• Xenforo Cloud has scheduled an upgrade to XenForo version 2.2.16. This will take place on or shortly after the following date and time: Jul 05, 2024 at 05:00 PM (PT) There shouldn't be any downtime, as it's just a maintenance release. More info here

Andre 'The Giant': Worthy or Not?

Does Andre 'The Giant' deserve to be IN the Hall of Fame?

  • Yes. 8th Wonder of the World bitches!

  • No. He was nothing but a side-show attraction.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TheOneBigWill

[This Space for Rent]
AndreTheGiant015.jpg

André René Roussimoff (May 19, 1946 – January 27, 1993), best known as André the Giant, was a French professional wrestler and actor. His great size was a result of a condition known as acromegaly, and led to him being dubbed "The Eighth Wonder of the World."

In the World Wrestling Federation (WWF), Roussimoff briefly held the WWF Championship. In 1993, he was the first inductee into the WWE Hall of Fame. Roussimoff was one of the most famous professional wrestlers of the 1970s and 1980s, and was involved in a legendary match with Hulk Hogan in 1987 at WrestleMania III.

On March 26, 1973, André made his WWF debut as a "face", defeating Buddy Wolfe in New York's Madison Square Garden.

He was billed early in his career at a height of 6 ft 10 in (2.08m) and 6 ft 11 in (2.10m); this was enlarged in the early 1970s to 7 ft 4 in (2.24m) with a weight that ranged from 309 lb (140 kg) to 565 lb (256 kg). His actual height is contested, and there has been much speculation and debate over the issue. Jim Duggan and Bobby Heenan maintain that his kayfabe height was correct. Wrestling journalist Dave Meltzer claims André was measured at 6 ft 9 ¾ in 1974 by a French athletic commission at age 28; Meltzer also estimated André at 6 ft 11 ½ inches.

He branched out into acting in the 1970s and 1980s, playing a Sasquatch ("Bigfoot") on the 1970s television series The Six Million Dollar Man and the character Fezzik in The Princess Bride. By the time the chairman of the (renamed) World Wrestling Federation, Vincent K. McMahon, began to expand his promotion to the national level in the early 1980s, André wrestled exclusively for WWF in the USA, while still holding international engagements.

He was offered a professional American football contract with the Washington Redskins after a tryout in 1975 and seriously considered it, but turned it down, reasoning that he could make far more money wrestling. Andre was mentioned in the 1974 Guinness Book of World Records as the highest paid wrestler in history up to that time. He had earned $400,000 in one year alone during the early 1970s.

André was one of WWF's most beloved "babyfaces" throughout the 1970s and early 1980s. As such, a legend insisted that he was never defeated for 15 years by pinfall or submission prior to WrestleMania III. This, however, is not true. André actually had lost cleanly in matches outside of the parameters of WWF; a pinfall loss in Mexico to El Canek in 1984 and in Japan a submission loss to Antonio Inoki in 1986, as well as a controversial no-contest finish against Akira Maeda, who used heel shoot-style tactics to nullify André's considerable size advantage. He also went sixty-minute time limit draws with the two other major world champions of the day, Harley Race and Nick Bockwinkel.

André had memorable clashes all over the world with a variety of tough, rugged opponents. Among his chief rivals in the ring: The Sheik (who gained a deathmatch win over the Frenchman in 1974 with the help of his fireball), Abdullah the Butcher, Stan Hansen, Ernie Ladd, and a young Hulk Hogan, who first met André in 1978 during his rookie years in the deep South. Hogan and André would go on to have one of the greatest WWF feuds of 1980, peaking in front of 36,295 fans at the Showdown at Shea event on August 9, 1980 in Flushing, New York's Shea Stadium.

One of André's most bitter feuds pitted him against the Mongolian terror Killer Khan, who was managed by Freddie Blassie. According to the storyline, Khan had broken André's ankle during a match in Rochester, New York by leaping off the top rope and crashing down upon it with his knee-drop. After a stay at Beth-Israel Hospital in Boston, André returned with payback on his mind. On November 14, 1981 at the Philadelphia Spectrum, André exacted revenge by destroying Killer Khan in what was billed as a "Mongolian Stretcher Match", in which the loser must be taken to the dressing room on a stretcher. In reality, André had snapped his ankle getting out of bed one morning. The injury and subsequent rehabilitation was worked into the existing André/Khan storyline.

