The medical mask I'll give you (I complained about that myself), but if you think the preacher drawl he spoke with didn't appeal to anyone, daddy, then I invite you to do your homework on a guy you might have heard about — "The American Dream" Dusty Rhodes. The pimp/jive-talking gimmick was fine for him. It was natural, because it derived of his natural persona. He was getting over just fine with it, as is evidenced by his early rise in the company.
All fair points, except that Dusty Rhodes' rise was in the 80's when he was sharing a profession with other funny sounding people like Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan, as well as things like taking Hogan's plane into a nose dive was considered wicked cool when grunted out by a forgotten Motley Crue member on steroids in the face of The Ultimate Warrior.
When you look at the landscape these days, a character like Pope's just doesn't fit in. Not necessarily a bad thing, but it is in his case. Pope always tried to be funny, he always tried to have this "Rocky" sense to him and forgot to take his opponents AND himself seriously.
Daddeh this, daddeh that, religion puns here, religion puns there. Has the Pope ever cut a down to Earth promo? Has he EVER delivered at least a minute of fine mic work worthy of a Main Eventer? Has he ever had a string of great matches?
If he did, I remember none of them and that says something.
But the character was simply half baked. He could've easily toned it down just a bit and make himself flashy, witty but at the same time serious enough to prevent us from thinking of him as a joke at times.
I just don't think it clicked with the people. His passion did and his natural charisma did. I doubt the character had anything to do with it and it probably held him back. He overdid it.
You wanna see good flashy in 2013? See Austin Aries. No 80's slang or coats or money or doctor masks or stereotypes needed. Just talent, a mic and something meaningful to say. Pope's never said a damn thing that made sense.
As a side note, I just realized he is copying Little Richard's mannerisms and way of speaking. Like, completely.