To be completely fair, Joe was not giving Crimson any favors during that match, including on that suplex. He looked slow and lazy (watch when he has Crimson on the fence, and he runs to him, never seen him run so slow in my life). When doing a power move to a big man like the Big Show, I mean sure the guy doing the heavy lifting needs some serious power, but they also need a hell of a lot of help from the "victim".
You make good points and I agree with you. However, this guy is supposed to be a "monster" right? The monsters that have always fared best have legit looked nasty out there. The ones that stand out for me are Vader and Ken Shamrock. Vader always looked like he was brutal with people and it gave that sense that he could kill you at there. He was intimidating and you didn't want to get in the ring with him. Shamrock had the look of nutcase and roid rage rolled into the madness that was his character. He was billed as "the world's most dangerous man" and you believed it. When he locked the ankle lock on, he looked like he would just as soon rip your leg completely off. THAT is intensity.
Lesnar had that too. The way he hurled people around showed he wouldn't take prisoners and such. Maybe it's the opponents, but I'm not even close to buying it with Crimson. If you want to do this "streak" thing, you don't debut him the way they did. You debut him as the brother if you want, then he wins a match to held Red, then starts just kiling lower to midcard talent. He doesn't see a Joe until later on when he gets his "first real test". It might work if you do it that way, but I still don't like it.
To me, it feels like Bischoff and Hogan were in with creative and they were like "ok, what can we do that has worked before?"
"Well, we lucked across Goldberg's streak, people liked that!"
"Ok let's do that!"
People have called Bischoff a one trick pony. Here is trick #2 and it wasn't even his idea. It was something they fell ass backwards into and it worked with Goldberg. The problem here is two-fold. Goldberg was perfect for it as he won squashes, was incredibly strong, and he came off instilling fear in his opponents. Crimson does none of these things. The other problem is that once you do a streak, it's been done. Actually, it's been done for literally every big man for the last 50 years. You debut a guy and have him beat jobbers until they bill him as undefeated and then the babyface takes him down to get a big rub. That's how every monster was booked for Hogan and it continued in WWF and WCW. Goldberg started as a heel but somehow the streak turned him face and he got over. You can't just expect to create another Goldberg with the EXACT SAME PUSH. It will not work and it's already not working. If you are going to do the streak, you can't have him NOT LOSE, he has to WIN. There's a major, major difference.
All the same, it won't matter. Crimson is incredibly green and really offers nothing. IF he's 4 inches shorter, he's nothing. If you want to build this kid, fine. It's better than building Pope's annoying self. However, build him with some sort of character. This "I'm intense but not really" schtick has already seen its bluff called.
And yes, Joe sucked last night. He's getting fatter, slower, and more awful each week. Might be time to simply cut his fat ass and not hire him back unless he drops like 75 pounds.