Another memorable André feud involved a man who considered himself to be "the true giant" of wrestling: Big John Studd. Throughout the early to mid-1980s, André and Studd fought all over the world, battling to try and determine who the real giant of wrestling was. In December 1984, Studd took the feud to a new level, when he and partner Ken Patera knocked out André during a televised tag team match and proceeded to cut off André's famous long locks (Big Show, Kurt Angle, Mark Jindrak, and Luther Reigns would duplicate the angle nearly 20 years later). André had the last laugh at the first WrestleMania on March 31, 1985 at Madison Square Garden. André conquered Studd in a $15,000 Body Slam Challenge. After slamming Studd, he attempted to give the $15,000 prize to the fans, before having the bag stolen from him by his future manager Bobby "The Brain" Heenan.

The following year, at WrestleMania 2 (April 7, 1986), André continued to display his dominance by winning a twenty-man battle royal that featured top NFL stars and wrestlers. André last eliminated Bret Hart to win the contest. Afterwards, André continued his feud with Studd and King Kong Bundy. André was suspended after a no-show; he returned under a mask as "The Giant Machine" part of a team with "Big Machine" (Robert Windham) and "Super Machine" (Bill Eadie) (The Machines gimmick was copied from New Japan Pro Wrestling character "Super Strong Machine", played by Japanese wrestler Junji Hirata). Soon afterwards, Giant Machine disappeared, and André was reinstated, to the approval of Bobby "The Brain" Heenan.

André was turned heel in 1987 so that he could face Hulk Hogan for the WWF Championship in the main event of WrestleMania III. In early 1987, Hogan was presented a trophy for being the WWF World Heavyweight Champion for three years. André came out to congratulate him. Shortly afterwards, André was presented a slightly smaller trophy for being "undefeated in WWF for fifteen years." In actuality, André had suffered a handful of countout and disqualification losses in WWF but had never been pinned or forced to submit in a WWF ring. Hogan came out to congratulate André and ended up being the focal point of the interview. A visibly annoyed André walked out in the midst of Hogan's speech. Then, on an edition of "Piper's Pit", Hogan was confronted by Bobby Heenan. Heenan announced that his new protege was André. André then challenged Hogan to a title match at WrestleMania III, ripping the t-shirt and crucifix from Hogan.

WrestleMania III was the first time the public really saw the pain that André was going through. At WrestleMania, he was billed at 520 pounds, and the stress of that immense weight on his bones and joints resulted in constant pain. After recent back surgery, he was also wearing a brace underneath his wrestling singlet. Hogan won the match after dropping André with a body slam, followed by Hogan's running leg drop finisher. Years later, Hogan stated that André was so heavy, he felt more like 700 pounds, and that he actually tore his latissimus dorsi muscle slamming him, though the legitimacy of this statement is questionable. Another famous story about the match is that no one knew if André would lose the match. WWF Owner Vince McMahon has stated in the past that he believed if Hogan had either purposely or accidentally disrespected André that night, there was no way André would have allowed Hogan to win the match, no matter what had been agreed to. Aside from that possibility, André had agreed to lose the match some time before, mostly for health reasons, though he almost pinned Hogan (albeit unintentionally) in the early goings of the match.

Contrary to popular belief, it was not the first time that Hogan had successfully bodyslammed André in a WWF match. A then-heel Hogan bodyslammed a then-face Andre early in a match in Hamburg, Pennsylvania on September 13, 1980, though Andre was much lighter and more athletic at the time. This, of course, back in the territorial days of wrestling three years before WWF began its national expansion (Andre had also previously allowed Harley Race, Kamala, and Stan Hansen to slam him). By the time WrestleMania III had rolled around, the WWF had gone national, giving more meaning to the Andre-Hogan match that took place then.

