A Few Thoughts On Jeff Hardy's Impending Return

Jack-Hammer

YOU WILL RESPECT MY AUTHORITAH!!!!
As we all know, via Twitter, Jeff Hardy intends to return to TNA in the very near future. Some probably think it's a good idea, some think it's a bad idea and some are probably not really sure where they stand at the moment.

Like a lot of others, I've criticized Jeff Hardy for decisions that he's made in his life. Not that my opinion or the opinion of anyone else on these forums means anything to Jeff Hardy, but the criticisms have been valid in my view. We all know about his problems with drugs, his legal troubles, the noticable downturn in the quality of his work, etc. So when it comes to the idea of Jeff Hardy returning at this point in time, there are some factors to consider I think.

One big factor to consider will be exactly how TNA plays this. They might wind up having Jeff Hardy simply return as if he's just been gone for a while and completely ignore what happened. They can go that route if they want to but nobody is simply going to buy into it. Hardy's problems have grown to the point that TNA is no longer simply able to sweep them under the rug.

Another way they can go could involve the use of Hardy's problems as part of a storyline to build him up as a sympathetic babyface. This could be a potentially intriguing idea or it can be a train wreck that blows up in both the face of TNA and Jeff Hardy. Hardy's problems are nothing to be made light of and IF they do decide to go the storyline route, I think they need to treat the subject with a degree of serious sobriety, no pun is intended. If they do the storyline, do it with some class and some degree of respect and not like something we'd see on your typical episode of Jerry Springer. I'd rather they just tried to ignore the whole thing and go about business as usual instead of doing that crap.

As for Jeff Hardy returning himself, I'm personally very skeptical at this time. Based on what we've been able to find out, which isn't everything of course as we're just fans on the internet, I haven't really seen or heard anything to suggest that Jeff Hardy has gotten his head together. His legal troubles are still hanging over his head, there have been questions regarding his sobriety and all kinds of rumors while he's been out, he's done some outright stupid things like that video he put up on the net with his brother Matt in which they used a taser on that chick, etc. I might be wrong and Hardy may have had some sort of breakthrough on a personal level that we're not aware of and that's what I'm hoping.

For me though, I'd be more into the idea of getting behind and supporting Jeff Hardy and his return IF I knew that he had turned things around. This might sound extremely strange and even a little stupid in the minds of some, and I can accept that, but it doesn't seem like Hardy has really accepted responsibility for his actions. I'd be less skeptical if Hardy had gone through some extensive drug treatment programs before returning to TNA. That would at least show that he's making some sort of an effort to get his life back together.

Now the part that might sound stupid to some is that maybe a little jail time would be beneficial for him as well. I know that Hardy's lawyers have been going back and forth with the D.A. in the case about Hardy going into treatment rather than serving some jail time. Hey, I get that. I totally get that. I work as a Corrections Officer and being incarcerated is not a pleasant thought. At the same time though, it would suggest, again, that Jeff Hardy is making a serious attempt to take responsibility for what he's done and to get himself back on course. The American Judicial System is flawed, no doubt, but I've honestly seen some people with similar problems as Hardy get their head on straight after being in the joint for a while.

Again, I'm just going by what I personally know about Hardy's situation, which probably isn't anymore than most of anyone on these forums know. Also, again, I know that my opinion doesn't mean squat to Jeff Hardy and that's completely understandable. At the same time, I don't think it necessarily invalidates anything that I said.
 
There are ways to use what happened at Victory Road without condoning it, and they need to find that balance. Much like the Montreal Screwjob for the WWE, what happened at Victory Road was a horrible but also signature moment in TNA's history. It brought them more mainstream attention than probably anything else. To not try and use that in some way would be bad business.

I proposed in a recent thread that Hardy should return as an ally for Sting (at the time I said Jeff and Matt, but things have obviously changed). Have Sting once again bringing the fight to Immortal but getting ganged up on. Lights go out... and they come back to Hardy in the ring with a black bat! Maybe even given him a new facepaint design that is similar, though still unique, to Sting's.

The story could be that Sting went and found Hardy after Victory Road and after Immortal had thrown him under the bus. He's been helping him "clean up" and prepare to strike back at the people who twisted, used, and abandoned him. Sting and Hardy now fight together to bring down Immortal, no doubt teaming up with Anderson and maybe Abyss at some point for a final battle.

I think this would be the best way to handle it. People either want to cheer for Jeff or are indifferent to him, so why fight it? I thought the heel turn was a good move, but it's not going to work with today's wrestling crowd. Ultimately you can only do so much to shape fan reaction. Sometimes you just have to go with what they give you, and in Hardy's case it's that he's someone they want to cheer for.
 
I'm with Rasha on this — Hardy's return is obviously happening as the show was already taped, but how it's handled matters most here. Simply ignoring what happened at Victory Road as though it never happened and trying to re-inject Jeff into the heel character he left as would be a monumental failure on TNA's part.

