I know it seems that way, but what I meant was that though he is actually from the streets, his promos seem forced for him to make moderately acceptable to the larger audience. I've heard him cut promos in ROH before, specifically at the last show he appeared at with them prior to going to TNA full time and it was painful to say the least. He struggles to find the words more talented stars find naturally. Amazing Red as the same difficulties.
You do realize how silly it is to judge someone's promo abilities on ONE promo, right? Not exactly a fair sampling of their abilities. Homicide isn't great on the mic, but he's certainly not bad and I've seen him cut some very good promos during his feuds with Corino, Joe, and Danielson.
Sure, he talks like it, but he doesn't speak purely in Bed-Stuy terminology – he actually tries to somehow fuse it with a more classical approach, and it just doesn't work all that well to me. The difference between Austin and Homicide is that Austin was capable of projecting a personality that sold to the masses, whereas Homicide appeals to about 12% of the population with his.
And you would know this how IDR? Did you take a national poll? I'm so sick of people saying someone can't draw or wouldn't work in the big time when they've NEVER BEEN GIVEN THE CHANCE to. Homicide never received a serious singles push in TNA, shit not even a midcard singles push, so how the hell do you know he couldn't have been huge in TNA?
And I don't know what world you're living in, but the one I'm living on is dominated by hip-hop and R&B music and culture. If anything Homicide's character is perfect for this generation of Americans.
Well, that might be the issue here, then, because I didn't see very much of him in ROH – only in TNA. I saw him wrestle for ROH twice, once against Roderick Strong and the second time against someone else who I can't remember. The third time I saw him he was cutting his exit promo at Hammerstein before leaving for TNA full-time. Also the last night MCMG wrestled for ROH against Steen & Generico.
See what I mean? You haven't seen his best work, or even close to it. It's like judging Jerry Lynn's career on the three episodes of Sunday Night Heat he wrestled on for the WWF. It's not a true portrayal of his talents and abilities.
Difference being that Punk (at least) has the traditional look of a professional wrestler, and is fantastic on the mic. Danielson and Homicide can't attest to the same, though Danielson, although small, at least has muscular tone – Homicide has the body of an under-developed 12-year old boy.
Punk---traditional? How the hell do you figure? Pretty sure he's literally the first character and wrestler of his kind, there has never been another wrestler with the straight edge gimmick, the dude is covered in tattoos and piercings...in other words the
opposite of a traditional look for a wrestler. A traditional wrestling look would be someone like John Cena.
And Homicide is just as built as Danielson is. Size doesn't mean shit, I think Rey Mysterio proved that when he skyrocketed through the glass ceiling and never looked back while becoming one of the most popular wrestlers on the planet and a multiple time World champion.
When I say a guy doesn't have a personality, I mean he doesn't have anything worth selling, which is exactly what I get from Homicide. Does he have an "original" look? Sort of. Does he have an "original" persona? Kind of. Does he have one that appeals to the masses? No.
Just as I said before, he definitely does. I'd say the thug look appeals pretty damn well to the masses considering if you look at the music charts, it's dominated by gangsta rappers like Lil Wayne. Look at the box office charts, the more violent the more popular it is (The Expendables has been number one at the Box Office for 2 weeks now). Homicide certainly appeals to this generation, he was over huge in ROH and was over big time in TNA despite being buried.
I think IDR is making some great points.
It's almost like Homicide can't be from the streets and "professional" at the same time (or in general you can't be.) From what I saw of Homicide in ROH, he was cursing all the time, you can't be like "F you, Mofo" (uncut) in TNA. But that is what the streets are. When I think of Homicide I don't think his character is one bit "distinct." When has a thug gimmick ever been distinct? Or extremely popular? New Jack? Here's the thing, New Jack never appealed to the mass audience. And if New Jack worked for WWE he'd be never the same b/c he'd be watered down and knowing New Jack he is street, and he never would have lasted in WWE b/c of this. New Jack was cheered by the rabid ECW fans for how raw he was, but that's ECW.
See this is where you're wrong though in comparing Homicide to New Jack when they're two very different characters. New Jack was one-dimensional, he was a gangster that liked to beat people up and that was it. Homicide's character was FAR more developed and incorporated both his family and his children and showcased Homicide's desire to overcome the streets and to make it big in wrestling and leave the streets behind him and provide for his family, and when he couldn't accomplish that against Samoa Joe he snapped and returned to that thug-like personality again with no respect, breaking all of the Ring of Honor rules and laughing about it, beating up referees.
This is what I'm saying, judging Homicide's character solely on his burial of a run in TNA isn't fair because it doesn't portray the true potential the character has, like he had the ability to do in ROH.
When I think of Homicide, I think of a poor mans Konnan.
Not even close man, Homicide is far more talented than Konnan ever was, even in his lucha prime. Konnan couldn't wrestle for shit once he left Mexico, unlike Homicide who can still have a great match with just about anyone in the business in a multitude of different styles of wrestling. It's hard to show this to people when he's being jobbed out to Rob Terry in 40 seconds on TV and then disappears from TV for another 4 months until he comes back for another quick job. TNA completely buried the guy once they split LAX, so no shit you're not going to be impressed.