The Hogan-André face off at WrestleMania III was likely the most highly anticipated professional wrestling matchup in history – the apex of wrestling's most recent golden era. The event, held at the Pontiac Silverdome, had millions watching on pay-per-view and established great permanent value in the WrestleMania franchise. A reported 93,173 fans turned out as the WWF sold many standing room only tickets and added seats in the alleys to exceed the Silverdome's capacity of 80,331. Hogan defeated André in what some consider a passing of the torch from André, wrestling's biggest star of the 70s, to Hogan, wrestling's biggest star of the 80s.
The feud between André and Hogan simmered during the summer of 1987, even as Roussimoff's health declined. The feud would begin heating up again when each wrestler was named the captain of rival teams at the inaugural Survivor Series event. Hogan was counted out, and André would go on to be the sole survivor of the match after pinning Bam Bam Bigelow.

In the meantime, "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase failed to persuade Hogan to sell him the WWF World Championship. After failing to defeat Hogan in a subsequent series of matches, DiBiase turned to André to win it for him. Acting as his hired gun, André won the WWF title from Hogan on February 5, 1988 in a match where it was later revealed appointed referee Dave Hebner was "detained backstage", and a replacement who DiBiase paid to get plastic surgery to look like Dave (in reality, his twin brother Earl Hebner), made a three count on Hogan while his shoulders were off the mat. After winning, André "sold" the title to DiBiase; the transaction was declared invalid by then-WWF President Jack Tunney and the title was vacated. This was shown on WWF's NBC program The Main Event. André famously mistakenly called the WWF Championship the "WWF Tag Team Championship."

At WrestleMania IV, André and Hulk Hogan fought to a double disqualification in a WWF title tournament match (with the idea in the storyline saying that André was again working on DiBiase's behalf in giving DiBiase a clearer path in the tournament). Afterwards, André and Hogan's feud died down after a brutal steel cage match held at WrestleFest on July 31, 1988 in Milwaukee. He and DiBiase also wrestled Hogan and Randy "Macho Man" Savage in the main event of SummerSlam 1988; the DiBiase-André team lost, despite apparently having referee Jesse "the Body" Ventura on their side.

During the summer and fall of 1988, André also became involved in a heated feud with "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan, and began wrestling Savage for the title.

André's next major feud was against Jake "The Snake" Roberts. In this storyline, it was said André was deathly afraid of snakes, something Roberts exposed on Saturday Night's Main Event when he threw his snake, Damien, on the frightened André; as a result, André suffered a kayfabe mild heart attack and vowed revenge. During the next few weeks, Roberts frequently walked to ringside during André's matches, causing him to run from the ring in fright (since he knew what was inside the bag). Throughout their feud (which culminated at WrestleMania V), Roberts constantly used Damien to gain a psychological edge over the much larger and stronger André.

During the late summer and fall of 1989, André engaged in a brief feud with then-Intercontinental champion The Ultimate Warrior, where the younger Warrior regularly squashed the aging André. Earlier in 1989, André and the returning Big John Studd reprised their feud, this time with Studd as a face and André as the heel.

André won the World Tag Team Championship with his partner Haku (known collectively as The Colossal Connection) from Demolition on December 13, 1989. Managed by Bobby Heenan, they lost their titles at WrestleMania VI back to Demolition on April 1, 1990. After the match, a furious Heenan slapped André; he responded by knocking Heenan out, much to the delight of the fans. André went into the match as a heel, and left as a face.

André continued to make appearances in the WWF throughout 1990 and 1991. His last major appearance was at SummerSlam 1991, where he seconded The Bushwhackers in their match against The Natural Disasters. He also made an appearance later in the year to help The British Bulldog who had just won a Battle Royal in London "Japan-U.S. wrestling summit" held in Tokyo Dome performance offered the tag team of "André the Giant and Giant Baba" on April 13, 1990. The team of "Andre and Baba" semi-won the championship with World's Strongest Tag Team League that All Japan Pro Wrestling had held in 1991.
After that he went back to Japan, this time for All Japan Pro Wrestling, where he briefly teamed with owner Giant Baba. André continued to compete in tag team matches, primarily in Japan and Mexico, until the end of 1992. His last U.S. television appearance was in a brief interview on WCW's "Clash of the Champions XX" special that aired on TBS on September 2, 1992.

The disease that granted him his immense size also began to take its toll on his body. By the late 1980s, André was in constant, near-crippling pain, and his heart struggled to pump blood throughout his massive body. When he was not in front of a camera, he was usually in a wheelchair.