He needs to return as a baby face and he needs to beg for the fans' forgiveness. It's the only way to get him over again. Fans love to love Jeff Hardy, but they probably feel betrayed at the moment, which suffice it to say could obviously be rectified with some groveling and apologetic sentiments from Jeff himself... preferably live, and not taped or via satellite.

For the record, I love the idea of having Sting help him and I love the idea of using Hardy as a returning strike against his former group to help disband it, probably along with Abyss, another soon-to-be-ex-founding member.
 
Well its definitely probably the best possible solution to have Sting be the one who brings Hardy in and shows him "the way" so to speak. Besides Sting is crazy these days much like Hardy and both have a reason to get into it with Hogan at this point. Sting already wants Hogan and Hardy will want revenge for Hogan twisting and turning him into something he is not.

I'll be honest I could care less that Jeff Hardy is coming back, I just always felt he was the definition of overrated (just my opinion).

They are obviously going to bring him in as a baby face and for my taste he at this point has to earn the fan's respect again if he is gonna get over as a baby face again. It can be done and feel eventually he will get the fans forgiveness and will win them back. He will need to admit his mistake and make amends with the fans first and foremost, as IDR puts it "beg for the fans' forgiveness". If he does that, returns as the Jeff Hardy the fans know and love and works hard I have no doubt he will make the turn and be accepted again.

Even though I don't like Hardy you cannot deny his popularity and the fact there are MANY Jeff Hardy fans out there. Hopefully it pans out for Hardy and TNA so everyone wins.
 
I proposed in a recent thread that Hardy should return as an ally for Sting (at the time I said Jeff and Matt, but things have obviously changed). Have Sting once again bringing the fight to Immortal but getting ganged up on. Lights go out... and they come back to Hardy in the ring with a black bat! Maybe even given him a new facepaint design that is similar, though still unique, to Sting's.

The story could be that Sting went and found Hardy after Victory Road and after Immortal had thrown him under the bus. He's been helping him "clean up" and prepare to strike back at the people who twisted, used, and abandoned him. Sting and Hardy now fight together to bring down Immortal, no doubt teaming up with Anderson and maybe Abyss at some point for a final battle.

This actually seems as a good idea. It would make sense and it would provide some continuity from what had happened at VR. It also would allow Hardy to say that he is sorry, he made mistake etc, and apologize to the fans.

However, we are talking about Russo and TNA. They really don't care about sense and continuity. So, even though I like the above idea, I think that Hardy will returns as nothing has really happen, as if he had some injury or something like this.
 
Why should Hardy return at all??? He could have really injured himself and sting at victory road!!!! Jeff has had chance after chance after chance!! As far as im concerned he's burned his bridges i understand giving a guy a break but after awhile come on enough is enough!! He completely shitted on the business his opponent sting who is an icon shitted on hogan eazy e the fans he didnt care!! Remember all jeff likes is living for the moment!!! I do wanna believe in Jeff i do but i dont think its gonna work out for him!!!
 
However, we are talking about Russo and TNA. They really don't care about sense and continuity. So, even though I like the above idea, I think that Hardy will returns as nothing has really happen, as if he had some injury or something like this.

Unfortunately, I am going to have to agree with this. Russo has never given a rats ass about someone's personal problems and has shown (Hall's alcoholism) that he will use someone dependency on something in a storyline for ratings.

I don't expect anything to change and I really don't see this as Hardy's rock-bottom moment in terms of his drug use. He'll come in as usual and go about his business like nothing happened.
 
I'm really interested in Jeff's comeback and intrigued on how it plays out. Jeff needs to come out and cut a Live promo and talk about the mistake he made at VR and ask for forgivness but he also has to earn it. Jeff is Very Popular and he has a pretty large fanbase and could be a big help to TNA in selling merchandise and tickets. There is very little doubt in mind that if Jeff talks about what happened and ask for forgiveness that he will get it from the fans and they will want to give him another chance. I think that this could be pretty good story of Redemption for Hardy.
 
PR 101- Don't dwell on a bad incident any longer than you have to. Anyone who has ever paid attention to politics understands that you can drive a girl off of a bridge while drunk, flee the scene, lie to investigators, and still be a multi-term senator, just so long as you don't dwell on the incident.

Professional wrestling is slightly different, as you're constantly trying to attract both positive and negative attention, but there are still boundaries. There is no way to approach a "Jeff's recovery" angle without reminding people of just how fucked up Victory Road was. TNA/IW does not need that kind of publicity; Victory Road was one of the worst debacles in company history.

On the other hand, TNA/IW's fans aren't complete idiots. Anyone who's got internet access and watches their show knows what happened at Victory Road. For TNA/IW to not even mention it and act as if it never happened would come across as a fairly extreme act of bullshitting. Something has to be said.

