complete idiots. I don't see what her race should have to do with anything She was born in America. She's an American. That's all there really is to it.
He didn't say:
"These white people making these statements", he said "these people". He then went on to say race had nothing to do with it. That includes white people, Macios.
Once again, you're not reading what's being written, or you're being contrary just to stir things up, as you've done in the past.
Likewise I wouldn't call the African American person who called me a "burnt white cracker" yesterday a representative of the entire African American population. (And I have sunburn for anyone who was wondering on the topic.)
I didn't read anywhere where people said that these whites, or any group of whites, are representative of the entire population. Slash-LN pointed out his experience at his school. Not your school, not my former schools
, his alone. Zeus showed that most of the people making these particular comments are white. Alex, well, he gave an opinion with no basis behind it, I'll give you that. But in your case, what exactly are you trying to say or prove?
I'm not saying other races aren't racists (they can be). I'm just saying that when someone of a different ethnicity other than white does something or achieves something on a national or global scale nine times out of ten, whites are generally the ones who say something prejudiced about it.
I hate this 9/10 crap, because you're providing an opinion, not stating a fact. Earlier, you said:
I still think at times America is the most racist country in the world.
It must be nice to sit in England and make judgments about a country you don't even live in. Have you ever even visited here? I'm not saying you're wrong, btw, I'm just saying that whether wrong or right, you're wrong, I honestly don't know. Simply put, it would be nice to have examples or empirical data that backs this up.
It would be no different then I saying "People from England have the world's worst teeth." Have I heard that before? Sure, as a joke. Do I have anything that shows it to be true? Nope!
Neither do you when you say America is the most racist country in the world.
The First being what happened last night. An American, born in America, who went to the University of Michigan, who has been in America for 24 years, who happen to be of Indian descent. THIS IS ACCEPTABLE!
Again, Macios, READ. That's what EVERYONE in this thread is SAYING.
The Scenario we disagreed with was: An Indian person with an actual Indian citizenship, spending time in American possibly for education, who was born in Delhi, who lived in Delhi 20 out of the 24 years of her life, who is actually NOT an American.
Well, yeah, the law says she wouldn't be eligible. Is there a point there somewhere?
There's a big difference between the two scenarios but the end result is that if you ae AMERICAN you can be MISS AMERICA.
Just the same as sharing one's own personal experience with racism doesn't make them a hypocrite, nor racist themselves. Perhaps Alex is, depending on his skin color, but you lumped Slash-LN's post right in there with him, and you're not close to being accurate in grasping what he's saying.