André died in his sleep on January 27, 1993, in a Paris hotel room. He was in Paris to attend the funeral for his father. It was later concluded that he died of congestive heart failure, a by-product of the growth hormone-secreting pituitary tumor he had much of his life and chose not to have treated. His list of accomplishments and Championships (according to Wiki) are as follows:

Championship Wrestling from Florida
NWA Florida Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Dusty Rhodes

International Pro Wrestling
IWA World Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Michael Nader

NWA Tri-State
NWA United States Tag Team Championship (Tri-State version) (1 time) - with Dusty Rhodes

Stampede Wrestling
Stampede Wrestling Hall of Fame[14]

World Championship Wrestling (Australia)
NWA Austra-Asian Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Ron Miller (Final)

World Wrestling Federation
WWF Championship (1 time)
WWF Hall of Fame (Class of 1993)
WWF Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Haku

Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame and Museum
(Class of 2002)

Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI Most Popular Wrestler of the Year (1977, 1982)
PWI Match of the Year (1981) vs. Killer Khan on May 2
PWI Match of the Year (1988) versus Hulk Hogan - The Main Event
PWI Most Hated Wrestler of the Year (1988)
PWI Editor's Award in 1993
PWI ranked him #3 of the 500 best singles wrestlers of the "PWI Years" in 2003.

Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
Feud of the Year (1981) vs. Killer Khan
Most Embarrassing Wrestler (1989)
Worst Feud of the Year (1984) vs. Big John Studd
Worst Feud of the Year (1989) vs. The Ultimate Warrior
Worst Worked Match of the Year (1987) vs. Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania
Worst Worked Match of the Year (1989) vs. The Ultimate Warrior on October 31
Worst Tag Team (1990, 1991) with Giant Baba
Worst Wrestler (1989, 1991, 1992)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame (Class of 1996)

Andre 'The Giant': While Andre was one of the most remembered individuals within the W.W.F., largely in-part due to his feud with Hulk Hogan as well as his massive size, I'm going to be in a big majority here and say I DO NOT feel he belongs in the Hall of Fame. (only with exception)

You see, the reason I feel this way (and this will be a running theme w/ this collection of HoF'ers) because everyone is jumping on the band-wagon of not wanting guys like Eddie Guerrero or Owen Hart into the Hall of Fame, largely because either they felt they didn't do enough, or their death's are all that make them 'famous'. Well, Andre is in the same category.

You take away his size, and he's forgettable. You minus his Hogan feud, and he's forgotten all together.Andre 'The Giant' is nothing more than a side-show that hit it big in the right time of his career, mixed with the huge boost that Pro-Wrestling gained in the 80's. So, while it will largely take a hit (I assume) I disagree that he should be in the Hall of Fame, and believe heavily that if guys like Eddie & Owen aren't to be, then neither should Andre. What are your thoughts and opinions on Andre 'The Giant' being in the Hall of Fame? Worthy or Not?
 
Well yeah of course if you take away his size he's forgettable. If you take away Austin's attitude or Hogan's charisma they're forgettable as well. The Andre that most of us remember is the broken down man that could barely move and put over Hulk Hogan. There's a reason that Andre was selected to be teh guy that put him over: he was the superstar before Hogan. Andre is a prime example of someone that never needed a belt to get over. We look at guys like Taker, Big Show and Khali today and you hear them compared to the same man: Andre. He had the look, the size, he was pretty good in the ring, and you can see it on his face that he loved every second of what he did. Andre was teh reason the HOF was created and there couldn't have been a better choice.
 
Andre deserves to be in, and deserves to be one of the first in, no matter when. He was the first legitimate big man to get over.

Will, how dare you say Andre doesn't deserve to be in because he was in the right place at the right time. You don't think Austin was in the right place at the right time, when 'rebellion against authority' was the big deal, he was WWE's poster guy for it. When they wanted a man with charisma to carry the company, a man called Terry Bollea happened to be there at that point. So cut the crap with timing being the only reason people are in isn't a good reason, because it got a lot of names into it.

Andre did what he did because he loved it. He put over Hogan despite being in agony thanks to his acromegaly. He gave everything to make WWF better because he was one of the few guys who could genuinely get over just by being themselves
 
He deserves to be in it the same amount that 90% or more deserve to be in. He is in it because of his size, his size that caused him to dominate professional wrestling throughout the 70s. He dominated Battle Royals throughout that time, and was able to revolutionize Wrestling. His feud with Hulk Hogan was the greatest early feud of the 80s. He is the building blocks for the creation of big wrestlers such as The Undertaker, Kane, and many others. I have no feelings in me that say that Andre The Giant should not be in the Hall of Fame,t he Hall that was built for him.
 