Which is why I expect very oblique references to Jeff's time off. I expect the announcers to refer to "Jeff's troubles over the past few months", without going into any detail. You won't get an "I'm so sorry" speech from Jeff. You'll probably get a lot of "you had your chance and blew it" from Hulk + Eric; I don't expect them to completely drop the Immortal thread with him. But don't expect his time off to become part of a story. TNA/IW doesn't want to focus people on the past- unless they're talking about Batman movies and hot WCW feuds from the '90s- they want to focus on the future.

All of this, of course, assumes TNA/IW goes by the well-read Book of Public Relations, and they aren't exactly famous for doing that with people not surnamed Angle.
 
I proposed in a recent thread that Hardy should return as an ally for Sting (at the time I said Jeff and Matt, but things have obviously changed). Have Sting once again bringing the fight to Immortal but getting ganged up on. Lights go out... and they come back to Hardy in the ring with a black bat! Maybe even given him a new facepaint design that is similar, though still unique, to Sting's.

The story could be that Sting went and found Hardy after Victory Road and after Immortal had thrown him under the bus. He's been helping him "clean up" and prepare to strike back at the people who twisted, used, and abandoned him. Sting and Hardy now fight together to bring down Immortal, no doubt teaming up with Anderson and maybe Abyss at some point for a final battle.

I think this could be a good way to handle it. Sting was visibly angry with Hardy on camera at the PPV, and they could say that he went to find Hardy after Immortal kicked him out and saw a man with severe troubles, and decided to help him get his head right.

Hardy would need to address these issues on camera and apologise to the fans though, as TNA cannot just ignore what happened, and bring Hardy back as some kind of triumphant return pretending he never fucked up a PPV by being drugged to the eyeballs.

It's a very big decision for TNA, this. Get it wrong and it could be disasterous. They surely cannot try and pretend it didnt happen, it would be a huge insult to the fans. There is the issue of whether Hardy is a face or a heel. I am unsure of the reaction he will get. There are some who will cheer him as they just love Jeff Hardy no matter what, but there are others who know about his drug issues and showing up in no condition to work, and may resent him.

I personally think Jeff needs to be a face, even though I was loving his heel persona. Most fans WANT to like him, and as long as TNA don't just make up a story like he was "taking a break" or "recovering from losing the belt" etc, and actually have Jeff apologise and admit that he fucked up, and ask for forgiveness, the majority of fans will give it to him, and if his in-ring work is of a high standard it could be used as a "feel-good story" with Hardy attempting to get back to his former glory and the title.

That is, if Jeff IS actually clean. Knowing Hardy, as soon as he cut that apologetic promo he could go to his car and smoke some crack. I really hope that he is clean, but I can't honestly say I believe he is. I haven't seen much evidence of it, but maybe he is just keeping it out of the public eye.

Jeff Hardy, if he is clean, heathy and sound of mind, still has something to offer. A druggie Hardy on the other hand, does not. I hope we get the former. The little kid in me wants to see him better and succeed.
 
(Big fat fucking spoiler redacted)

If your a wikipedia fan like me you would know something already about the storyline which is he is going the im sorry and ima do better for my fans route
And if you read the stickied "NO SPOILERS ALLOWED - NO EXCEPTIONS" thread at the top, you would know already that this board has a policy towards not revealing anything televised until it had aired. Save the "but the main page" line- "NO EXCEPTIONS" is pretty clear, although a lot of people seem to think it doesn't apply to them because they had a good reason.

Great, you're a wikipedia fan. You're also a tard who just spoiled this for anyone who'd rather watch it first from TNA/IW.
 
***Completely ignoring the above spoiler...Tool***​


I think that the best option for jeff would be to acknowledge his past and history for what I believe to be the first time, and ask that we (the fans) let him move on from it. Ask for forgiveness, and leave it at that. Then, over the next few iMPACT broadcasts, basically play the straight man, classic babyface style, break no rules, shake the guy's hand before every match, things of that nature.
After a few run-in saves of Fortune members and assorted other Babyfaces, he comes face-to-face with Sting. Stinger grabs a mic, and tells Hardy that he approves of what he's been doing, but he still has some miles left to go.
This leaves Hardy with a mission, endear himself with Sting so that they can both fight against Immortal together.

***Please, don't let the above spoiler ruin this thread, it was going really well, and it doesn't have to die because of some loose-lipped Schmuck***
 
I just hope he doesn't screw it up again. He is a phenomenal talent who has had countless opportunities only to be destroyed by drugs. Who knows, if he had given up drugs a few years back, he could of been one of WWE's top guys by now but i guess we'll never know. If Jeff can get his life sorted and prove to everyone he is a changed man, who knows what the future holds for him
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,834
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top