Andre deserves to be in, and deserves to be one of the first in, no matter when. He was the first legitimate big man to get over.

So you're agreeing that he's only actually credible to the Hall of Fame, merely because he was.. tall, and nothing else. Agreed. Let's add Rhonda Sing (Bertha Faye) next year, because she's really fat. Let's also toss in Hornswoggle in a couple years, cause he's bringing midget's in wrestling back, yeah?

Will, how dare you say Andre doesn't deserve to be in because he was in the right place at the right time.

Well, you kinda said it yourself just a second ago. You said he was the first big man to legitimately get himself over. Because of his size, and size alone. What else did he do? Being tall doesn't usually win you shit. I don't see people jumping on Khali or Big Show's band-wagons these days.. and for the record, they DO have more talent than Andre.

They just weren't "the first" big man.

You don't think Austin was in the right place at the right time, when 'rebellion against authority' was the big deal, he was WWE's poster guy for it.

Actually, Steve Austin was the 'Ringmaster' when guys like Kevin Nash, and Shawn Michaels were beginning to show 'attitude' within the company. But because Steve Austin got the green like to flip people off.. well.. just sayin'...

That's another subject for another thread though.

When they wanted a man with charisma to carry the company, a man called Terry Bollea happened to be there at that point.

And later, guy's like Randy Savage and Dusty Rhodes came in.. but weren't originally around when Hogan first got the chance. Thus, neither Rhodes nor Savage had the opportunity to be what Hogan became.

Both guy's got chances at taking it, but much the same way Big Show will never be Andre.. Savage will never be Hogan. Duplication doesn't work well in most cases.

So cut the crap with timing being the only reason people are in isn't a good reason, because it got a lot of names into it.

A lot of people DON'T deserve to be anywhere near this thing either. But I obviously can't change that. I can, however, voice my feelings on it.

I'm not saying Andre 'The Giant' wasn't important to the company. He was, and he did several things to establish himself as a note-worthy name. Because of that, I might be willing to believe he should be in.. but the main reason they pushed him in.. was because of his height. Which ironically, is the only reason he became famous to begin with.. so...

Andre did what he did because he loved it. He put over Hogan despite being in agony thanks to his acromegaly.

Is it my fault he had a genetic disorder? Is it my fault he decided to willingly enter into a company that would wear on the body even more? Better yet, is it my fault that he agreed to be apart of the side-show act that was his career against Hulk Hogan?

When was Andre ever billed as anything other than a mere "Giant" against Hogan? What's that.. Gonzalez was a bigger Giant against the Undertaker, I haven't seen his name mentioned in the H.o.F. category yet.

He gave everything to make WWF better because he was one of the few guys who could genuinely get over just by being themselves

Hornswoggle is over because he's a midget. Zach Gowen technically got over by having only one leg. So you're more or less putting the both of them in the same category with Andre.

I personally can't wait to see what Gowen's acceptance speech might be. I mean, you know, since we're adding side-show attractions and everything now.
 
So you're agreeing that he's only actually credible to the Hall of Fame, merely because he was.. tall, and nothing else. Agreed. Let's add Rhonda Sing (Bertha Faye) next year, because she's really fat. Let's also toss in Hornswoggle in a couple years, cause he's bringing midget's in wrestling back, yeah?

Well, you kinda said it yourself just a second ago. You said he was the first big man to legitimately get himself over. Because of his size, and size alone. What else did he do? Being tall doesn't usually win you shit. I don't see people jumping on Khali or Big Show's band-wagons these days.. and for the record, they DO have more talent than Andre.

They just weren't "the first" big man.[/QUOTE]

And why do you think that is Will. Why aren't Khali and Mark Henry viewed as future Hall of Famers? Could it be because bother have the personality of a wet sponge? Andre was likeable and marketable as a big man. If you're going to claim he was only in the HOF because of Hogan, what made him special enough that he became the highest paid wrestler in the world in 1973? Wasn't that 14 years before the Hogan bodyslam?

Actually, Steve Austin was the 'Ringmaster' when guys like Kevin Nash, and Shawn Michaels were beginning to show 'attitude' within the company. But because Steve Austin got the green light to flip people off.. well.. just sayin'...

That's another subject for another thread though.

So because Austin was in the right place and managed to secure what he needed, that means he's irrelevant to the discussion? Besides, as I recall Michaels' attitude was misplaced and more ego than attitude.

And later, guy's like Randy Savage and Dusty Rhodes came in.. but weren't originally around when Hogan first got the chance. Thus, neither Rhodes nor Savage had the opportunity to be what Hogan became.

Both guy's got chances at taking it, but much the same way Big Show will never be Andre.. Savage will never be Hogan. Duplication doesn't work well in most cases.

Indeed, and both men were more than successful at getting over and did their jobs very very well... but as I pointed out, it was Hogan was there when WWF needed the poster boy.

A lot of people DON'T deserve to be anywhere near this thing either. But I obviously can't change that. I can, however, voice my feelings on it.

Very true, I'd just be of the opinion Andre is one of the few who deserves it.

I'm not saying Andre 'The Giant' wasn't important to the company. He was, and he did several things to establish himself as a note-worthy name. Because of that, I might be willing to believe he should be in.. but the main reason they pushed him in.. was because of his height. Which ironically, is the only reason he became famous to begin with.. so...

Oh no... A guy is pushed because he happens to be marketable. Whatever will become of the world. In ordinary cases though, most will only be pushed for a short time on an aspect... Andre was pushed for over 15 years on that fact. Let's contrast with a man you're about to name. Giant Gonzalez - the man was huge and marketed for literally a few months. Why? Because Andre had the ability to keep the fans wanting him. Same with Viscera, Mark Henry etc.

Is it my fault he had a genetic disorder? Is it my fault he decided to willingly enter into a company that would wear on the body even more? Better yet, is it my fault that he agreed to be apart of the side-show act that was his career against Hulk Hogan?

When was Andre ever billed as anything other than a mere "Giant" against Hogan? What's that.. Gonzalez was a bigger Giant against the Undertaker, I haven't seen his name mentioned in the H.o.F. category yet.
See my previous point regarding Gonzalez. You want proof that size doesn't matter... there it is.

As for Hogan, he was put over in the twilight of Andre's career. What else did he really have to do other than end the 15 year unpinned streak he held in WWF. I believe that says something about the man. To go out saying you'd NEVER been pinned in the biggest company of them all would have been the ultimate claim, but he gave it up to add to Hogan's legend. Face it, Andre being slammed is THE moment people remember about Hogan.

Hornswoggle is over because he's a midget. Zach Gowen technically got over by having only one leg. So you're more or less putting the both of them in the same category with Andre.

I personally can't wait to see what Gowen's acceptance speech might be. I mean, you know, since we're adding side-show attractions and everything now.

When they're over for 15 years, then we'll talk.

Will, you paint Andre as a one trick pony whose only moment was responsible for putting Hogan over, but the fact is that when you remain on top for so long, beating names like Hogan, Warrior, Roberts, Studd, you can deserve to be called a Hall of Famer. Now...when WWF felt the need to create the HOF, who exactly did they choose to create it for? Was it coincidental that it was in the year Andre died?
 
I don't see people jumping on Khali or Big Show's band-wagons these days.. and for the record, they DO have more talent than Andre.

I agree with mostly everything you said in your post except this particular part. The Great Khali isn't more talented than Andre The Giant, maybe more talented if you consider Andre when he was really suffering at the end of his career, but come on, even then Andre the Giant put on exciting matches. There is no way that Khali is more talented than Andre.

The Big Show in his prime back in WCW was definitely one of the most talented big men in wrestling history. The guy was incredibly powerful and unbelievably agile for his size. I mean the guy did a missile dropkick from the top rope on Roadblock on an episode of Nitro from 96 or 97. I guess I might agree with you on the point that The Big Show, in his prime, was a bit more more physically talented, but that leaves other areas that one would have to compare the two in.

The big problem I see on forums is that people tend to forget that Andre existed before his feud with Hogan or before the 80s. All one has to do is check the videos of Andre on youtube when he was a young man in the 70s to see what a great worker he was. The man knew how to wrestle, and could easily maneuver himself around the ring, even resorting to submission holds. There is a great set of videos posted on youtube just recently, where Andre the Giant battles Antonio Inoki from 1976. I would implore anyone that remembers Andre as the slow heel of the late 80s to watch this match.

Oh yeah, questioning whether or not Andre the Giant deserves to be in the WWE Hall of Fame is laughable. He is the perfect example of a Legend. It isn't right to simply look at him for his size, one has to look at his character, the man himself. He was very important to the world of wrestling, and helped carry it for many years. God knows where wrestling would be now without him. He was huge all around the world for as long as he was wrestling. Whether heel or face, the guy has battled or teamed with men who we would call legends today in all parts of the world.
 
The Big Slow and Kahli more talented?? Hardly. I invite you to veiw the Hulk Hogan anthology. There is a VERY old match on their with a young Andre coming off the top rope, and throwing around drop kicks. and this was at somewere in the neighborhood of 7'5" of 7'6". All anyone seems to remember these days was the broken down slothfull Andre from WMs 3, 4, and 5. To be honest folks, do some fucking research, for goodness sakes. He was at about 10% of his true preforming capacity at that time, I assure you. Andre is THE transcendant big man, and Icon of our sport. There is a reason a reported nearly 100,000 people came together to watch WM 3 under one roof. It sure a fuck wasnt to see Steamboat Vs Savage. It was to see Hulk Hogan Vs Andre the Giant. The 8th wonder of the world bitches.
 
YES

I'm almost shocked to see a "No" vote up there. Andre might not have belonged as the first Hall of Famer, but he deserves his spot. He was great in the ring, no matter what size he was. From what I've heard, he was alegendary face, and from what I remember, he was a damned good heel. Take out his match at Wrestlemania 3, and he still had a great career. It's a shame that he only had 1 title run, but this was also at a time when faces ruled the world, and held every title. Like NorCal said, he was the man chosen to put over Hogan, because to be "the man", you need to beat "the man".
 
God, this isn't even a debate. Will, man, he was only famous because of his size, really? Why are guys like Khali and Big show employeed, because of size. Why was a guy like the Undertaker given a character like Death, because if you put it on Hornswoggle it looks silly. Discrediting a wrestler for his size is like trying to discredit Shaquille O'Neil and his ability to slam dunk, it's just silly.

Andre was the mega draw of the 70's and early 80's. Sure, Graham and otehrs were teh champion, but Andre simply put, was bigger then the Belt. People paid to see Andre the Giant in droves. The guy was massively over, and contrary to what the Wrestlemania Era of Andre shows you, the guy could work like crazy in the ring. This is just silly, the Hall of Fame was built around the legacy of Andre the Giant.
 
TheOneBigWill said:
You take away his size, and he's forgettable. You minus his Hogan feud, and he's forgotten all together.

Yeah, but he had both of those things. It doesn't matter what you COULD take away, all that matters is what he had. His feud with Hogan is iconic, a "Wrestlemania moment" as they say. You need to remember that this isn't the Hall of Achievements. This is the Hall of Fame.
And Andre is pretty damn famous.
 
Who were the two sad souls who voted "no"? Jeez, some people need a history lesson in the sport of pro wrestling. Of course Andre deserves it, even if you discounted his WWF stuff, he has done tons of great things in the NWA and Japan that would allow him entry into the REAL pro wrestling HOF, nevermind the WWE HOF.
 
This is my opinion about Andre:
1.Undefeated for 15 years
2.Former WWE champion
3.Had one of the most historic match in wrestling history against Hulk Hogan at WM III
4.First wrestler to help WWF get into the main stream
5.First giant in pro wrestling

Andre Should be in the HoF:worship:
 
I vote him in. His size is what made him a household name, yes. But his popularity stems much further than his wrestling. Everyone knows about the "OBEY GIANT" poster with Andre's liking and for his role in "The Princess Bride". I do admit to seeing that movie, but still. Everyone knew him as a gentle giant, even after the feud with Hogan.
 
I can see the argument against it but I am all for the induction of Owen and Eddie. I think they both worked their asses off for the WWE in spite of health issues, much like Andre and to show that level of dedication to your craft warrants a HoF position to me.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,826
Messages
3,300,735
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top